11

The Klingons are not known for being defensive, so why is their space fleet named for defence? It should be called the Klingon Imperial Expansion Force, or the Klingon War Fleet.

I have some hypotheses:-

  1. The name is a translation artefact. The Klingon name actually sounds very aggressive, but Federation translators decided on a more euphemistic name. Out-of-universe, this is a reference to contemporary use of the same word. Is the Klingon name of the KDF actually mentioned anywhere, and if so, does it really include the word Hub?

  2. The name was imposed on the Klingons as part of the second Khitomer accord, like the Japanese after the Second World War. Is the name ever used before peace with the Federation (i.e. in TOS or Enterprise)?

I'd like confirming or disconfirming information for my guesses, or an official answer if one exists (e.g. quoting an interview), or a more plausible in-universe explanation.

  • 2
    Possibly a reference to the Israel Defense Forces – Kevin Jan 12 '14 at 17:49
  • 8
    Next time you see a Klingon ask him why they're such wussies. ;) – Meat Trademark Jan 12 '14 at 19:15
  • 3
    @Meat Trademark, perhaps today is a good day to die... – Valorum Jan 12 '14 at 19:26
  • I always thought it was an (out of universe) ironic commentary on both the translators and the klingon military's expansionist policies. I don't have any back up for this – SteveED Jan 12 '14 at 20:27
  • In TOS are they not just referred to as "Klingon Empire" ships? Perhaps the KDF was tasked with the defence of Klingon space and their role expanded. – Valorum Jan 12 '14 at 22:45
6

I can answer the question of whether the Klingon term for the KDF contains the term Hub - the answer is yes. The KDF is called tlhIngan Hubbeq in Klingon.

  • Cool. That rules out the translation artefact hypothesis: Hub is pretty unambiguously "defence". – Dan Hulme Jan 14 '14 at 18:44
5

There's actually a reason why they are known as the Klingon Defense Force..

As stated here : http://memory-beta.wikia.com/wiki/Klingon_Defense_Force

This could be a reason as they are named this way:

The Defense Force was known to consist of two elements, the first of which is the Deep Space Fleet (DSF) which consists of the regular naval forces. The second military group is the Internal Security Force (ISF) which operated smaller ships whose duties include policing rules, border patrols, anti-piracy duties, safety & rescue and customs along with tariff regulations. Their duty also extends to watching over client or conquered worlds to ensure they do not rise up against the Empire. However, despite its duties, the ISF is inferior to the DSF in political, military and even social standing. (TOS video game: Starfleet Command II)

The name could derived because they defend the empire through the ISF.

  • Nice detail. I don't see that it follows that the umbrella body would be called "defense" something, if it contains both the internal and the external fleets. It would make more sense if the KDF was originally the fleet that ran border patrols, alongside a Deep Space Fleet, and somehow took over the duties of the latter (through internal politics, or because the DSF mutinied or was completely destroyed in action). – Dan Hulme Jan 13 '14 at 17:56
2

Because this is what the armies of even the most expansionist empires tend to be called? One could argue that Nazi Germany had an ideology of racial superiority and expansion that was in some ways similar to that of the Klingons. Still, its army was called "Wehrmacht" which quite literally means "defense force", and afaik there never was an effort to change it to something more aggressive sounding. I know that this is not in-universe, but because of this real life example (I'm sure there are others) I do not think the name is paradoxical in any way.

  • Note that the Wehrmacht was basically a follow-up of the pre-Nazi Reichswehr. If Hitler had made up an entirely new name for his army, I'm not sure it would have been such a "defensive" one. – leftaroundabout Oct 31 '14 at 8:57
  • 2
    It could just be what it's called. My German isn't 100%, but in my own language (Afrikaans), every country's army is called its "weermag," meaning "defense force." The word "defense force" == the word "army," there's no other way to say it. As for why such a non-aggressive-sounding term would be used in Klingon, or why it would be a linguistic feature of Klingon, perhaps they mean to suggest that their military actions are always justified. Even if they're the aggressors, they're defending their own interests; the fact that you're in their way is your problem, not theirs. – Wolfie Inu Oct 9 '15 at 6:43
0

"Why Does the Klingon Defense Force have such a wussy name?"

Because their Federation allies kept objecting to titles like "the Klingon Exterminators of Enemies", The Klingon Aggression Force". "Thee Klingon All-Conquering Invasion Force" etc. etc.

Or maybe the Klingons use such a wussy name to trick other groups into thinking they are weak and attacking them, thus giving the Klingons an excuse to fight.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.