2

"Federation ship Enterprise, surrender and prepare to be boarded!"

I love this scene in Yesterday's Enterprise and have frequently considered the possibility of Worf delivering that line. Michael Dorn's voice would have been instantly recognizable to fans (that's always fun, to be a bit more in the know than dilettantes watching the show). We never see the Klingon that delivers that line, that would somehow make it more shocking. The best part though would have been the great multileveled nuance that casting would give the next line.

Picard: "That'll be the day!"

It almost feels like the line demanding the Enterprise's surrender was written for Worf.

The only conflict with canon that I can see would be if the attack on the Klingon Outpost Narendra III and the destruction of the Enterprise C happened after the Khitomer Massacre. In that case it would stretch incredulity (HA! Like that could ever in the Star Trek universe) that Worf could could become a Klingon ship captain. However, the Khitomer Massacre happened (correct me I'm wrong) on 11/10/2346 and the "C" was lost and presumed destroyed on 5/13/2344. Who knows? As long as the Battle of Naredra III happened before the Khitomer massacre, unless I'm missing something, it's anything goes. Maybe in the alternate timeline Mogh was the hero that destroyed the the Romulan Warbirds and saved Khitomer? (That's just a bit of hyperbole, not the question I'm asking)

The question is, is there anything I'm missing? Is there any reason (in-universe or otherwise) NOT to give that line to Worf?

EDIT

I'm finding it difficult to understand why this question has been closed as being opinion based. I'm not asking if it's a good idea or if it makes sense. I'm simply asking if there is any reason within canon that Worf could not have attacked the Enterprise during the alternate timeline of Yesterday's Enterprise or if anybody has any inside knowledge of the thinking of the writers.

FURTHER EDIT - NEW

MEMO

TO: Rick Berman

FROM: Michael Piller

DATE: Oct 3, 1989

SUBJECT: Pitch

Re: The Time Travel Story “Old Enterprise” by Trent Ganino…what about this as a twist… we’re in this routine action story when in flies this old Enterprise through a time warp, however we choose, and immediately, things change without anyone on board realizing it. Picard is still in command..Riker, number one, Data in position, but Worf is gone (in fact a member of an enemy crew) and Tasha Yar is at security…

The above is a quote from The Making of Yesterday’s Enterprise by Eric Stillwell (emphasis mine)

The question of the possibility Worf's involvement in this episode as it relates to Khitomer is uninteresting and circular. As evidenced by the memo quoted above, at least at one point the possibility played in the minds of the series creators. As an answer to this question I would like to know why the creators chose not to use Worf in that way, or if there is a reason within canon that I am missing. Because the Khitomer Massacre happened (in our timeline) long after the events on Nerendra III, it's irrelevant to this conversation.

As written, this question is answerable. As a matter of fact, having found the memo quoted above, I might very well be able to answer this question myself eventually, if the question were reopened.

closed as primarily opinion-based by Donald.McLean, Ward, Stan, NominSim, phantom42 Dec 28 '13 at 14:45

Many good questions generate some degree of opinion based on expert experience, but answers to this question will tend to be almost entirely based on opinions, rather than facts, references, or specific expertise. If this question can be reworded to fit the rules in the help center, please edit the question.

  • 7
    It seems to me that any answer to this question would be pure, random, blind speculation. – Donald.McLean Dec 28 '13 at 5:08
  • 1
    @Izkata The stardate Picard quotes at the beginning of YE is 43625.2. The calculator hillschmidt.de/gbr/sternenzeit.htm converts that to 8/17/2366. Data says the C was lost 22years, 3mo, 4days prior. That means 5/13/2344. I'm not sure how solid the calculator is, I'm actually planning to make that my next question. – Jolenealaska Dec 28 '13 at 5:39
  • 3
    @Jolenealaska Any answer to this question would be purely opinion based speculation, unless one of the writers stumbles upon it and decides to definitively answer it. You've already shown that the creative team thought of it in your memo, via what should be a definitive source, and you've pointed out that there is no way to know what happened to the house of Mogh in those 20 something years (for all we know Duras killed them all). There is really just no way to know. – Xantec Jan 3 '14 at 3:58
  • 3
    @Jolenealaska - I still don't think your edit is enough. The memo establishes that he had gone over to the other side for sure, but what is the connection between that and him saying the line? It's still reading as "this would have been cool so why didn't it happen?" – user8719 Jan 3 '14 at 8:30
  • 2
    Related meta discussion. – Beofett Jan 3 '14 at 21:04
1

I am fairly certain the answer is they just didn’t think about it.

However, a plausible answer is that since the Federation ship never rescued Worf he either ended up dead or on the Romulan prison colony.

  • Considering over two years between Narendra III and Khitomer, with a history very different from the "real" events, I'm not seeing it as inplausible based solely on the events of Khitomer in "our" timeline. – Jolenealaska Jan 2 '14 at 22:41
  • As evidenced by the memo I just quoted as an edit to the original question, "they just didn't think about it" is incorrect. – Jolenealaska Jan 3 '14 at 2:50
  • Actually I think this tracks, though it's a bit under-detailed. Worf's adoptive father was onboard the Intrepid when it responded to the Khitomer situation, which did take place after Narendra III. The likelihood of his taking a Klingon under his wing is far lower in the alt-universe. Chances are Worf ended up with the rest of the hostages in Birthright Pt 2, though it's hard to say for sure. – Stick Feb 20 '15 at 19:40

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.