0

In Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire, Severus Snape accuses Harry Potter of stealing rare potion ingredients used primarily to make Polyjuice Potion, including lacewing flies and boomslang skin. In the movie at least, he accuses him of "brewing Polyjuice Potion with his little friends."

Why did he think that it was Harry? Was it just his general dislike of Harry and his friends, or did he find out about him brewing it in his second year? If so, how? Did he hear about the incident in the second year from Draco Malfoy or Crabbe and Goyle? Or did he use legilimency?

0
2

The scene in the books:

"So I give you fair warning, Potter," Snape continued in a sorter and more dangerous voice, "pint-sized celebrity or not - if I catch you breaking into my office one more time -" "I haven't been anywhere near your office!" said Harry angrily, forgetting his feigned deafness. "Don't lie to me," Snape hissed, his fathomless black eyes boring into Harry's. "Boomslang skin. Gillyweed. Both come from my private stores, and I know who stole them." Harry stared back at Snape, determined not to blink or to look guilty. In truth, he hadn't stolen either of these things from Snape. Hermione had taken the boomslang skin back in their second year - they had needed it for the Polyjuice Potion - and while Snape had suspected Harry at the time, he had never been able to prove it. Dobby, of course, had stolen the gillyweed. "I don't know what you're talking about," Harry lied coldly. "You were out of bed on the night my office was broken into!" Snape hissed. "I know it. Potter! Now, Mad-Eye Moody might have joined your fan club, but I will not tolerate your behavior! One more nighttime stroll into my office, Potter, and you will pay!"

Ways Snape would know/accuse Harry:

A- Why won't he accuse Harry of anything possible.

B- He suspects Harry was out in the night + In that same night someone broke into his office and stole Polyjuice ingredients= Harry stole it.

C- The scene in book 2:

"If I ever find out who threw this," Snape whispered, "I shall make sure that person is expelled." Harry arranged his face into what he hoped was a puzzled expression. Snape was looking right at him, and the bell that rang ten minutes later could not have been more welcome.

Snape could have read Harry's mind right there. but since he couldn't prove it was Harry, he just remembered it and he might have been referencing that incident.

D- Did you notice how Snape's eyes were "boring into Harry's", and that "Harry stared back at Snape, determined not to blink"? I can bet Snape was using legilimency right there. That's why right after, Snape didn't accuse Harry of stealing! Instead, Snape accuses Harry of being out the night his office was broken into.

E- Combining all the answers: Snape added 1+1 and thought that when Harry was out in the night, he stole some Polyjuice ingredients. He also knew that Harry had something to do with the stealing in book 2. Therefore Snape accused Harry of stealing. Harry finally looked up into Snape's eyes and Snape used legilimency on him, discovering that Harry didn't actually steal. Snape, however, still needs to accuse Harry of something, so he accuses him of being out in the night the office was broken into. Snape than also for no reason accuses Harry of going into his office, because it's Harry Potter and Snape hates Harry Potter.

6
  • 1
    Also, Hermione was in the infirmary for weeks after her Polyjuice accident in Book 2, if I recall correctly. If Snape knew why she was missing his classes, he'd be fairly certain that Harry had been involved somehow. – notovny Dec 19 '20 at 23:04
  • @MBEllis, Don't get me wrong, but I kinda doubt that Snape used Legillimency right here, because when Snape is asked by Dumbledore to teach Harry Occlumency, he had to pronounce 'Legillimens' to actually use it on Harry. So it seems that Snape couldn't have used it on Harry right here without doing so. This seems a very likely theory to me, unless you think otherwise? – Infinity Milestone Dec 23 '20 at 14:09
  • @AyushBhatt- There are plenty of times legillimency is used without an incantation: "Harry's throat went dry. He knew what Snape was going to do and he had never been able to prevent it... The bathroom seemed to shimmer before his eyes; he struggled to block out all thought, but try as he might, the Half-Blood Prince's copy..." – MBEllis Dec 23 '20 at 14:21
  • or for example Voldemort: "Do not lie to Lord Voldemort, Muggle, for he knows..." – MBEllis Dec 23 '20 at 14:24
  • In cases where Legillimency is used the victim knows that it is being used. In the cited passage Harry has no such experience. Snape does not seem to routinely use it on students. (Why not? That would be a good Question). – Paul Johnson Dec 23 '20 at 18:36
1

In the book:

"Don't lie to me," Snape hissed, his fathomless black eyes boring into Harry's. "Boomslang skin. Gillyweed. Both come from my private stores, and I know who stole them."

Snape blames Harry because Gillyweed was stolen and he knows Harry used Gillyweed in the second task. He also remembers the egg from the night it was stolen.

Putting both facts together, the Gillyweed and the egg, he blames Harry.

It was probably Dobby who stole the Gillyweed and Barty Crouch Jr. who stole the Boomslang.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.