7

Note: The eyes of the Terminator I think were real but he did not rely on them, although interestingly they would have blocked his electronic eyes, so I wonder how that worked.

A robot disguised as a human is not what I meant - I mean, something that is flesh and machine, but started out purely as machine, not as a human. The robots of The Second Variety were mechanical but they also may have employed real body parts and if so, it could be argued that they preceded the idea in the Terminator except Terminators used flesh purely as camouflage. The RUR creatures are not relevant here since they are not a combination of machine and flesh but rather artificially grown flesh IIRC.

"Cyborg" to me always meant an artificially enhanced organism, but importantly, originally a naturally-born organism.

I am not sure Arnold's Terminator was a cyborg. He was a robot with real flesh added, but the skin and eyes I guess were not essential and he was, it goes without saying, never human. (In later flicks, we saw it seems to me that Skynet started out by modifying humans into cyborgs.)

So my question is, was Cameron (or whoever thought of the idea) the first to come up with a robot "enhanced" with real human tissue (although presumably the tissue was cultured, not taken from humans)?

7
  • 4
    The eyes were robotic and the flesh was purely cosmetic, and only served as a disguise. The skin is definitely not required, as shown by the skeletal terminators hunting humans in the first scenes. (And by the skeletalized terminator still fighting after having its flesh burned off.) The earliest "robot disguised as human for infiltration purposes" I can think of is Dick's "Second Variety."
    – DavidW
    Commented Aug 22 at 19:09
  • 5
    There are at least two distinct questions here: "Was the Terminator the first robot of that nature in science fiction" and "is there a different term than "cyborg" for such a robot?" The former is a [history-of] question while the latter is a [terminology] question, and the answer to one does not necessarily provide the answer to the other. As such, I think they should be asked separately rather than being packaged together as a two-for-the-price-of-one deal. Commented Aug 22 at 19:42
  • 5
    If I remember right, the first "robots" (R. U. R., Karel Čapek, 1920) were made entirely of artificial flesh and blood, and could pass for human beings. But I don't think that's what you want.
    – user14111
    Commented Aug 22 at 21:21
  • @user14111 R.U.R. robots being more like Blade Runner replicants than TNG's Data no doubt you realize. Commented Aug 23 at 4:58
  • @LogicDictates: You are right but I am pretty sure there is no term specifically for a robot that only uses flesh to fool humans and, of course, to time travel. "Cyborg" is probably the closest even if wrong technically. The more important question is whether this was an original idea of Cameron and I think it was: It also provided some very good details, i.e. (pun intended) the self-surgery scene and the idea that the Terminator seemed to deteriorate over time, perhaps due to wounds. This had no real effect beyond its progressive difficulty blending in.
    – releseabe
    Commented Aug 23 at 7:20

4 Answers 4

4

Metropolis. (Novel by Thea von Harbou 1925, Fritz Lang's motion picture 1927, IMDB.)

Everyone is familiar with the poster of a shiny robot female (Technically the false Maria, played by Brigitte Helm) being created inside a machine. That's from the most popular movie poster:

Famous monochromatic movie poster of mechanical woman with a city backdrop.

Illustration by Heinz Schulz-Neudamm. Copyright expired.

Another, lesser known poster-version of the character (false) Maria of the Maschinenmensch (a worker class of humanoid robots) shows her with the outer layer added:

Almost art deco painting of a woman wired to a machine.

Artist unknown. Out of copyright.

Images are not subject to copyright, but belong to Paramount studios.

3
  • Very nice. I think this is the right answer.
    – releseabe
    Commented Aug 25 at 10:26
  • Are you sure the poster shows the Maschinenmensch? Because that really looks like the contraption Maria is lying in during the transformation: youtu.be/VJVUQ5gHsZI?t=120. The fake Maria is sitting in a chair without the same kind of machinery in the background. Commented Aug 26 at 17:54
  • @EikePierstorff You might have a point there, I'll try to make time to watch it again and check then update the answer. Commented Aug 27 at 9:34
3

Philip K. Dick had The Second Variety (a story I found absolutely creepy) was published in 1953.

Pohl and Kornbluth's Wolfsbane from 1959 I still think one of their best, and Fred Saberhagen started writing the Berserker stories in 1963 (and at least one of them I've always thought the ancestor of The Terminator movie).

But I see The Second Variety as the start, and I've never forgotten this:

The claws weren’t like other weapons. They were alive, from any practical standpoint, whether the Governments wanted to admit it or not. They were not machines. They were living

things, spinning, creeping, shaking themselves up suddenly from the gray ash and darting toward a man, climbing up him, rushing for his throat. And that was what they had been designed to do. Their job.

"They did their job well. Especially lately, with the new designs coming up. Now they repaired themselves. They were on their own ... Down below the surface automatic machinery stamped them out. Human beings stayed a long way off. It was too risky; nobody wanted to be around them. They were left to themselves. And they seemed to be doing all right. The new designs were faster, more complex. More efficient."

2

Since you are asking Science Fiction in general and not movies specifically, the German Perry Rhodan pulp series featured (first in issue 403 from 1969) the "Vario 500" robot, an egg shaped device that was constructed to disguise itself with a variety of human looking "cocoon masks" made from cultured flesh. The purpose was essentially infiltration (in early issues the robot impersonated a politician influencing a somewhat isolationist goverment to join an alliance) so a bit similar, if rather more benign than the Terminator.

1

There are also the androids of I, Mudd, the Star Trek TOS Season 2 episode that aired November 3, 1967. In an early scene a male android announces to the bridge that he is in control of the Enterprise and opens a cover in his abdomen revealing he has an electronic and mechanical interior under his human-looking skin, hair, fingernails, etc.

The story summaries I've found don't say whether the androids' skin/hair are organic or inorganic.

1
  • 2
    Androids resembling humans is the very nature of androids; but making "fake cyborg" with real flesh is what I think Cameron may have invented.
    – releseabe
    Commented Aug 23 at 9:26

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.