15

I've always wondered what would happen, and have asked my friends a few times, but without a satisfying response.

  • 9
    Kind of a speculative open-ended question, because it depends on the writer and the era. You could have the tardis filling up, or you could have an invisible barrier keep the water out. Depending on how the particular writer/crew wanted to take it. – Mark Rogers Feb 2 '14 at 20:07
  • 2
    @MarkRogers Without the barrier, woulde the tardis fill up, or would the oceans disappear into the depths of the tardis? – user14111 Feb 3 '14 at 4:01
  • 2
    @user14111: Whatever Moffat needs ;) – Voldemort Feb 4 '14 at 11:03
  • 2
    Man, ocean doesn’t have enough water to fill the TARDIS. – I Love You 3000 Feb 4 '14 at 12:12
  • 1
    Presumably either A: the Tardis floods or B: the atmospheric shell acts as a barrier like it did in the beginning of The Beast Below – Pharap May 28 '14 at 13:36
26

We actually see this in "Listen", where the TARDIS is opened underwater. With all of its systems working correctly, it simply remains trapped inside its own air bubble with the water held at a safe distance outside.

enter image description here

As to how this is achieved; in the episode "Logopolis" there is a lengthy discussion of the doctor's plan to open the TARDIS doors underwater. From this conversation we can deduce two main facts;

A substantial number of systems need to be shut down in order to allow water to enter through the doors

∴ Under normal circumstances, the doors can be opened without suffering a catastrophic influx of water

DOCTOR: No, how can we with the Master in the Tardis? They're a retiring people. They like a quiet life. There's no telling what a creature like that would do on Logopolis.
ADRIC: So how do we flush him out?
DOCTOR: And there's no saying what that might do to the Tardis systems. Can you swim?
ADRIC: Yes.
DOCTOR: Good. Materialise the Tardis underwater and open the door.
(Down in the Cloister Room, Tegan walks round the police box. The door opens invitingly. The Doctor calls up an aerial view of London on the scanner.)

DOCTOR: That's the River Thames. We'll put down there.
ADRIC: And water sluices in and floods out the whole Tardis.
DOCTOR: Yes. Adric, shut down everything. Fold back the Omega configuration. (Adric gets on the floor underneath the console.)
ADRIC: Folded back.
DOCTOR: Good. Exponential cross-field?
ADRIC: Halted.
DOCTOR: Good. Pathways to conditional states seven to seventeen?
ADRIC: Closed.
DOCTOR: Excellent. Main and auxiliary drive?
ADRIC: Ended.
DOCTOR: Good. Now, we're partially materialised, so there'll be a slight jolt. Are you ready? ADRIC: If you are.
DOCTOR: What? Well, I'd feel more confident if you just said yes.
ADRIC: Yes.
DOCTOR: Good. Here we go, then.

[Cloister room] (Tegan gets jolted.)

TEGAN: This is too much!

[Tardis]
DOCTOR: A gentle splash-down.
(Thud! They fall to the floor.)
DOCTOR: We must have touched bottom.
ADRIC: Touched bottom?
DOCTOR: Yes. Good thing the water was there to break our fall.

[Cloister room]
TEGAN: Crazy idiot of a pilot! Wait till I have a word with him.
(Laughter comes from the open door of the police box.)
TEGAN: Who's that?

[Tardis]
(The Doctor is standing braced across the doors.)
DOCTOR: Careful, now. The water pressure could send us both flying. Ready?
ADRIC: Yes.
DOCTOR: Now!
(Adric presses a button and runs to join the Doctor. The doors do not move.)

DOCTOR: That's odd. There's no pressure on those doors at all.
ADRIC: Perhaps we aren't down very deep. (The doors swing open and they step outside [onto dry land])

29

Since it's never happened on screen, any answer would be pure speculation. However, since we've frequently seen the Doctor open the Tardis door in deep space - in both classic and modern series - without the air rushing out, we can speculate that the same force would stop the water rushing in.

  • I remember an episode where River jumps from a building and the TARDIS catches her - she falls into the swimming pool. There is a large splash of water coming out of the TARDIS' doors, and then, the water comes back inside. Not sure if that proves anything, but that may suggest that there is no real water barrier around the TARDIS. But then again, the Doctor could've turned it off for the moment. But then again, all I have is speculation. – Voldemort Feb 4 '14 at 11:01
  • 1
    It has happened on screen. See above. – Valorum Sep 14 '14 at 8:10
5

In the episode The Beast Below, the Doctor references an "air shell". This allows a sustainable environment for the TARDIS and the residing occupants to have the ability to open the doors and be on the immediate outside.

The reason we often see the TARDIS constantly filled with water, I presume, is that the air field must be enlarged manually, otherwise it is automatically at a minimum. Or it just looks cooler.

  • 5
    “The reason we often see the TARDIS constantly filled with water” – we do? When? – Paul D. Waite Feb 4 '14 at 7:48
5

In Logopolis the fourth Doctor tried to land the TARDIS underwater in order to flood the TARDIS. Unfortunately we never saw what happened as the TARDIS materialised on a barge instead of dropping to the bottom of the Thames.

4

We see this at the start of Series 8, Episode 4 "Listen" where The Doctor does open the TARDIS doors underwater.

Nothing happens. The TARDIS maintains a shell around it which doesn't let any water in.

2

XKCD No. 969 addressed a very similar question for the first Narnia book, "the lion, the witch and the wardrobe".

enter image description here

Randall Munroe of XKCD has also estimated that it would take very long time to drain the ocean (Thanks b_jonas)

  • 1
    what-if.xkcd.com/53 is also related – b_jonas Feb 4 '14 at 11:49
  • 1
    Although a great comment, this does nothing to address the question regarding the TARDIS. – bitmask Feb 4 '14 at 12:12
  • True, it relates to user14111's comment to the question. That is, the ocean would not disappear. – Abulafia Feb 4 '14 at 12:21
1

TECHNICALLY, in the episode with Donna Noble, when she opened the TARDIS when David Tennant was Doctor, she asked why they were breathing. The doctor replied with the fact that there was an oxygen field surrounding the TARDIS, which would also mean that no water would be able to get inside when the shields are up.

0

Disney mermaid in the second left picture has the tardis also opening underwater

enter image description here

  • Hi, welcome to SF&F. What is the source of this image? Is it just fan art? – DavidW Jun 15 at 23:16

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.