3

Thinking back on it now, it makes little sense; Adora was the Princess of Eternia, the kingdom if not the planet itself. And in various flashbacks, the Sorceress says that the Horde tried to invade Eternia as they had countless other planets, but "they were no match for your father's brave soldiers, and the magic of Castle Greyskull". You can see it here:

Hordack himself even says "You may have defeated us, but you'll never see this child again!" when he escapes to Etheria, and later in the Secret of the Sword film says "The Horde has no more interest in this world!" [likely because they got their asses handed to them!]

Considering the Horde is purported to be a galaxy-spanning empire, Eternia must be one TOUGH ass planet of Badasses to have them just straight "Nope!" off the planet and never return!

But then.... why didn't the Eternian Army come to aid their Princess in a rebellion she was a part of for years?

I mean obvious separation of the series aside.... wouldn't that have ended the war sooner?

Think about it:

  • The Eternian Army---- not even the PLANET-wide army, just (it seems) those under King Randor---- were more than a match for the Horde. So they had an established success against the evil forces already.
  • Even if they wouldn't have Grayskull's magic on their side this time, they would still have the Crystal castle, or at least the Kingdoms of Bright Moon and its allies like Spike-Heart. So magically, they should be covered.
  • They had adequate reason to join the fight, as the Horde had kept their Princess as a POW for at least 18 years! Even if they want to claim that a whole other planet is somewhat "out of their jurisdiction," as a foreign power, they can offer aid to a friendly kingdom under siege from a common enemy. Adora's imprisonment, as a War Crime, would be justification enough for them sending troops or supplies as aid to the Etherian realms as a means of support. Not only would they be protecting their interest (Adora) they could argue being "pulled" into the conflict due to "previous aggressive actions against the kingdom of Eternia" by the Horde.

And its not as if they were engaged in any other serious conflict; Skeletor was a continuous threat, yes,but not one the army is called in to do with. His villainous band is more of a "Terrorist cell" trying to make incursions into the kingdom, not on the same scale as full other nation waging endless battle. Sending troops to aid the Rebellion as a means of assuring Adora's safety seems logical.

And yeah, the Rebellion was going on for years, even if we presume it only started a few months back before or right at the beginning of Secret of the Sword. This to makes sense, as by that time Angella had been captured, Adora had been raised on the planet as a trained and established Force Captain, and a good portion of Etheria had been under Horde rule and taxation for years. This had been made worse by an apparent "time skip" that had occurred between seasons 1 and 2, a time skip made clear by the life of General Sundar.

The Rebellion ran into Sundar in season 1, and they'd been fighting alongside She-Ra for some time by then. Adora had been with the Rebellion as one of their co-leaders after Secret in season 1, before Sundar had switched sides; when Sundar returned in season 2, Adora was almost Completely in charge of the Rebellion by then, and Sundar and Mally had a daughter who was at least 3 or 4 years old. If the war had been continuing through All that time, then that's most likely 5 years of battle with the Horde!

Granted, time probably moves differently on Eternia and Etheria, but it's still a long period for a Princess to be at risk and a king of a relatively peaceful nation to not offer any support.

I know there was a post-2000s comic which may have gone into details [have no clue, honestly], but is there any canon reason why no suggestion of aid was given?

  • It's been quite a while since I've seen those, but wasn't portal between worlds erratic or even permanently closed by the end of the cross-over movie? – Michael Richardson Feb 4 at 18:16
  • @MichaelRichardson Not at all! In fact, it was used multiple times to pull He-Man over to give She-Ra some aid. Those portals went through castle Greyskull, though, and usually only sent a few people at a time. However, there was nothing that said the sorceress Couldn't open a bigger gate to send a few Eternian battalions through. – Russhiro Feb 4 at 19:47
  • 1
    The Etheria of the early Horde comic books is not the same as the Etheria of She-ra. Etheria portals were considered erratic originally - but not in the filmation universe. – lucasbachmann Feb 5 at 18:30
  • @lucasbachmann Okay, viable.... but then, after it was shown in cartoon that stable portals could be made basically at whim (remember, the Sorceress said "should you ever wish to return, just call me through the sword,") ... why didn't that become a viable option at that point? – Russhiro Feb 5 at 18:40
1

No aid is probably not accurate. Covert aid is suggested as there were a few episodes with He-man and Orko helping on Etheria. In-universe perhaps a covert resistance was preferred over actual war because the Horde was merely being oppressive at that point.

