6

In Aladdin (2019), by rewinding, Genie reminds Aladdin that he already used his first wish to get out of the cave but Aladdin argues that it didn't count as his wish.

How did Aladdin trick Genie inside the cave ?

  • 1
    @Valorum I took the liberty of just editing that in. – SQB Jan 28 at 10:49
  • 1
    Aladdin (the 1992 animated film) is one of my favorite movies and this is my biggest point of frustration with it. You asked about the 2019 version, but the concept is the same. Genie is supposedly bound by the laws of magic which place djinn at the command of their human masters. Djinn are presumably limited in many ways, otherwise they could use their magic to manipulate humans and, presumably, free themselves. If the Genie is able to cast wish-level spells (as opposed to what must have been visual tricks for his "friend like me" song) without being ordered to by a human, it breaks the rules – Brian R Jan 28 at 20:48
15

He didn't rub the lamp.

Distracted by his own lighter-than-desired shade of blue, the Genie didn’t notice as Aladdin deftly slipped the lamp out of his hands and into the outstretched hand of Abu. With the lamp safely out of his hands, he nodded. “Genie,” he said, “I wish you to get us out of this cave.”

...

“I’ll do it,” Aladdin said, cutting him off. “I’ve got three, right?”

“Two—” the Genie corrected. “You already used one.”

Aladdin raised an eyebrow, a mischievous smile tugging at his lips. “Did I?” he said. “Or did you? Thought I had to rub the lamp.”

Aladdin - Official Novelisation.

enter image description here

2

It's essentially the same trick as the animated film. Aladdin challenges Genie's pride, Genie gets them out of the cave voluntarily to prove that he can. Aladdin successfully argues that he never actually asks Genie to do so, so it's not a wish.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.