31

In Revenge of the Sith after Luke and Leia are born, they are sent to separate parts of the galaxy. The droids are given to Captain Antilles, with the instructions to clean them up, and have C-3PO's memory wiped. Why just C-3PO's and not also R2-D2's?

Initially I thought it was due to R2-D2's inability to communicate verbally, but he not only can communicate via text message (as seen in The Empire Strikes Back I believe), but we see other characters understanding his blips and bleeps as well.

  • 1
    Did R2D2 see the delivery (of Luke, Liea) too? That could be major problem. – Captain Cold May 5 '14 at 0:10
  • @SachinShekhar Had to double check that scene but just watched it and they are both witnesses to the delivery. Though the scene where the decisions on where to hide them are made does not appear to have either of the droids. – NominSim May 5 '14 at 0:13
  • As we now know, the rebel Alliance was founded by Yoda, Obi-Wan Kenobi and Bail Organa. At the end of Revenge of the Sith, Bail Organa orders 3PO's memory wiped but not R2's. What can readily be deduced is that one of their first recruits was R2-D2. – Stefan Urziceanu May 29 '14 at 14:12
  • 1
    @StefanUrziceanu: well indeed. – Paul D. Waite May 30 '14 at 9:05
  • 1
    Because C3PO is an Idiot, and R2 is not. Also it seems funnier in that situation, I guess. That's what Lucas uses C3PO mainly for in EP 2&3, being funny. – kratenko Nov 25 '15 at 9:48
50

This is mentioned in the film's official novelisation.

Echoing @Envite's answer, the fact is that C-3PO opened his fool mouth at the wrong time;

“I’m placing these droids in your care,” the Senator said. “Have them cleaned, polished, and refitted with the best of everything; they will belong to my new daughter.”

“How lovely!” C-3PO exclaimed. “His daughter is the child of Master Anakin and Senator Amidala,” he explained to R2-D2. “I can hardly wait to tell her all about her parents! I’m sure she will be very proud-“

“Oh, and the protocol droid?” Senator Organa said thoughtfully. “Have its mind wiped.” The captain saluted. “Oh,” said C-3PO. “Oh, dear.”

34

Quite clearly, C-3PO is unable to shut up, while R2-D2 is quite able to keep a secret.

We're looking for long answers that provide some explanation and context. Don't just give a one-line answer; explain why your answer is right, ideally with citations. