7

The movie presents the fight as completely avoidable. The bridge is two flights of stairs away from the eastern gate. It would seem that the Balrog could not have followed them outside and they were well ahead of him, at least judging by the speed with which everybody was moving (the Balrog was slow).

What is the situation in the books? I assume the bridge is far deeper down and the way from the bridge to the exit is much further?

Also, the way it looks in the movie, Gandalf could have just kept running to the far end of the bridge and destroyed the bridge, trapping the Balrog (and the orcs) in Moria forever with both exists unreachable?

11
  • 4
  • 11
    I don't think it's a given that the Balrog could not have followed them. – Radhil Mar 16 at 20:35
  • 2
    Plus the movie is different from the source material – Paulie_D Mar 16 at 20:49
  • 6
    obviously the Balrog could not have followed them outside Really? How is that obvious? – KorvinStarmast Mar 17 at 11:52
  • 3
    If this is your first time at Khazad-dûm, you have to fight. – PM 2Ring Mar 17 at 17:37
1

We don't really know how fast a balrog can run, how far away the exit is, or if it is small enough to block the Balrog. And there would still be the matter of the orcs chasing them as well.

The bridge of Khazad-dûm was intentionally designed narrow, to stall an invading army. If anything, the narrow bridge itself ought to be an obstacle. It might very well have been Gandalf's improvised plan to lure the Balrog onto the bridge and collapse it, since he was successful in doing exactly that - or it would have been a successful plan if the Balrog hadn't caught him with the whip.

But Gandalf's priority here it to get the rest of the Fellowship and the Ring away to safety, so he draws the Balrog's attention on purpose to buy the others time, possibly even revealing that he is a Maia - the "Flame of Anor" part is a bit mysterious.

Gandalf might very well have decided to take the fight despite the uncertain odds, just to ensure that Frodo got away safely. This could explain why he doesn't want the rest of the party to engage it either. He claims that "this foe is beyond any of you" - it could be true, but he could also just be saying that to ensure that the others stay with Frodo.


The out-of-universe explanation for the scene is simply that this scene is the climax of the whole Moria episode. If the Fellowship had just legged it, it wouldn't be nearly as dramatic. (The endless "Why didn't they just fly an eagle to Mt Doom?" discussion - because it wouldn't have been much of a story then, would it?)

Tolkien had skilfully been building up an ominous feeling from the point where the Fellowship is trapped at the western gate, through the journey through the dark, the discovery that Gollum is stalking them, then the escalating events in the Chamber of Mazarbul, all leading up to the fight with the Balrog.

And the first time you read the book/see the movie, you actually don't realize that Gandalf...

survived. Or rather got reincarnated.

Gandalf falling to his death sets the mood for many chapters ahead.

The Moria chapters are perhaps, in my personal opinion, some of the most well-written in the whole story. Tolkien's writing style was very much about slowly building up the thrill and tension during several chapters, more and more intense until it ends with a dramatic final event. This is then followed by a more relaxed chapter to give the reader some room to relax before starting the next story arc. Both The Hobbit and LotR are written exactly in this manner.

2
  • Sorry for the late response! Some mod had closed this topic for being "opinion-based", I think, so I stopped following it. My suggestion that the Balrog could not have followed them was mostly based on the assumption that he'd have a problem with daylight, not the size of the door. My assumption that the exit is close was based on there being a shot in the movie where one can see the bridge and a gateway from which daylight falls into Moria. Walking distance from one to the other being less than 100 yards, I'd say. Essentially, I was faulting the film for making the fight seem avoidable. – Hesha Mar 24 at 15:40
  • @Hesha Balrogs aren't bothered by sunlight, except they might find it annoying. The reason the Balrog was in Moria is because at the end of the first age after the last of the great battles, the surviving balrogs hid from the wrath of Valar deep underneath the earth. The dwarves at some point dug too deep while mining under their city Khazad-dûm and came across an imprisoned Balrog, who then killed the dwarven king Durin - hence the epithet Durin's Bane. This was the end of Khazad-dûm and it became known as Moria – Amarth Mar 24 at 17:25

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.