1

Is there any definitive canon relating to various races of Elves, and how they treat each other or is it pretty much up to each individual author as to how various races/subraces of Elves get along?

Examples:

Raymond Feist - Riftwar series - Several races of Elves, among them the glamredhel (mad elves), moredhel (dark elves), eledhel. They all mostly get along, and the eledhel actively try to break the power of the Dark Path to redeem their moredhel brethren.

Weis/Hickman - Dragonlance - Kaganesti, Sylvanesti, Qualanesti. Definite race striation, with the Kaganesti being seen as primitive and fit only for servants, with the Sylvanesti being the "highest" ranked race.

Tolkien - Falathrim, Sendar, Eldar - Various offshoots of the original 12/144 Elves (Tribes of Israel anyone?), generally all get along although they have some race wars (Wars of Beleriand) that can be attributed to the same reasons as human wars.

Given that Elves are one of the first "exotic" creatures and are a mainstay in fantasy fiction, is there an accepted reason for the variation in relationships among subraces or is that mainly an author preference to suit the flavor of the story being written at the time?

  • There are no rules whatsoever – Izkata Aug 10 '13 at 0:14
  • 7
    Knock! Knock! ::creak:: Good morning, sir. I am agent Fair and this is special agent Folk with the Elf Depiction Bureau. We'd like to talk to you about that novel you're working on. – dmckee Aug 11 '13 at 6:16
11

No, there is no "accepted practice."

Although elves originate in established Germanic mythologies, even in that context they're very loosely defined.

Tolkien took inspiration from the Germanic myths, but re-designed elven society/culture to reflect his idea of an Ideal Society. Due to the seminal nature of his work, many post-Tolkien works have been inspired by his elves--but not always by mimicking them.

It is the nature of speculative fiction to tease and play with established tropes, so although there are a set of common elven themes, not only are these established themes often contradictory, they're also often deconstructed and defied.

Thus, like any other fantasy construct, the nature of elves and their relationships have some common elements, but authors are rarely interested in adhering to those elements simply for the sake of tradition.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.