6

In the movie adaptation of The Two Towers, Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli meet the newly-resurrected Gandalf the White in Fangorn Forest.

For the first few words of his conversation he sounds like Saruman, before slowly transitioning back into his own voice.

Is it ever explained why he chose to do this? Did this detail occur in the book?

  • 1
    It is in the book, I'm sure one of the Tolkien experts around here will give you a very detailed answer on it. I myself don't know where they get such great text excerpts, or I'd do it myself! – Aww_Geez Jun 25 at 19:23
  • 3
    Part of it is no doubt that the Three Hunters assume it is Saruman at first, and the audience is also meant to. – Nolimon Jun 25 at 19:32
  • I don't have it anymore so can't give this as a proper answer, but for a heads up to someone who does still own it (and therefore can back this up), the LOTR film box set with interviews and such included, it's mentioned that they had Christopher Lee and Ian McKellen both speak those lines to "confuse the audience" for a bit before revealing that it is actually Gandalf, not Saruman, presumably to mirror the fact that, in the book, the three heroes aren't sure at first (as per Paul's answer below). – NathanS Jun 26 at 9:03
15

In The White Rider, chapter 5 of The Two Towers we are shown the meeting between Gandalf and Aragorn et al. They see an old man in dirty grey rags and jump to the conclusion that it is Saruman (after all, they know that Gandalf is dead, so who else is it going to be?). Gimli urges Legolas to shoot him, but Aragorn and Legolas refuse to kill an old man who might be entirely innocent.

Gandalf approaches the three and speaks in riddles. Eventually:

"Saruman!" cried Gimli, springing towards him with axe in hand. "Speak! Tell us where you have hidden our friends!..."

Gandalf blocks the attacks by magic, and is suddenly recognised by the party. Aragorn wonders "What veil was over my sight?"

"Gandalf", the old man repeated, as if recalling from old memory a long disused word. ... "Yes, you may still call me Gandalf," he said, and the voice was the voice of their old friend and guide.

So it seems that the film merely tried to represent this scene, albeit in a way that compresses several minutes of conversation and argument into a few seconds. In particular it seems from the book that Gandalf's face and voice were unrecognisable until after Gimli's attempted attack.

Also, part of the return of Gandalf is that he is now "Gandalf the White". In the book this does not become plain until later, but in the movie we see Gandalf wearing a shining white cloak from the beginning of this scene. Since the wizards were previously Saruman the White and Gandalf the Grey this was another reason for Aragorn et al to believe that they were seeing Saruman.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.