10

Aldrich Killian's machinations in Iron Man 3 seemed somewhat bizarre.

  • Why involve the Mandarin at all? Was the formation of Advanced Idea Mechanics a criminal version of Stark Industries?

  • Once Killian secured the Extremis technology, why did he go through such a complex scheme when his development of the Extremis project would already give him a formidable army of trained and dedicated super-soldiers?

27

He clearly explained it at the end of the movie.

By manipulating a fake villain called "The Mandarin" he creates fear and thus the weapon demand. By owning AIM and a super-soldier program he controls weapon's supply. He also wanted to manipulate the Vice-President (because the Vice-President's daughter had only 1 leg and would have recovered her second leg with EXTREMIS injection?). If he succeeded in executing the President publicly then the Vice-President would have be in charge and would have owed Killian a debt.

So in the end he would have taken control of both weapon demand and weapon supply. That would have made him (WARNING, TV TROPE LINK) The Man Behind The Man

EDIT to answer to your first bullet question (thanks to Omegacron):

Why involve the Mandarin at all? Well the Mandarin is a cover for the accidents caused by Extremis. You got yourself an explosion because one of your super soldier died? Well, just have the Mandarin claim the bombing. No one will investigate an explosion if it's been publicly claimed (in a video or whatever) by a well known terrorist.

  • 17
    I just lost my job because you posted that trope-bait link – WOPR Apr 30 '13 at 3:20
  • It's a good answer, but it should add that the threat of the Mandarin served a secondary purpose - covering up for the Extremis explosions. – Omegacron Mar 13 '15 at 18:36
  • 1
    And, of course, a major reason for him embarking on this grand scheme was to prove, once and for all, that Tony was a butthead and Adrian could do so much better than him. :) – FuzzyBoots Mar 16 '15 at 16:27
7

The ending plan was actually an evolution of the surrounding circumstances. We know from Tony's detective work that Killian's original test runs of Extremis had resulted in catastrophic failure. There were a few unexplained explosions that were similar to the Mandarin's attacks (temperatures reaching a specific magnitude, 3000 Centigrade) but were not attributed to the Mandarin.

These early test runs were, in large part, ignored by Killian and he didn't see the need to attempt to cover them up. After all, Killian doesn't send his agents to cover up information on that early test failure until Act 2. It wasn't until the test runs continued to fail and no fixes to the Extremis were foreseeable that Killian began to panic. He realized that, eventually, the government would discover that he'd been failing to deliver on Extremis in a rather... explosive manner.

This lead to his creation of the Mandarin. As a terrorist, the Mandarin would be expected to initiate attacks on the US and any future Extremis incidents could be attributed to him. This way, the US government wouldn't even think about a local US research & development firm being the actual cause of the explosions. After all, an upcoming terrorist is taking credit for them, and given the current War on Terror, who would blame them?

The conclusion is more speculation on my part, but as things escalated, Killian likely realized that there was no way he could cover up Extremis forever. At least, not without some grand spectacle to distract everyone. Obviously, the death of the President on live television would be attention-grabbing enough and it was just lucky coincidence (for Killian) that the vice-president's daughter had a disability. With that, Killian realized that he could control the presidency. The plan that Killian eventually arrived at was born more of coincidence and desperation than actual preparation.

  • I fixed the temperature for you. – user1027 May 13 '13 at 16:09
  • I did not think that way, nice theory. But the last paragraph is pure speculation. Why do you say no Extremis fix is foreseeable ? One thing bugs me in your interpretation : why would he need to destroy Tony Stark's house ? Tony Stark is just going to war against a puppet, why not let him do that ? It would be good for him that everyone see Iron Man failing at finding a vilain, wouldn't it ? – Kalissar May 14 '13 at 8:03
  • @Kalissar I did mention that the last paragraph is speculation. Killian and Hansen couldn't come up with a fix for Extremis even with how long they had been working on it. That was when Killian panicked and realized his test subjects would continue to fail and there was nothing he could do about it. His reaction to Tony is part of a knee-jerk reaction to Tony's provocation. This is, after all, the man who insulted him so long ago. The attack on the Malibu house is also a way to reinforce his Mandarin character. – Steam May 14 '13 at 14:29
  • @Yawus and also a chance to knock off Tony Stark, sans Iron Man suit. Tony's biggest crtuch is the fact that he is just a human being without the suit. If I got called out like that, yeah I'd shoot a few rockets at a dude when he was the most vulnerable. It's called revenge. – Jersey Aug 21 '13 at 20:55
0

I also will lend my opinion in that I think the main reason for Killian attacking Tony was: 1. To destroy Iron man publicly 2. To grind Tony down in the hope that Tony(who came up with the Extremis formula overnight-drunk) may be able to fix it hence Killian pumping up Pepper with the stuff in the hope (knowing -coz Tony eventually did fix it) that a he could stabilize and control it.

  • If they had successfully killed Tony/Iron Man (as they almost did), there would be no one to grind down and fix the formula to stabilize it. – phantom42 May 20 '13 at 15:59

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.