6

In the Hulk movies he is portrayed as a dumb monster. They made him look completely mindless. I am concerned about it because within the Marvel Cinematic Universe he barely talks.

  • 6
    It is a common prejudice to associate lack of speech with lack of intelligence. It's just a prejudice though, with no basis in fact. I didn't see him as mindless, merely mute. – Donald.McLean Jul 10 '13 at 15:30
  • 2
    The Hulk is an exploration of rage and how we react to it. During the first two movies, he is not at peace with his rage - or the Hulk, and seems something closer to "mindless". By the events of The Avengers, he has come to terms with everything and is shown as being much further away from "mindless" - working as a team member, messing with Thor and directly reacting to Loki's taunts with speech of his own. – phantom42 Jul 10 '13 at 15:37
  • 1
    @phantom42 Ah, you mean "puny God" is more eloquent than "Hulk smash"? – Mr Lister Jul 10 '13 at 18:12
  • 2
    @MrLister, the fact that he's clearly responding to something someone said with something arguably thought out is definitely better than "Hulk smash". – phantom42 Jul 10 '13 at 18:26
  • remember the leadup to...World War Hulk i think it was? When he was on the other planet, he was very intelligent and talked quite a bit. – acolyte Jul 10 '13 at 20:40
10

All things being equal the character of the Hulk has had several permutations during his very long history where he did have the intellectual capacity of a five year old child. This is canon with the original premise of the Hulk as designed by Stan Lee and Jack Kirby in 1962.

Hulk is the alter ego of Bruce Banner, a socially withdrawn and emotionally reserved physicist who physically transforms into the Hulk under emotional stress and other specific circumstances at will or against it; these involuntary transformations lead to many complications in Banner's life. When transformed, the Hulk often acts as a disassociated separate personality that hates Banner. Over the decades of Hulk stories, the Hulk has been represented with several different personalities based on Hulk and Banner's fractured psyche, ranging from mindless savage to brilliant warrior, and Banner has taken control of the Hulk's form on occasion.

  • While this may be unsatisfying as a movie-goer, the character of the Hulk is not truly the central element in the Hulk storylines, Dr. Banner is.

  • This is most strongly seen in the early Hulk television series where the Hulk appears for five or ten minutes near the end of the show either to resolve violently a problem that generally could only be resolved with violence, or to screw up a potential friendship or relationship and cause Dr. Banner to move on.

Hulk Canon includes:

  • The Grey Hulk - transformed at night and reverted during the day, had some of Banner's intellect. This form would appear again many years later as Mr. Fixit.

  • The Green Hulk - abuse of the gamma machine which allowed him to control the Hulk's intellect lead to his Hulk persona growing more powerful and uncontrollable, spontaneously changing. His speaking was limited and memory impaired, almost never remembering what he did as the Hulk. In the early seventies, he had a moment of clarity when Jarella used magic to help him have Banner's intellect in Hulk's body.

  • The Savage Hulk - This is the Hulk most people are familiar with and the Hulk most seen in the first two Hulk movies. This Hulk has limited child-like intelligence, appears mostly when attacked and does everything in his power to escape conflict (after destroying what caused his transformation first).

  • The Professor - A version of the Hulk with Banner's intellect and the Hulk's abilities. During this time he worked with and eventually lead a group of metahumans called the Pantheon. It was during this time, Banner learned of an alternative future self known as the Maestro. The Professor appears to be the idealized version of the Hulk, all the power and all of the brains of his Banner form.

Hulk Movies

  • Ang Lee's Hulk (2003) - Seemed to reprise the early wandering years of Dr. Banner as his transformations into the Hulk were random and highly destructive. The Hulk was an engine of destruction whose intellectual capacity was more of cunning than true displays of intellect.

