12

I'm not sure whether this happens in the books - it's been a while since I've read them - but in the films at least, there's occasions when subject(s) of a given painting venture outside of its frame. In Prisoner of Azkaban, the Fat Lady goes into another painting after being scared off by Sirius Black. In Order of the Phoenix, Filch 'empties' paintings of their subjects, by shaking the frames hard enough. In Deathly Hallows - Part 2, subjects are seen rushing from painting to painting, seemingly 'getting out of the way' as the preparations take place for what is about to be the Battle of Hogwarts.

But how does this work?

Is there any explanation given by JK Rowling inside the canon, or in interviews on this?

Where did the subjects go during Umbridge's time as Headmistress - where did they 'hang out' during this short-lived exile from Hogwarts? Are they in their own alternate 'world' or 'space' and can travel to any adjacent painting and thus theoretically wherever they want to, within the painting 'world'? To find some other home, if kicked out of their (original) portrait?

Thanks.

  • Yes, there's a possibility of another magical dimension... – S S May 18 '13 at 13:38
  • 3
    This brings up another interesting question: are the people in the paintings actually sentient, or are they just "animations"? – ApproachingDarknessFish Jun 14 '13 at 7:43
  • 4
    @ValekHalfHeart - According to JKR, the portraits are impressions of a person as that person appeared in life and they do things like repeat catchphrases and characteristic mannerisms that the person did in life. Personally, I think both Dumbledore and Phineas Nigellus show sentience, but apparently that is not typical. I think JKR addresses portraits on Pottermore, as well as in interviews and Tales of Beedle the Bard. – Slytherincess Jun 15 '13 at 19:10
  • scifi.stackexchange.com/q/150249/4918 has an additional quote where Ron explains magical portraits to Harry when Harry first sees one. – b_jonas May 22 '18 at 8:06
  • They go wherever the plot takes them. – EvilSnack yesterday
12

The people in the portraits at Hogwarts were able to go into each others' pictures within the same building (As the fat lady did when she was scared out of her own, or when she wanted to drink wine in another portrait), and into pictures of the same subject in other locations (As did Phineas Nigellus Black and Ariana Dumbledore).

As for author statements, I only found this on Wikipedia (not my favorite source, but it's all I could find at this point.):

Authorial statements regarding portraits have been vague. Rowling made a comment in an interview that a portrait is something like a faint imprint of the person in question, imitating the basic attitude and thought patterns of the person. It is therefore completely different from a ghost, which, as explained by Nearly Headless Nick, are the souls of wizards who are afraid to leave the world. Portraits exist completely separately from the person's soul, being just an impression of the person passed on.[24] Rowling may have found inspiration in short stories by the French novelist Théophile Gautier (1811–1872). In La Cafetière (The Coffee Pot, 1831) and in Omphale (1834) people in portraits and tapestries come alive, step out from the wall into the room, drink coffee, dance, talk with and kiss the story-teller.[25]

  • 4
    The quote you cite appears in Tales of Beedle the Bard and is not vague. It's pretty definitive. JKR has also discussed portraits with The Leaky Cauldron and Mugglenet. Aside from the Wikipedia's assertion, is there verification JKR has read Théophile Gautier? Meaning, has she said so? If there is verification of her having read Gaultier, I truly have no problem with that section of the Wiki quote being in your answer, but if not, I think it should be removed as conjecture. The Wiki sources its information -- did you check on the source of the Gaultier statement? Sorry to be a wet blanket... – Slytherincess Jun 15 '13 at 19:05
4

They can go to others in the same building, or with their portrait.

People in portraits can visit any other portrait in the same building as theirs. They’re also able to physically interact with the other wizards in those portraits.

“They walked along the corridor, through a set of double doors and found a rickety staircase lined with more portraits of brutal-looking Healers. As they climbed it, the various Healers called out to them, diagnosing odd complaints and suggesting horrible remedies. Ron was seriously affronted when a medieval wizard called out that he clearly had a bad case of spattergroit.

‘And what’s that supposed to be?’ he asked angrily, as the Healer pursued him through six more portraits, shoving the occupants out of the way.”
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 23 (Christmas on the Closed Ward)

They can also go into things on the wall that aren’t portraits - the Fat Lady once hid in a map.

“And the Fat Lady, sir?’

‘Hiding in a map of Argyllshire on the second floor. Apparently she refused to let Black in without the password, so he attacked.”
- Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban, Chapter 9 (Grim Defeat)

They can go to any building where there’s a portrait of them, but they can’t just leave the building and go anywhere they want if there’s no portrait of them there.

“Everard and Dilys were two of Hogwarts’s most celebrated Heads,’ Dumbledore said, now sweeping around Harry, Ron and Professor McGonagall to approach the magnificent sleeping bird on his perch beside the door. ‘Their renown is such that both have portraits hanging in other important wizarding institutions. As they are free to move between their own portraits, they can tell us what may be happening elsewhere …”
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 22 (St Mungo’s Hospital for Magical Maladies and Injuries)

In addition, they’re also able to go to other portraits that are in the same building as their other portrait as well - this ability isn’t restricted to only one building with their portrait.

“Anyway, they carried him up a few minutes later. He doesn’t look good, he’s covered in blood, I ran along to Elfrida Cragg’s portrait to get a good view as they left –”
- Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix, Chapter 22 (St Mungo’s Hospital for Magical Maladies and Injuries)

Everard is able to hop between portraits in both locations he has one.


J.K. Rowling also mentions these rules for portraits in an interview.

So the other two reasons that I have for him not to speak to Dumbledore’s portrait, first of all, I created a lot of rules for this world and then later had to navigate my way around them. But this rule was always good, and the rule was that portraits could only move between portraits in the same building. so if I’m in a picture and you’re in a picture and we’re both in Carnegie Hall, then we can move into each other’s pictures. Otherwise we can only move only to other places where we have a portrait. You can’t just move willy nilly through all the – the Louvre, the Met – you can’t do a world tour, as a picture person. You are limited by geography.
- Carnegie Hall interview (October 20, 2007)

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.