7

From Chapter 38 in Order of the Phoenix:

"Well, I've lost a few of my possessions," said Luna serenely. "People take them and hide them, you know. But as it's the last night, I really do need them back, so I've been putting up signs." She gestured to the notice board which, sure enough, she had pinned a list of all her missing books and clothes, with a plea for their return.

I have seen it implied in fan theories that because her missing objects included articles of clothing, this means it was Luna’s fellow dorm mates who were taking her belongings. This is further supported by the films by showing a pair of sneakers hanging from the ceiling. I can not think of who else in Hogwarts would have access to Luna’s clothes or shoes. Was it ever confirmed by Rowling (or elsewhere in books or films) who was responsible for taking Luna’s belongings? Is there anything else to support the idea it was her fellow Ravenclaws?

  • 3
    I'm reasonably sure it was nargles. – Valorum May 4 at 7:46
10

It was almost certainly the other Ravenclaws.

First off, there's the obvious reason that in general, only Ravenclaws would have access to Luna's belongings. While it was indeed possible for other people to enter Ravenclaw Tower, as we see in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, I find it highly unlikely that someone would risk getting caught in another House's area just to steal Luna's belongings.

At once the beak of the eagle opened, but instead of a bird’s call, a soft, musical voice said, "Which came first, the phoenix or the flame?"
"Hmm... what do you think, Harry?" said Luna, looking thoughtful.
"What? Isn’t there just a password?"
"Oh, no, you’ve got to answer a question," said Luna.
"What if you get it wrong?"
"Well, you have to wait for somebody who gets it right," said Luna. "That way you learn, you see?"
"Yeah... trouble is, we can’t really afford to wait for anyone else, Luna."
"No, I see what you mean," said Luna seriously. "Well then, I think the answer is that a circle has no beginning."
"Well reasoned," said the voice, and the door swung open.
Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, chapter 29: "The Lost Diadem"

But in addition to that, it's worth noting that Ravenclaw House has a history of bullying and snobbyness.

In the old Slytherin acceptance letter to Hogwarts on Pottermore, there's this line:

For instance, we Slytherins look after our own – which is more than you can say for Ravenclaw. Apart from being the biggest bunch of swots you ever met, Ravenclaws are famous for clambering over each other to get good marks, whereas we Slytherins are brothers.

That shows already that Ravenclaws have a reputation for not really caring about each other. That's reinforced if you carefully read this part of the Ravenclaw letter:

Another cool thing about Ravenclaw is that our people are the most individual – some might even call them eccentrics. But geniuses are often out of step with ordinary folk...

So we can see from these that Ravenclaws tend to not really have the best intraHouse dynamics, reading between the lines.

And, of course, there's the case of Olive Hornby and Moaning Myrtle.

Both Myrtle and Olive were both Ravenclaws, and, as we know, did not get along well. Olive tormented Myrtle about her glasses - incidentally, paralleling everyone mocking Luna later on.

"Ooooh, it was dreadful," she said with relish. "It happened right in here. I died in this very stall. I remember it so well. I'd hidden because Olive Hornby was teasing me about my glasses. The door was locked, and I was crying, and then I heard somebody come in. They said something funny. A different language, I think it must have been. Anyway, what really got me was that it was a boy speaking. So I unlocked the door, to tell him to go and use his own toilet, and then -" Myrtle swelled importantly, her face shining. "I died."
"How?" said Harry.
"No idea," said Myrtle in hushed tones. "I just remember seeing a pair of great, big, yellow eyes. My whole body sort of seized up, and then I was floating away . . . ." She looked dreamily at Harry. "And then I came back again. I was determined to haunt Olive Hornby, you see. Oh, she was sorry she'd ever laughed at my glasses."
Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, chapter 16: "The Chamber of Secrets"

All in all, I think there's sufficient evidence that it was the other Ravenclaw students who were bullying Luna and stealing her belongings due to how odd she was. (For a related question on Ravenclaw and eccentric folks, see Ravenclaw House - is it really a good place for eccentric people?.)

| improve this answer | |
  • 4
    So not nargles then? How disappointing. – Valorum May 4 at 13:13
  • You never know... – Mithical May 4 at 13:14
  • 2
    "First off, there's the obvious reason that in general, only Ravenclaws would have access to Luna's belongings." Luna would have classes with students from other Houses, would spend time between classes around students from other Houses, etc. There would be opportunities for any student to take (some of) her belongings, and that could include certain items of clothing (e.g. cloaks, scarves, gloves, hats). If it was only Ravenclaws taking her possessions she'd only need to post a request for her belongings on the noticeboard in their common room, rather than all over the school. – Anthony Grist May 4 at 16:12
  • @AnthonyGrist That is quite possible. It could also be that Ravenclaws took the items and, like the shoes in the movie, they ended up everywhere. Then she may still need help from the school in general to find them. – Bishop May 4 at 16:30
2

Any student could take them using Accio.

There is no way to know who took Luna’s things - they would not need physical access to her dormitory. Hogwarts students all carry bags with their school supplies and personal items. However, even more significantly, anyone could steal Luna’s things from her dormitory by summoning them with Accio. Hermione took the books on Horcruxes that were kept in Dumbledore’s study this way.

“Well … it was easy,’ said Hermione in a small voice. ‘I just did a Summoning Charm. You know – accio. And – they zoomed out of Dumbledore’s study window right into the girls’ dormitory.”
- Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Chapter 6 (The Ghoul in Pyjamas)

The Headmaster’s office is protected by a gargoyle which requires a password before allowing anyone entry. Despite this, Hermione was able to take the books kept there by summoning them with Accio, which brought them to her own dormitory. Other students would be able to do something similar with Luna’s belongings, and Summon them to a different location, whatever their house is. Also, Ravenclaws would not be the only ones possibly motivated to steal Luna’s things. Students from other houses also thought of her as odd.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.