[Spoilers] Why did Wednesday hire Mad Sweeney to pick a fight with Shadow? Did he intend for Shadow to get the magic coin? If so, then for what purpose? Obviously it didn't go according to plan, since Shadow resurrected his wife with it when Wednesday wanted her to stay dead. Wednesday also chastises him about holding on to his gifted coins when he gets the one from Zorya.

Then in Lakeside, Wednesday told Shadow to practice all of his tricks but the one Sweeney taught him. Why? There's also the fact that Low Key gave Shadow coins to practice with. It seems like they might have been grooming him for something other than just the sacrifice, but never made it that far. Did it have something to do with making him "King of America?"


Spoilers here too--When Sweeney accidentally gives the golden coin to Shadow, it likely was a mistake encouraged by Wednesday, as we later saw that Wednesday used the appearance of error often in his con jobs. Hiring Sweeney may have been only a pretext on Wednesday's part, to gain Shadow some protection at no cost to himself. Of course, Shadow was set on his own mythic path, and thus wasn't perfectly steered by Wednesday's intent, as shown when he threw his coin into Laura's grave. It isn't clear if Wednesday predicted that Zorya Polunochnaya would give her protection to Shadow, but he certainly wished to capitalize on it, and so warned Shadow to keep the silver coin.

Later, recognizing that Shadow was gaining some power of his own and becoming noticed as a result, Wednesday parked Shadow in Lakeside specifically to keep him out of sight of other gods and entities. Warning Shadow not to practice Sweeney's trick was one way to keep Shadow from recognizing his own nature and growing as a mythic hero, and thus becoming more visible to other mythic figures.

There are a lot of facets to what happens in American Gods, as Gaiman employs a lot of echoes and symbolism. Here, just as the magic of American Gods is both real and illusion, so too are the magic tricks Shadow is teaching himself, once he receives the magical coins.

As to being the King of America, that was a role that Odin was reserving for himself, not for Shadow. And Low Key, by teaching Shadow coin tricks in prison, was showing himself to still be a doomed trickster, giving Shadow the first nudge along a path that led to his and Odin's downfall.

  • What I don't understand is why Sweeney claims that he gave Shadow the wrong coin. Was it because the coin Sweeney gave Shadow allowed Laura to "live"?
    – RHPT
    Oct 6 '16 at 22:19
  • @RHPT Sweeney says it himself in the book. He was not allowed to give that coin and presumably bad things will happen to Sweeney unless he puts the coin back. This is not directly connected to Wednesday, but to Sweeney's own mythos with presumably King of fairies or something similar. The coin itself was of mythical power unlike the rest of coins, and , as I read it, not intended for mortals
    – Gnudiff
    Apr 22 '20 at 4:46

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.