9

Baron Wulfenbach took a hive engine aboard Castle Wulfenbach so he could study it. When it was activated, Gil and Agatha were trapped and herded toward it.

Gil: We'll be taken over — and then our job will be to defend it.
Agatha: Kill me first.

Why were they afraid, given that it was common knowledge that the wasps don't work on sparks?

8

There are several points to bear in mind here, but none of them are that the wasps are harmless. (Clearly both Wulfenbachs think the wasps are a real threat, and neither is inclined to panic easily.)

  • Common knowledge, especially in Girl Genius, is often very far from true. Agatha, who is almost completely ignorant at this point in time, has no reason to trust her immunity to the wasps - she's only beginning to realise what she's capable of at this point. It's only Gil's actions that need explanation.

  • Standard slaver wasps don't infect sparks, but it is possible to modify slaver engines to infect sparks. (We see one in action, later.) Klaus is clearly aware of this, and considers all engines a lethal threat. Gil may not know this at the time (he does later), but has clearly picked up his father's attitude. (Agatha, who at the time has been kept purposely ignorant of most spark history, is merely responding to Gil's concerns and the general atmosphere of panic over slaver wasps.)

  • Slaver wasps that can't control sparks can still kill them trying. Also, sparks are heavily dependent on their supporting minions. It's not much good to be immune to mind control yourself if all your aircraft crew and bodyguards have turned into slaved copies of the Other trying to kill you.

  • Lucrezia's slaver wasps, once created, were frequently redesigned and repurposed by other sparks to enslave for them. Redesigning them to work fine on sparks is an obvious next step. Since the Baron can't be sure who's been using the hive engine first, it's a huge threat. (Selnikov is clearly worried about something like this in the section linked; he expressly claims that Tarvek's in danger from other kinds of wasp than Lucrezia's.)

    We know that many other factions are performing exactly this kind of research. The fake Heterodyne's defences against becoming the Other accomplish something much more sophisticated and difficult than merely controlling a spark; they secure a complete copy of the Other in a mental trap.

(With thanks to Adamant, whose comments greatly improved this answer.)

| improve this answer | |
  • Nice answer, but this definitely needs amending. There is a specific slaver wasp engine modified to infect Sparks (and we see it in action), so it’s not merely a deception: the standard variety actually don’t work on Sparks. Also, the Smoke Knights in general are not Sparks. – Adamant Jul 15 '17 at 1:28
  • The reason Klaus Wulfenbach thinks the wasps are a threat is clear: they may not be able to control Sparks (even though they clearly will try to), but they can certainly kill them (the warrior versions). As for Agatha, she doesn’t (at that point) know much about Sparky stuff, and Gil was sort of new to the whole thing. – Adamant Jul 15 '17 at 1:35
  • Anyway, look here. This proves that (at least later) Gil knew that the ordinary slaver wasps couldn’t control Sparks. – Adamant Jul 15 '17 at 2:05
  • @Adamant All good points - I wrote this answer years ago, and missed some of what - at the time - was recent information. It's badly in need of updating. Do you want to go ahead and edit your changes in, or shall I? – Tynam Jul 15 '17 at 12:11
  • I think you should do it. These are some major changes, and some portions of your answer will also need to be removed. I don’t want to remove the things that you might still agree with. – Adamant Jul 15 '17 at 21:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.