8

At the beginning, the Robot is very much limited to his programming, a wealth of knowledge, but not expressing himself all that well - very logical and law-obeying with simple answers ('A-firm-a-tive', 'neg-a-tive'). Yet, by the end of series 3, he is willing to sacrifice himself for the Robinsons and is basically a human in robot form. Throughout the series, we see him bake a cake, fish and even play the guitar, and he regularly cites his programming in many different areas back at Earth. So, getting back to the question, is there actually a definitive point when the Robot becomes more human, or is it just gradual (although I seem to recall a major change from the end of series 1 to series 2, along with the color!)

  • So... then the question presents itself, are you sure it's the same robot? – Mr Lister Feb 28 '14 at 14:26
  • 2
    @MrLister Yes - it is still the B9 Environmental Control, non-theorizing, general utility robot they started with. It just seems to evolve and I was wondering whether there was a specific point of major evolution (eg a change in programming, alien encounter etc.) – Often Right Mar 1 '14 at 1:36
  • Even in the middle of the first season, the robot delivers some witty comebacks to Dr. Smith. – Anthony X Oct 14 '18 at 2:54
  • As I'm watching (still in the first season), I'm seeing a gradual episode-by-episode change; it's as if the robot is gradually developing a personality. – Anthony X Oct 21 '18 at 3:25
  • I just watched "War of the Robots" (Season 1 Episode 20). I was struck by the change in the robot's character. Unlike any of the previous episodes where it only displayed subtle hints of personality, in this episode, it speaks with much more emotive intonation than previously; in both words and actions, it quite clearly displays feelings, although it denies having them. As I continue to watch in episode order, not clear to me yet if this is a "one-off" anomaly or persisting change, but it is a very noticeable shift from the preceding episodes. – Anthony X Oct 24 '18 at 1:43
9

Interesting question..there are two possibilities for that happening in my view. the latter of the two of course, would be a logical reason.

the first, is that in the science of Lost in space, the robot was built and programmed as a true machine, with many facets of programming, and over time, it developed a personality via his experiences being recorded into his "tapes", ( will Robinson in one episode, refers to Dr smith wanting to erase the Robot's "tapes" and that would be "murder"..we also see in the 3rd season episode "The Time Merchant" The robot is sent back in time to retrieve Smith from earth that he deceived the time merchant into sending him to before the launch. When the robot arrived, his tapes were temporarily erased in the time travel process, and he was as he was in the first half of the first season, and of course to further the plot of this episode, he regains his memory and accomplishes his mission. it seems this kind of robot was created with a gradual learning process and the ability to develop a personality along with its artificial intelligence.

now in reality:

Lost in Space in 1966, was running opposite "Batman", and the batman TV series back then, was obviously very Campy, and quite silly..but it was raking in the ratings, so the story goes that Lost in Space had to do something to compete with it, and they decided to switch from stories of adventure and survival, to an "in kind" ridiculousness that Batman was pumping out..In addition, Jonathan Harris decided to change his character from an evil sneering villian, to a pathetic,laughable, and ridiculous buffoon, as he felt Smith as he was, would have no longevity, and would be killed off or written out sooner or later as the series progressed.. The stories then started to revolve mostly around Will robinson, Dr. Smith and the robot. Due to that also, is why the writers started to make the robot more like a human crew member than just a machine, with emotions, and snappy comebacks to Dr. smiths insults. In fact, once those changes were accomplished, Lost in Space's ratings shot UP, and it was a force to be reckoned with Batman. Unfortuantely, it lost all credibility with most true science fiction fans.

  • So basically, the answer is that it was a gradual process rather than something that happened at a specific point. – Often Right Mar 1 '14 at 3:23
  • 3
    That would be a correct assessment. But keep in mind, that it was from the production standpoint in reality, and they of course did their best to make it look like a development of the robots programming advancement that was "built in"..In any case, that's my "take" on it. – Zathras Mar 1 '14 at 4:34
1

I've been re-watching the show recently, working my way through the first season (the last time I watched it was during its initial run, and have only vague memories of it). I've chronicled it in comments; I think I've seen enough to build my observations into a meaningful answer.

A transformation appears to occur over a few episodes during season 1.

At the start, the robot is essentially emotionless; when confronted with human illogic (mostly from Dr. Smith), or given commands it is unable to execute, its responses have a mildly condescending tone. This tone doesn't suggest an emotional origin, just a dispassionate lack of tact or empathy. For the sake of comparison: on occasion, the computer on the Enterprise D (voiced by Majel Barrett) sometimes sounded a bit condescending too, but it was never ascribed any personality or emotional structure.

At about the tenth episode or so, the robot starts issuing witty comebacks to Dr. Smith, suggesting at least the hint of a personality.

In "War of the Robots" (season 1 episode 20), the robot's behavior can only be explained by emotion - jealousy and mistrust directed at the new arrival, concern over the welfare of the Robinson family, hurt over no longer being needed, despite its denial of having feelings. Some of the robot's lines are delivered with obvious emotive intonation.

In "The Challenge" (season 1 episode 22), the robot laughs at Dr. Smith on a couple of occasions, although it denies doing so. It also holds opinions and a dislike for Dr. Smith, while remaining at least reluctantly obedient to him.

There seems to be no canon explanation for the robot's emergence of a personality - no cause is ever stated or even suggested on-screen, although its apparently emotional behavior is occasionally noticed and questioned by the Robinsons and Smith.

From a production perspective:

These changes coincide with the premiere of the Adam West Batman series. In response to this new competition for viewers, Wikipedia states that the show became more campy. The endowment of a personality to the robot seems to have been part of the show's over-all transformation.

-1

There was a lot of talk in the fist season about dr smith reprogamming the robot. First to play chess, then making him a valet/bodyguard. Watch the two-part episode (3 and 4 of y1 i believe) and you can watch guntecr "come to life".

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.