I'm trying to find either the specific short story or the book in which it can be found. The book was published some time in 2009.

The book was a collection of both fiction and nonfiction stories reflecting on the idea of heroes. One of the nonfiction stories was about Sully landing the plane in the Hudson.

The specific short story I have been trying to find is about two scientists talking to a man with amnesia. They tell him he is superhuman and he needs to save them all from a nuclear plant about to meltdown. He does not believe them, so they perform multiple examples to prove their claim. One of those is one scientists shooting a gun at the man and the man appearing to catch the bullet. The man in the end believes them and leaves to save them.

The story continues with the scientists explaining how they pulled off their illusion to trick the man, and how when the hero came back, they would make sure he was not in any pain as he died from radiation poisoning.

  • Hmm, a part of me wonders if it's a sci-fi story then. One thing for sure, the book in which it was is about both.
    – Clockwork
    Jun 20, 2022 at 5:35

1 Answer 1


Had to create an account for this. You're looking for "Time for a Hero" (1995) by Brian M. Thomsen. Pretty obscure - looks like it only got printed in one anthology, Superheroes.

Regarding the following part of your description...

two scientists talking to a man with amnesia. They tell him he is superhuman and he needs to save them all from a nuclear plant about to meltdown.

... here's a relevant excerpt from the story itself:

"The bazooka shell," repeated Parker. "Don't you remember?"

"No. I don't remember anything. This all must be some dream. Getting hit in the head would kill an ordinary man… probably blow him to bits. No, I'm just not awake yet. This is all just a dream," he added, the pounding in his head becoming more and more noticeable. "I'm going to just close my eyes, go back to sleep, and wake up later when I'm not so delirious."

"You can't do that," insisted Dr. Kirschenbaum. "We need you. Surely you must remember the crisis… your mission… what you have to do…"

"What do I have to do?" he asked, hoping that this dream would soon be over.

"Save the world, of course," answered Parker.

Googling the phrase "Parker said to Kirschenbaum" leads to an online version of the story, including the mention that it was a suicidal mission.

"Well, it certainly works," said Parker, patting the older doctor on the back. "In less than two hours we can turn an ordinary soldier with human flaws and instincts for self-preservation into a confident and carefree hero with no other concerns except the completion of his mission. One man dies so that many can be saved. No matter how you look at it, that's a more than acceptable casualty rate. Lt. O'Connor, aka Meteor Man I, will get a hero's funeral, and the day will be saved."

"A hero's funeral," mused the increasingly more depressed Dr. Kirschenbaum. "I remember reading about the Soviet firemen who rushed into Chernobyl to contain the fire to keep the plant from exploding, knowing that in doing so they were signing their own death warrants. I also remember stories of soldiers earning medals that were awarded posthumously by jumping on top of hand grenades..."

Great story in a quality 1990s anthology!

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.