18

According to Neil Gaiman's account,

Shadow's real name is Baldur Moon, which translates to the fact that the protagonist of American Gods is a god.

How is it possible that he does not realize that? Or does he?

17

Actually, there seem to be an apparently convincing argument that Shadow/Baldar is NOT Baldur the god, but merely has the same name. The full discussion can be seen here. The main points of the orignal write-up are:

First, it doesn't fit at all with the mythos established in the novel for Balder to be incarnated in human form. We see no other god that is embodied this way. It makes little sense for Balder to emerge now, since there's not exactly scores of people just starting to believe in him again. Besides that, the people that did believe in Balder for the most part believed he was dead, so he's just not going to be up running around in any form.

Second, while Shadow corresponds to Balder in many ways, there are many ways in which he doesn't. Shadow may be attractive, but he's not the Nordic vision of blond beauty that Balder was. Balder's wife died after him, not before. When Balder did die, it did not involve hanging himself in the manner of his father. Shadow's death does not involve the manipulation of a blind of otherwise handicapped brother, which I think is a pretty important part of the Balder myth. Shadow is a fighter, Balder wasn't.

Third, Shadow is a great human character, and it cheapens him to be seen as just another face for an eternal god. Gaiman's works tend to be built on normal, non-mystical characters encountering a world of magic. Richard Mayhew, Tristran Thorn, Rose Walker, that kid in Mr. Punch. Sometimes they turn out to have a mystical heritage, like Rose and Tristran, but they still tend to be very human. I see Shadow as very much in this mold, and probably the best of these characters so far. To make him a god strips him of his humanity, which weakens him in my opinion.

  • 4
    Then, why Mr. World / Loki would want to kill him with a stick from a mistletoe tree? Shadow himself is implied to be the Norse god Balder, which is confirmed in the follow-up novella, "Monarch of the Glen". Taken out of Wikipedia's article – Darius Apr 24 '11 at 0:28
  • @Darius - stick from a mistletoe is discussed in the linked thread. The assertion is that this is another one of the similarities that are actually different (since Loki didn't actually kill original Baldur himself). Mind you, I'm not saying that this is 100% correct - merely taht the arguments sound somewhat persuasive – DVK-on-Ahch-To Apr 24 '11 at 0:33
  • 1
    I read the whole post and I still believe that Shadow is Baldur. And it was Mr Town that made the air stabbing with the mistletoe stick that affected Shadow's body. – Darius Apr 24 '11 at 1:01
  • 2
    Follow-up question: Suppose that Shadow isn’t the god Baldr, or some American version of him. Why wouldn’t he still suspect that he is? – Adamant May 28 '17 at 8:03
2

Shadow has many similarities to Christ as well as to Baldr: choosing to sacrifice himself, son of a god, being tied to the tree to die in way similar to crucifixion, returning from the dead, being resurrected by EASTER (which, especially after making the point that Eostre is not remembered except for Christianized Easter, is a very funny, loaded, and self-aware moment). Plus his appearance in "Monarch of the Glen" is to fill the same ritualistic role as Beowulf. This is clearly NOT an argument for Shadow being an actual reincarnation of Beowulf or Christ. ;-) (Indeed, Gaiman wrote a scene of Shadow, while on the tree, hallucinating/astral projecting into a conversation with Christ. It's read by Gaiman in the 10th Anniversary Audiorecording, and may have been included in the second printed edition, but was cut from the original publication because Gaiman says he wasn't sure it was part of the same book. Not for another reason, like wanting to keep it ambiguous that Shadow might be Christ.) Since no one seems to find that problematic, being clearly a thematic similarity, bringing together and reusing a lot of religious tradition/imagery/cross-cultural similarities in the same way that Christianity itself historically did, I don't find it problematic for Shadow also to have similarities with Baldr in a thematic way, without it needing to be literal. Even in a work where a lot of gods do literally show up.

0

I think he's Ra, and I think he doesn't know because there isn't enough people that believe in him to have come back full form.

  • Do you have any evidence for this theory that you could edit in to back it up? – TheLethalCarrot Mar 24 at 13:41

protected by Community Apr 22 at 4:35

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.