Marvel's Cinematic Universe

  • The Incredible Hulk (2008) - Edward Norton reprises the role of Dr. Banner and the Hulk's role appears only a bit more intelligent than Ang Lee's Hulk. Banner's role is larger and Hulk smashes even more stuff. Unfortunately, smashing military vehicles is fun to watch but not very interesting after a while. Which lead to the development of the Hulk's character in the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

  • When the Hulk appeared in the Avengers, the Hulk appears to retain much more of the mind of Dr. Banner than either of the two earlier movies. He is still destructive and powerful, but now appears to have both more control and an ability to discern who to harm. This has happened in the comic canon several times. Two examples of the Hulk retaining his intellect and abilities as the Hulk have been as Mr. Fixit and as the Leader of the Pantheon.

It has been shown that the time spent by Dr. Banner in learning to control both his rage and the Hulk transformation allows him now to instantaneously transform and maintain at least some of his intellect while he is the Hulk. Whether that will continue remains to be seen.

| improve this answer | |
  • but he doesnt talk just like the way he talks in animations for example, hulk vs wolverine. he talked. they should make him talk in the next avengers 2 movie. – user15891 Jul 10 '13 at 16:50
  • 1
    Animation is a medium where, in my opinion, it is less tolerable for a character who is present to not speak. Since they have the option for the Hulk to talk, he does. I personally think most of the animations make the Hulk the way he should be, terse, tense and a little bit surly. – Thaddeus Howze Jul 10 '13 at 17:13
  • @Thaddeus - Hulk's first hulk-out in Avengers was all about him trying to kill the pretty girl, fighting Thor, and tearing apart the Helicarrier. None of this strikes me as intelligent. – Wad Cheber stands with Monica Jun 1 '15 at 2:43
  • Five-year-olds can be quite talkative! – RDFozz Aug 17 '17 at 18:31
6

In the history of Hulk he went from talking to being a monkey many time. You can see in this topic how this is a open converstion: http://marvel.wikia.com/User_blog:RiderJones/Since_when_could_the_Hulk_talk_right%3F

As one of the people there says:

The Hulk's intelligence and conversational prowess has changed multiple times over the years. It all really depends on who is writing him. You know, artistic license. Other times it's because some other factor relating to his mutation has effected the ol' brainpan. For example, there have been times the Hulk only got less articulate when he got mad, or he was bombarded by more Gamma radiation. There was at least four or five times that the Hulk retained the intelligence and mind of Bruce Banner (notably a pretty long stint in the early 90's when he as the "Professor") and the Grey Hulk has always been pretty smart, but very cruel.

| improve this answer | |
2

In Avengers, Hulk does speak... "Puny God!" is uttered right after Hulk thrashes Loki soundly. I'd have to rewatch the recent Hulk movie (which leads into to Avengers) to be certain, but I seem to recall that he utters a few words there, as well.

Hulk, as a rage monster, is capable of speech, but has very little to say. The other problem is that if Hulk calms enough to be eloquent, he reverts to Banner...

... the telling comment comes from Banner, tho'; his control over his transformation is that "I'm always angry."

Even in the comics, Hulk generally is monsyllabic when he does speak. He's not, after all, Ben Grimm.

| improve this answer | |
0

Talking Hulk is cool but RAGE is the word here. How many of us talk when angry? Rage is mostly expressed by violent action! The Hulk is not supposed to 'think out' a solution but to just smash everything. Smash the whole place up until that becomes the solution! I think talking weakens the big green guy's super power. However, speech makes him smart which means he becomes the most powerful superhero ever. Which means he can defeat Superman! Stab him with a green Kryptonite shard not try to beat the life out of him.

| improve this answer | |
  • 2
    Does this have any evidence supporting it or is this just your theory? – Mal Aug 17 '17 at 2:06
0

To answer the question body rather than the title, he was already established as more than a mindless brute in his first Cinematic Universe appearance, in 2008's The Incredible Hulk:

In particular,

  • 4:50 where uses one of the ripped-off metal sheets as a barrier against the sound waves.
  • 6:30 where he protects Betty from the gunfire and crashing helicopter.
| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.