5

In the Star Trek: Voyager episode "Pathfinder" (Season 6, Episode 10), Reginald Barclay suggests opening a communication wormhole, and goes rogue when not getting permission immediately.

How did he know where to point it? The last communication between Voyager and Earth dates back almost 2 years (Message in a bottle), and Voyager had received a few jumps and boosts on the way. I feel it's basically impossible that it was pointed at the correct position.

7

Message in a Bottle (4x14) happened about half a year after The Gift (4x02), when Kes bumped the ship across Borg space, bringing them about 9,500 light years closer to home.

Given the importance of the Borg, the Doctor's debriefing in Message in a Bottle would likely have included this encounter. Additionally, Voyager was far closer to home than it should have been, so events in The Gift would have been included in the debriefing.

Given all the unknowns still hidden away in the galaxy (Iconian gateways, the Traveler, tricksters, spacial trajectors, and so on), that Voyager has already met such forces firsthand (both the Caretaker and Kes), and is now trying to seek them out for help, it seems likely that Starfleet would have kept this possibility in mind during the Pathfinder project, projecting a range of space they would likely be in, given the course Voyager was going to take.

And as we would expect with this information, during Pathfinder Barclay redirected the micro-wormhole numerous times before it opened near enough to Voyager for Seven to see it on the sensors.

He probably started at Voyager's most likely positioning (probably, where they should be if limited to only Warp drive), then each try was to a less likely location (closer to the Alpha quadrant, which would have required some sort of help).

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    There's an additional bit of pure speculation that I'm not sure should make it into the answer directly: Technology of civilizations in different parts of the galaxy seems to mimic each other. The Federation and others nearby developed transporters and replicators, while those didn't exist in the further reaches of the Delta quadrant. Species over there seemed more likely to develop transwarp technology, which was virtually unheard of near Federation space. This could also have been taken into account by Pathfinder, depending on how thorough the Doctor's debriefing was. – Izkata May 12 '13 at 3:37
3

Assuming this is not a case of writers not being up on the script and show specifics (which happened several times during the run of Voyager) the show attempts to set up the possibility of effective communication with several foreshadowing events. It is unfortunately likely the writers/producers did not take previous episode information into sufficient account. Some hand-waving is necessary.

Voyager had already predetermined flight plan at this point. This information was sent with the holographic Doctor two years prior. Voyager had already indicated the path they were going to take and had informed Starfleet. During the briefing with Admiral Paris, we are informed of the estimated path of Voyager. (As seen on the display during the briefing).

enter image description here

The second foreshadowing occurs a few seconds later when the commander continues with,

"As you know we've been working with the Vulcans on the deployment of the Midas Array. Though we are still in the testing phase, we think it won't be long before we can use this technology to send signals at 'hyper-subspace speeds', a message that would normally take years to reach its destination could be received by Voyager in a matter of days."

These regions were already determined and even if Voyager was far beyond those regions, the show sets up the notation of a "hyper sub-space communication channel" which would be far faster than normal subspace communication.

"Assuming they are still on course for Earth, we have established a likely course of trajectories. Estimating an average warp speed of 6.2 and accounting for various astronomical obstacles, we can reasonably assume Voyager is in one of these three sectors."

Even if Voyager were supposedly far from their estimated position, the singularity/wormhole was able to be detected by Seven of Nine in her highly specialized astrometrics setup designed for long-range scanning and the emergency beacon was clearly able to be distinguished and recognized by Voyager's crew.

Was there a degree of luck? Absolutely. But Barkley had also spent a significant amount of time knowing the limitations of both Voyager's technology and the Midas Array and had obviously compensated for the difference in location using the more advanced communication methods.

Was there the possibility of a mistake due to the miscommunication of writers? Very possibly, but the show was made with sufficient wiggle room to allow for some degree of fudging between episodes. It is unfortunate this episode is a lot less accurate than most.

| improve this answer | |
  • 1
    Let's not go out on a limb to defend the writers, here. When I saw this episode, I immediately noticed the continuity error here, and I think the writers just plain forgot. Voyager is WAY ahead of where they should be on their trajectory after two years, given all the leaps and jumps ahead they were able to make. There's no way Starfleet could have known this. I would have liked to give the staff the "wiggle room" of advanced tech or pure luck if they had thrown us ANY kind of bone with even a superficial explanation, but they didn't. It's just plain lazy writing. – Kim Rudolph May 12 '13 at 3:05
1

As there do seem to be some issues with the writing of some episodes; the best thing I have come up with that they could have worked with is that the Midas array created a wormhole that was fixed position on one end but variable on the other (as indicated with Barclay's comments about directing the wormhole toward different locations).

If instead of simply opening in precalculated sectors Voyager might have been in it were to have been such that the wormhole's other end actually opened at one point and moved at extreme speed along a trajectory/path of locations Voyager might have been located in and more than one possible trajectory was calculated based on what starfleet knew.

These trajectories would have had to span 30,000 light years or so but the Barzan wormhole apparently does that (lets ignore the laziness Voyager's season 3 episode involving said wormhole and that the Ferengi were stranded in the delta quadrant about 200 light years from the prior gamma quadrant terminus per TNG dialog).

The series had already established that wormholes can move around, so given this, Barclay's initial attempts should have been to use that to scan for where Voyager actually was (even if it took the computer a lot to sort out the mess of data it got back through the wormhole in either an active or passive scan). Lets assume it would only work right if you know what you are looking for.

| improve this answer | |
  • hi and welcome to stack exchange :) ... the "something does not have a place in an answer neither your 1st phrase before the edit. be careful about the Question and Answer. i recommend you take the tour and visit the Help Center. ;) – Rocket Dec 28 '14 at 7:42
  • I meant... the @somthing does not have a place in an answer** :P – Rocket Dec 28 '14 at 8:40
  • In TNG:The Price the Barzan probe ended up in the Gamma Quadrant but the Ferengi and the Enterprise shuttle travelled to the Delta Quadrant, with only the Enterprise shuttle returning before the mouth of the wormhole moved (possibly back to the Gamma Quadrant). So the events of VOY:False Profits is consistent with that. – CJ Dennis Oct 28 '15 at 23:02
  • The consistency issue with TNG is that Voyager had a position and trajectory which would not have EVER put the ship at a location in the Delta quadrant that is about 200 light years from ANY position in gamma quadrant. Voyager's path home never even took it within 5,000 light years of the gamma quadrant and it would not be until Voyager was about halfway home (give or take a few thousand light years) that the ship even came close to 10,000 light years of the gamma quadrant. Voyager seemed to be a magnet for everything that ever disappeared from earth or in an incident involving the federation. – Sequoia Treezilla Jan 17 '18 at 13:00

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.