15

In The Big Bang Theory episode The Bakersfield Expedition, Penny, Amy, and Bernadette are having an argument if Thor's hammer:

  1. Can be lifted by anyone in space.
  2. Can be lifted & wielded by anyone if Thor is touching it.

The first argument is settled in Can Thor's hammer be wielded by anyone in outer space?.

But the second argument remains unsolved. Can Thor's hammer be lifted & wielded by anyone if Thor is touching it?

  • Keep in mind it's not the weight/mass of Mjolnir that prevents people from wielding it, it's the enchantments. So I suppose, a follow up would be--what happens in zero-g? Does Mjolnir remain in a fixed position in space when Thor isn't touching it? Or, when in zero-g, does it float around like anything else and just limits the hammer's "special abilities" if someone tries to wield it? – Force Flow Feb 15 '13 at 19:31
  • That question is partially answered in the link given above. – Siddhartha Feb 16 '13 at 10:11
25

Yes, in Marvel comics and cartoons Thor's hammer can be lifted and wielded by others if Thor is touching it. The trick is that they have to be strong enough to overpower Thor. The Hulk has done this in a recent issue of Avengers Assemble (#4):

Hulk v. Thor: Avengers Assemble

The same thing happened earlier in the Hulk: Let the Battle Begin one-shot.

Hulk: Let the Battle Begin

Finally, there are many, many instances of the Hulk either lifting or tossing Thor while Thor was wielding Mjolnir. Here are just a few of those.

Hulk vs. Thor Animated Movie

Hulk slaps Thor down

Hulk headlocks Thor

Hulk lifts Thor

Hulk punches Thor

  • 3
    To be fair, that's the Hulk, who can actually lift Mjolnir by himself when he's angry enough. – Zibbobz Aug 12 '14 at 15:12
8

The second point is up to interpretation, based on how you define "lift up".

This also depends on which interpretation of Thor you are considering: The original folklore has Thor's hammer stolen at least once, something I'd consider impossible, if only the worthy can lift it.

As for Marvel's Thor I'd say anyone (strong enough) could lift both at once. Otherwise no bad guy would be able to throw or kick Thor around as long as he's in possession of his hammer. I've only seen the old animated series years ago, but I think I remember him being kicked around at least once.

  • +1 and waiting for more opinions before checking 'Accepted Answer'. – Siddhartha Feb 3 '13 at 10:41
-2

The Norse Mythology's Thor can only use Mjölnir because of his gloves. The one time where a giant stole Mjölnir happened because Thor was used to take his gloves off before he went to sleep. After that, he never took his gloves off again. Also, nobody could take his gloves off after he wear both of them. With only one glove, whoever is wearing it still can't control Mjölnir. The only way you could take one of the gloves off once you wear both of them is if the other hand with a glove tries to take it off. For instance, if the person wears the right glove and then the left glove, he'll be able to control Mjölnir. Nobody will be able to take any of the gloves off other than the wearer himself. So he takes his right hand wearing the right glove and takes the left glove off the left hand. From now on, the "enchantment" doesn't have effect anymore and anyone can take the right glove off his hand - by anyone, it means another god or a creature strong enough to fight a god.

  • And how does this relate to the fictional Thor seen in the Marvel comics? – Valorum Apr 19 '15 at 7:53
  • This is not correct even if referring to Norse mythology. @Richard – eirikdaude Apr 19 '15 at 18:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.