4

In Star Trek: First Contact, Picard and Worf have an argument leading to Picard calling Worf a coward. After he comes to his senses, he says:

Picard: Mr Worf, I regret some of the things I said...

Mr Worf isn't too pleased, and Picard makes a noncommittal backtrack, saying that Worf is the bravest person he's ever met. However, that "some" seemed to bother Worf.

What did Picard mean, and what did he not regret?

  • 1
    I don't mind downvotes if they can help me to improve the question, but downvotes without comments don't help much. Can the downvoter please explain what the issue was and how I can improve the question? – Michael Stachowsky Feb 5 at 15:53
  • I believe it's just colloquial to say "some of the things". To say "I regret (all of) the things I said" might imply that every single statement he made recently was regrettable, and certainly accusing Worf of being a coward isn't the only thing he's said in the recent past. – ThePopMachine Feb 5 at 17:15
  • I think that's just a way to Picard to say he regrets calling Worf a coward without having to repeat exactly what he said, as doing that would almost be like repeating the accusation. – Paul D. Waite Feb 6 at 10:49
7

Picard can be arrogant, and doesn't even notice.

Here's the transcript of the relevant part of the scene:

[Enterprise-E bridge]

CRUSHER: So much for the Enterprise-E.
PICARD: We barely knew her.
CRUSHER: Think they'll build another one?
PICARD: Plenty of letters left in the alphabet. ...Mister Worf. I regret some of the things I said to you earlier.
WORF: Some?
PICARD: As a matter of fact I think you're the bravest man I have ever known.
WORF: Thank you, sir.
PICARD: See you on Gravett Island.

Here is the video on youtube

To me, it's a rather obvious example where the arrogant side of his is coming out: He rather downplays the impact and magnitude of his words, and Worf calls him out on it.

Because if there is one negative thing that we can say about Picard, then that at some times, his pride, or arrogance, gets in his way. And this is one of the times. In fact, you could argue that it's his own pride (in always doing The Right Thing) that blinds him to the fact that he is acting out of vengeance, and not rationally, during this exchange in the same movie:

LILY: Jean-Luc, blow up the damn ship!
PICARD: No! ...No!
(Picard breaks the starship display cabinet with his phaser rifle)
PICARD: No! ...I will not sacrifice the Enterprise. We've made too many compromises already. Too many retreats. They invade our space and we fall back. They assimilate entire worlds, and we fall back. Not again! The line must be drawn here, ...this far, no further! And I will make them pay for what they've done.
LILY: You broke your little ships. ...See you around, Ahab.

This is not something invented for the movie, though. This is discussed in Star Trek Picard between him and Admiral Clancy. Even though we, as the audience, are obviously on Picard's side, we can see how Clancy perceives him:

Picard: The Federation does not get to decide if a species lives or dies!
Clancy: Yes we do. We absolutely do. Thousands of other species depend upon us for unity, for cohesion. We didn't have enough ships left. We had to make choices, but the great Captain Picard didn't like his orders.

Now, you could still argue that Picard is right, Clancy is wrong, therefore what she perceives as arrogance is in fact being noble.

But there are several other occurences where Picard is arrogant and doesn't even notice it. Just remember how blind he was to Wesley's obvious talent, just because he didn't like him on the bridge, in Encounter at Farpoint:

(Wesley steps onto the Bridge)
PICARD: But don't touch anything! Try it out. (the captain's chair) The panel on your right is for log entries, library computer access and retrieval, viewscreen control, intercoms, and so on. Here we have
WESLEY: And here, the backup conn and ops panels, plus shield and armoury controls.
PICARD: The forward viewscreen is controlled from the ops position there
WESLEY: Which uses high resolution, multi-spectral imaging sensor systems
PICARD: How the hell do you know that, boy?
WESLEY: Perimeter alert, Captain!
CRUSHER: Wesley!
WESLEY: I'm sorry.
CRUSHER: You shouldn't have touched anything
PICARD: Off the bridge! Both of you.
WORF: You have a perimeter alert, sir.
CRUSHER: As my son tried to tell you!
(Crusher and Wesley step back into the turbolift)

Perhaps the most intimate insight into the negative traits of his personality, as perceived by others, can be seen in TNG's Episode "Family", where his nephew tells him how his father thinks about Picard:

RENE: Why have you been away so long?
PICARD: Well, Starfleet keeps me very busy.
RENE: Father says you don't like it here.
PICARD: I'm sure you misunderstood.
RENE: No, I didn't. He said so.
PICARD: Well, Robert and I, we. Perhaps it's time to change all that.
RENE: You know, you don't seem so arrow. Arrow. You know.
PICARD: Arrogant?
RENE: Yes, arrogant. You don't seem that way to me. What does it mean anyway, arrogant son of a...
PICARD: Let's talk about that later, shall we?

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    +1 good character study of this darker side of Picard – EleventhDoctor Feb 6 at 15:34
  • 1
    I think this is the best answer we can hope for at this point – Michael Stachowsky Jul 1 at 0:20
7

Personally I think that Picard regretted everything that he said which made him too ashamed to even admit that he had regrets because he should have known better. Picard is a great captain, but let's face it, he is not flawless and his arrogance sometimes get's the better of him (something that Q noted a few times over the course of the series). And something that is also noted by Lily, who criticized Picard's beliefs of them being "more evolved" than humanity of her time while still being little better than Captain Ahab from Moby Dick. This conversation took place before Picard's apology to Worf.

| improve this answer | |
  • I can agree somewhat, but Picard has never been shown as a character who doesn't say what he means. If he regretted it all, he'd have said it, or been more direct ("Mr Worf, I regret calling you a coward") – Michael Stachowsky Feb 5 at 11:48
  • 1
    The difference between fighting for what he believes and admitting to a mistake. A somewhat similar situation in DS9 where Captain Sisko revealed to him his wife died at the Battle Of Wolf 359. Picard's change in tone during the remainder of their encounter changed notably. While his arguments with Q he always stood more firm, and even when admitting he was wrong he did it grudgingly and only when there was no other way out as with their first contact with the Borg. – A.bakker Feb 5 at 11:58
  • 1
    That's a fair point. I'd prefer canon evidence over analysis, though, but I think you may be correct – Michael Stachowsky Feb 5 at 13:15
  • Exactly - Picard's statement is a bit milquetoast. Rather than simply saying "Worf. I was wrong and should not have personally attacked you the way I did. That was uncalled for. I regret that and I'm sorry. You are, in fact, the bravest person I've ever met.", Picard waffles. Worf saying 'Some?' is Worf pointing out the wishy-washy 'take you want to hear from my non-apology apology' nature – NKCampbell Feb 5 at 14:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.