36

In Iron Man 3,

When the real villain kidnapped the President of the United States,

it is never explained why none of the other Avengers came to help, or why Tony didn't call them. The only explanation so far is: "it was an Iron Man movie...", but an in universe answer would be good.

  • 2
    I don't think they're really quite a "team" yet. Their personalities clashed hugely during The Avengers, and while they gained a mutual respect, they went their separate ways. – Django Reinhardt May 9 '13 at 12:49
  • This could all be answered in the upcoming S.H.I.E.L.D. series as well as Thor: The Dark World and Captain America: The Winter Soldier. – Monty129 May 14 '13 at 17:47
  • It would be nice they did... – jsedano May 14 '13 at 18:09
  • If you want to see other members of Avengers, watch a movie dedicated to it... movie's name is "Avengers". – Baby Yoda May 25 '13 at 11:06
  • 2
    There's also the scene in the restaurant where Rhodey specifically says the Mandarin is America's problem and should be handled by America (which of course doesn't rule out S.H.I.E.L.D. or Cap) – Monty129 May 25 '13 at 14:27
47

It isn't known where the rest of the Avengers are during the kidnapping. Since the entire event happens in the space of about eight hours, it could simply be considered too difficult to gather the Avengers in that short space of time.

Consider:

  • Thor lives in Asgard most of the time. Until they repair the technology/magic which creates the Rainbow bridge, I suspect commuting is out of the question.

  • The Hulk: As seen in the Avenger's movie, it is likely the Hulk spends his time as far away from other people who know who he is as possible. An eight hour window probably makes getting his attention challenging. Nor is he known for his subtlety. The last thing you want is HULK SMASHING his way toward the problem you are trying to sneak up on.

  • Hawkeye and Black Widow are both SHIELD operatives and could easily be on assignments anywhere on the planet. While they might be perfect for the job, they could just as easily be in Kazakhstan doing a secret operation.

  • Captain America, currently a fellow out of time, is probably being brought up to speed and likely living in a SHIELD base while he catches up on the last sixty years of history. He would likely be very concerned if he knew of the kidnapping but no information had been made public at the time, so he would not be mobilized either.

Most importantly, in the comic genre, it is common for a superhero to be alone on a mission even though the world is slathered in potential metahumans who COULD be available but aren't. We are supposed to accept the idea superheroes are always engaged in something which occupies their time and makes them unavailable to the star of the comic we're reading. Comics poke fun at this sometimes when they have the Avengers call the Fantastic Four and Reed Richards answers from the Negative Zone saying he wishes he could help but they have their own problems.

enter image description here

Kevin Feige, Marvel Studios President stated in an interview:

Journalist: After cell phones came out horror directors had to come up with elaborate ways to explain why people wouldn’t call someone on a cell phone for help, now that all The Avengers know each other do you have to come up with excuses for why Tony Stark wouldn’t reach out when he needs a hand?

Feige: It’s a good question, and it’s sort of half and half. I am betting that like the comics you don’t have to keep – if you are reading a standalone “Iron Man” comic, they don’t spend every page explaining where every other Marvel hero is. The audience kind of accepts that there are times when they’re on their own and there are times when they are together. I’m betting that movie audiences will feel the same way. That being said, there is a little bit of lip service here and there to that. There is also just the very nature of Tony wants to, once he barely survives that house attack you saw today, and even you saw it in the message he left for Pepper, he’s basically saying “I’m going off the grid to try to figure something out.”

  • 1
    I think this pretty well covers it. The only thing I might add is this: in the comics, The Avengers are a standing team. There's an impression that some combination of their roster are always doing something together, working on some problem, defeating some supervillain, etc. For the movies, that's just not true. While we see, at the end of Avengers, that Tony and Pepper are making changes to the Stark Tower to allow it to be used as the equivalent of the Avengers Mansion from the comics, there's no impression that they're going to be working as a team, or partial team, on a regular basis. – Michael Scott Shappe May 8 '13 at 20:29
  • 7
    Note also that, as per the post-credits scene, Bruce Banner is contactable for non-emergency situations too. – Paul D. Waite May 9 '13 at 0:22
  • 3
    @PaulD.Waite but he's not that kind of doctor D: – Nil Jul 5 '13 at 2:21
  • 3
    I didn't say "they're all busy" and leave it at that. I gave both a canon precedence for why metas don't just appear when called, possible reasons for the Avengers to be doing something else and a producer's perspective on why they might not be available. If you find my answer lacking, write a better one. – Thaddeus Howze Sep 27 '13 at 17:36
  • 4
    And Thor also makes a point of indicating his arrival on Earth occurs at great cost to Odin, which is how they explain any reason he does not randomly appear otherwise. Marvel tried to keep things tidy. – Thaddeus Howze Sep 30 '13 at 2:15
9

Since the release of Thor: The Dark World and Captain America: The Winter Soldier, we can now answer this question more thoughroughly.

Spoilers for Captain America: The Winter Soldier, Iron Man 3, Thor and Agents of SHIELD below.

In Captain America: The Winter Soldier we learn that Hydra secretly infiltrated SHIELD in the early days of it's formation, and have been shaping world events ever since, including the death of Howard Stark and the assassination of JFK. They specifically mention that they have been funding terrorist groups, and as such it is safe to say that the 10 Ring Terrorist group (which turns out to be AIM) were funded by Hydra, and as such their activities were being masked from SHIELD from with in. This is further backed up by Hydra having access to Extremis in Agents of SHIELD (although at first they are at known as Centipede in early episodes).

This means;

Captain America, Black Widow and Hawkeye all work for SHIELD, and as such wouldn't have known that the events of Iron Man 3 were occurring as it would have been hidden from them in order to keep distruption to a minimum. Thor was off world fighting the rebellion caused by the Bifrost being destroyed in Thor. However, Bruce Banners location throughout what is known as "Phase 2" of the Marvel films is still currently unknown.

  • 2
    One minor nitpick - Centipede and Extremis are NOT the same things. Simmons described Centipede as a "cocktail" of power sources: Extremis, Gamma radiation, steroids, and more. The Extremis component WAS causing the overheating & explosions, though. – Omegacron Apr 17 '15 at 17:53
  • Even if Shield might not have been able to keep up with all of the Ten Rings activity, they couldn't have been totally in the dark. The "Mandarin" was broadcasting messages relating to his terrorist attacks, and I'm certain Shield has protocols in place to let them know if the President gets kidnapped. But you're right that Hydra could have conspired to keep them from finding where the President was taken – childcat15 Jul 15 '15 at 17:07
1

Although an answer has been selected, I'll give it a try.

The reason the Avenger's haven't been assembled is that the problem isn't important enough. The Avengers are assembled for really big threats - extradimensional/supernatural invasion or unstoppable machines out to exterminate mankind. A mere supervillain threatening the security of the USA falls under the heading of mundane and near-trivial. It's like the story of the Texas town undergoing a riot which called for help from the Texas Rangers and one Ranger showed up. His response to protests that they needed more help: "One riot, one Ranger".

Same with mere international terrorists: one villain, one Avenger. If Tony isn't up to the task, there's always time to get the rest of the team together. It's not as if humanity is in danger.

  • +1 Yes. The threat to the US President, though very worrying, is not an existential threat to the planet / all human beings - which is the threat level you need to unite the Avengers. Subsequent Avengers movies bear this out. – EleventhDoctor Oct 9 '18 at 10:11

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.