5

I would like to get the timeline of the following events - which has never been entirely clear to me - straightened out once and for all:

  • The Phantom Menace - including the Battle of Naboo, the downfall of Valorum and Palpatine's election to the Chancellorship.
  • Dooku leaves the Jedi Order
  • Dooku first learns of Sidious' Sith identity
  • Dooku becomes Sidious' apprentice (if this is not immediate)
  • Sifo-Dyas orders the clone army on Kamino
  • Sifo-Dyas disappears/dies on Oba Diah
  • 'Tyrannus' 'takes over' from Sifo-Dyas as the Kaminoans' client
  • Jango Fett is recruited on the moons of Bogden
  • The Kaminoans begin production on the clone troopers

I am looking for both the Canon and Legends versions (if they differ at all). If there are any holes, unknowns, or inconsistencies, please feel free to reply with whatever is available, including multiple contradictory versions.

3
  • 3
    In Legends much of this would be covered by the novel Dark Plagueis IIRC, but I don't know how much of this has been set in stone in the Disney canon.
    – Hypnosifl
    May 23 at 22:45
  • @Hypnosifl Did you write that the legends novel was titled Dark Plagueis or Darth Plagueis? May 24 at 16:19
  • 1
    @M.A.Golding - Whoops, yeah it was supposed to be "Darth" not "Dark"
    – Hypnosifl
    May 24 at 16:24
7

I've made a flowchart ordering the events whose relative order we know. Explanation of the ordering follows.

Flowchart of order of events

Canon

The canon version of events is almost straightforward, except that:

I'm assuming the USW version of events is a mistake, although it's possible that there's some explanation, like Sifo-Dyas taking so long to reach his destination that he didn't get there until after TPM. With that in mind:

  1. Dooku leaves the Jedi Order in 42 BBY (The Star Wars Book, Dooku: Jedi Lost)
  2. Dooku first learns of Sidious' Sith identity / Dooku becomes Sidious' apprentice (Rise of the Separatists sourcebook)
  3. Sifo-Dyas orders the clone army on Kamino (Complete Visual Dictionary)
  4. Sifo-Dyas disappears/dies on Oba Diah (The Clone Wars: The Lost One).
  5. The Phantom Menace. TPM apparently happens after Sifo-Dyas' death, since he was on a mission for Chancellor Valorum, who was no longer Chancellor by the end of TPM. However, this contradicts Ultimate Star Wars, which explicitly places Sifo-Dyas' clone order and death after TPM (page 190, Kamino).
  6. 'Tyrannus' 'takes over' from Sifo-Dyas as the Kaminoans' client (Ultimate Star Wars)
  7. Jango Fett is recruited on the moons of Bogden (Age of Republic: Jango Fett). This definitely took place post-TPM according to Ultimate Star Wars.
  8. The Kaminoans begin production on the clone troopers

Legends

Much of the order is the same, except in Legends, Dooku left the Jedi Order after TPM, which creates some inconsistencies.

Dooku first learns of Sidious' Sith identity

This apparently happened first, since Dooku was apparently training under Sidious at the time Sifo-Dyas made the clone order. This creates an inconsistency given that Darth Plagueis says that Sidious hadn't revealed himself by the end of The Phantom Menace, although Sidious and Dooku had had a working relationship by then.

Dooku becomes Sidious' apprentice

Dooku was apparently training under Sidious at this point, since according to Jedi vs. Sith: The Essential Guide to the Force, killing Sifo-Dyas was required for his promotion to Sith Lord.

Note that this is a fairly large inconsistency, since Darth Plagueis and other sources strongly imply that he hadn't turned until later. The Essential Guide to the Force in particular seems to have assumed that the Tyranus/Sifo-Dyas events took place post-TPM, not least because of the Rule of Two, but this assumption was apparently later retconned.

Sifo-Dyas orders the clone army on Kamino

Darth Plagueis and Darth Sidious arranged for Sifo-Dyas to fund the creation of the clone army, using funds provided by Plagueis's company Damask Holdings. This is described in Darth Plagueis and appears to uncontroversially take place before TPM.

Sifo-Dyas disappears/dies on Oba Diah

This apparently happened before The Phantom Menace, since Chancellor Valorum's aide, Silman, was present at the time, according to the TCW episode The Lost One, and Chancellor Valorum has been replaced by the end of TPM. Sifo-Dyas was murdered by Count Dooku in all versions of his story. This happened relatively soon after ordering the clone army.

Note that TCW is the first mention of Sifo-Dyas being killed by Dooku pre-TPM; without this detail, there would be very little inconsistency.

The Phantom Menace

Valorum replaced by Palpatine as Chancellor. Palpatine kills Plagueis during the events of the film, according to Darth Plagueis. Qui-Gon is killed and Darth Maul is believed dead.

Setting up the army (order unclear)

a. Dooku leaves the Jedi Order

Officially, his leaving was due in part to his dissatisfaction with the Jedi's actions at the Battle of Galidraan, which definitely took place before TPM (variously in 44 BBY and 34 BBY in Legends), but ultimately he only left after Qui-Gon died in TPM.

However, since he'd apparently fallen to the dark side at this point, this can be assumed to be a cover story. In any case, he could only have erased Kamino from the archives while still a Jedi (according to Attack of the Clones), so his leaving would have had to have happened after he was at least aware of the cloning plot.

b. 'Tyrannus' 'takes over' from Sifo-Dyas as the Kaminoans' client

Probably happened before hiring Jango Fett, but it's unclear.

c. Jango Fett is recruited on the moons of Bogden

Shown in Bounty Hunter.

The Kaminoans begin production on the clone troopers

Presumably this happened last, since the genetic template would need to have been selected, and Dooku would need to be able to set things up with the Kaminoans.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.