0

In the Goblet of Fire, the other schools participating the Triwizard tournament used means of transport like flying carriages (Beauxbatons) and ships (Durmstrang) when they could have simply used Portkey?

0
6

There are two reasons for the two schools not to arrive in Portkey. The first is that the students needed a place to sleep and stay while they were at Hogwarts, and I think they the students of their respective schools would prefer staying with each other instead of with the students of Hogwarts. Also it provided a grand effect. The visiting schools want to make a first impression of themselves, just as the castle was also being spruced up for the first impression of the visitors. This way, I would think, takes only two to three hours with the assistance of magic, and it has the added benefits of room and outstanding an entrance.

1
  • @hello Room, yes, but not board. I think they eat all their meals at Hogwarts don't they? I definitely agree on the showing off though! (You could add the quotation from the Quidditch World Cup about that). Jan 28 at 10:28
0

In the Wizarding World articles about the Hogwarts Express, it is explained that before the train they used to travel to Hogwarts using Portkey and other methods but preferred the train because kids can lose the object and can get sick from the trip.

Source

Also a portkey is usually a small object you can use to teleport a small group of people but I don´t think you can have more than ten people touching a small object at the same time so probably they prefer a method like Hogwarts express, that can take a lot of people.

2
  • Hi, welcome to SF&F. This doesn't explain why the other teams don't use Portkey to get to Hogwarts. (The triwizard teams are not typical students who might be forgetful or inattentive and hence needing special care.)
    – DavidW
    Mar 1 at 2:11
  • First the triwizard team are a lot of people and usually portkey are not big enough to port all the candidates plus professors. Second wizards are really old fashioned, if English wizards have to travel by train to Hogwarts they guest have to travel y similar means, not portkeys.
    – wolfpirate
    Mar 2 at 1:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.