  • Hmmm... i agree that He-Man assited the Rebellion on numerous occasions, but they were still fighting to Free Etheria from the Horde's Cluthes. you do make a point in so much that, by the end of season 1, it was more of a "standstill battle" than a constant war; many kingdoms, including Brightmoon, more or less went about their business, and it was other Horde-occupied spaces (Thamore village, Beast Island or the badlands), which were under constant horde rule. But again, if an Eternian force could drive the horde off world once...why not just do it again, especially to protect Adora? – Russhiro Feb 4 at 19:51
  • Well as I recall there was a point where King Randor was so furious with Skeletor he was going to wipe Snake Mountain off the map and then backed off. In-universe they seem to prefer containment over decisive victory. – lucasbachmann Feb 5 at 18:47
  • Again, you make a point...but I think it had more to do with the immediate severity of the threat, than "containment." Skeletor could be likened to a dangerous Crime Lord or Mafia boss; yes, a constant, ever present threat, but he doesn't literally own the city or people. Given relative scale, they could be left to the Police. Da Horde by contrast, are a major invasion/occupation force, like unto the Nazi Army in WWII. If America = Eternia, and Etheria= Europe, then the equivalent action would be sending Battalions, not a Police force, into the fray to stop the actual warring. – Russhiro Feb 5 at 19:01
1

Firstly, regarding your statement, I do not believe time runs differently between Eternia and Etheria, at least per the Filmation series continuity. I will stick with the Filmation continuity as that is the most well known.

The likely answer here is probably a combination of factors, but mostly (1) offensive capabilities, (2) resources, and (3) accessibility.

You state that the Eternian guard was able to defend Eternia from the Horde. This event takes place in Eternia, which means the Eternians were defending. If they took the battle to the Horde on Etheria, the Horde would be on the defense and the army roles would be switched. Perhaps Eternians are better at defense than offense; consider the majority of the rest of Eternia is presented as a wild land of crazy untamed mystical chaos, and divided fiefdoms which do not necessarily bow to King Randor. If the Eternians were capable offensively, they'd have a better handle on their own home turf, but they do not. This demonstrates they are better at defense than offense.

Consider that on Eternia the entire army was available; Randor needs to also maintain Eternia while fighting a war in another dimension; he could not possibly send his entire army on an offensive mission to Etheria while simultaneously defending Eternia.

Regarding accessibility, Etheria is another planet/dimension/galaxy; one that isn't accessed till the movie special, and afterwards this access isn't overly abused, meaning it may require special circumstances. Perhaps the resources needed to move an army to the dimension of Etheria (and eventually back), including ongoing supplies, is not a viable proposition.

These are three rationale examples why Randor might not have sent his army.

  • Interesting Argument! I may need to post multiple replies to cover all of them, but here goes: 1.The time theory is speculative. We don;t really see characters "grow" in either show, but Sundar's family_mis a big indicator that a lot of time has passed on Etheria. Adora swore to her parents she wouldn't come back to Eternia _until Etheria was freed. but it's hard to think Randor would go years without seeing his daughter/knowing she's in danger, even for a good cause, and do nothing to help her in any significant way. Hence why time may be "perceived" differently on the two worlds – Russhiro Feb 7 at 16:01
  • Adam and Adora are twins. If time passed differently between dimensions, Adora would be presented as significantly older than Adam. Your focus on Sundar's family is noted - perhaps the simplest answer is correct: lot of time passes between the two episodes in question. – JoshDM Feb 7 at 16:18
  • 2. You may have a point about Eternia's stronger defense than offense. While both planets are full of magic, Lou Schieffer wanted Eteria to be more rugged and dangerous to fit with He-man's aesthetic; Etheria, by contrast, was more a land of beauty and wonder. He-Man also had a more "sci-fi" feel, which is why there was so much "tech being used wisely" in his adventures; it made a lot of Eternia able to be accessed. She-Ra's were more about magic. So while the Eter-army would lose the planets natural protection, they'd still have advantages in numbers, tactics, and with Duncan's hardware. – Russhiro Feb 7 at 17:09
  • Yes, Adam and Adora are twins, but i'm speaking more here of length of years than actual aging. And keep in mind that Adora is a half human Eternian born; she wouldn't necessarily be affected the same way other Etherian's are. you ever notice how more naturally agile she is than even other trained Etherians, even without her powers? That could be down to her past horde training, but seems like natural gifts. Also, Etheria is another planet somehwere outside of Eternian space (which is said to be at the very center of the universe); its never said to be another "Dimension". – Russhiro Feb 7 at 17:13
  • 1
    Modern is Netflix; Legacy would be Filmation. – JoshDM Feb 7 at 20:15

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.