12

In Nolan's Dark Knight, Batman (or rather Lucius Fox) develops a technology which allows using a phone as a mini-radar (I didn't quite catch if it was using EM like radar or sound like sonar, but given this is Batman I wouldn't be shocked if it was sonar).

  1. Was this technology detailed anywhere as being hardware based or software based?

  2. If it was stated as hardware based, how exactly did Batman manage to equip pretty much everyone in the entire city with a new phone containing that hardware in the short time period that the movie takes place in? If it was software based, how did he download the software to both emit and receive the signals onto EVERYONE's phone without the cell companies objecting[1]?

I am looking for answers from canon (movie, script, DVD, delete scenes); creative team interviews; or if there are specific DC comics that Nolan based the movie on, I'm ok with answer from those specific comics if it matches up to the movies.

[1] If it was software, I would accept an answer listing the (canon) fact that Wayne was a major cell carrier in Gotham

h/t: Based on a comment on another post.

2

1 Answer 1

12

How did it work?

When Lucius Fox and Bruce Wayne are discussing the device (around 33 minutes in), we learn that the device really is powered by sonar:

[Lucius hands Bruce a phone]

Bruce: What’s this?

Lucius: I had R&D work it up. It sends out a high-frequency pulse; records the response time. For mapping an environment.

Bruce: Sonar. Just like a…

Lucius: Submarine. [nodding]

We get confirmation that it’s sonar at the 1 hr 56 min, when Batman shows Fox his mass-scale implementation of the idea. As far as I know, this is also the closest we get to knowing whether it’s software or hardware.

Batman: Beautiful, isn’t it.

Lucius: Beautiful? Unethical. Dangerous. You've turned every cellphone in Gotham into a microphone.

Batman: And a high frequency generator-receiver.

Lucius: You took my sonar concept and applied it to every phone in the city. With half the city feeding you sonar, you could image all of Gotham.

Unfortunately, I think that the software/hardware distinction is ambiguous:

  • The word “turned” suggests that this is a modification to existing phones. Lucius also says “every phone in the city”, which is impossible if you have to upgrade all the existing hardware. (You might get good coverage, but not complete coverage.)

    That would suggest a software patch, probably distributed virally or through the cellular carriers (more on that shortly).

  • On the other hand, this is the first time Lucius has seen the technology. Anything he says about it is necessarily a guess; he doesn’t know how this actually works, or he would have tried to stop it. Custom hardware is very plausible.

    Further, as your answer on What is the time frame for Batman Begins, The Dark Knight and The Dark Knight Rises? attests, The Dark Knight is set in 2008. In the real world, I doubt this level of monitoring could be achieved with 2008-level phone hardware. In the real-world, he’d need to have added custom hardware for this to work. (So how much does Batman-world tech mirror the real world?)


How was it distributed?

I don’t know if Wayne Enterprises were a major phone carrier in Gotham (it wouldn’t surprise me, but I can’t find canon either way), but they might have some good links. At the 59 minute mark, there’s this very telling conversation between Bruce and Lucius:

Lucius: Did you reassign R&D?

Bruce: Yep. Government telecommunications project.

Lucius: I wasn’t aware we had any Government contracts.

Bruce: Lucius, I’m playing this one pretty close to the chest.

I can’t find anything else in the film that this conversation might be referring to, so I assume that this is Bruce reassigning R&D to build his large-scale sonar device. The “Government project” line suggests that he’s using his political influence to force this change through, so nobody is objecting. (Or at least, not loud enough to make a difference.)

There isn’t more detail on the Government’s involvement. I doubt they would allow him to spy on everybody in Gotham, so there’s probably a smokescreen to hide the true purpose from the officials. Or perhaps Lucius is right: the reason he doesn’t know about the Government contracts is because they don’t have any, and Bruce is going behind their backs.


Batman Wikia

The Batman Wikia article about the lenses says that it was a computer virus, but doesn’t source this assertion:

Batman later innovated the idea to an extreme, writing a virus that inserted the program into every cell phone in Gotham

It also alludes to an interview with Christopher Nolan where he might have discussed the lenses in more detail, but it doesn’t provide a link and I haven’t been able to find it.

When asked in an interview along with Christopher Nolan, Christian Bale said that the device was put into the cowl by Lucius Fox, who first invented the gadget, and it was part of his entire suit which helped him see better in the film.

3
  • 5
    I bet that drains their phone batteries!
    – Liath
    Apr 25, 2014 at 10:49
  • Since this sort of capability is doable with any computerized device that has both a reasonable quality speaker and microphone, it doesn't make sense to use hardware to deploy this capability unless Wayne Enterprises is already positioned as a major supplier of mobile chipsets, like Foxconn IRL. But if Wayne Enterprises does, in fact, provide OEM parts to all major handset makers, then those hardware components would give him the perfect backdoor through which to distribute the software, across all carriers (with time). Apr 25, 2014 at 17:32
  • How long their Battery Power remains ? Jun 3, 2014 at 9:37

This site is temporarily in read-only mode and not accepting new answers.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .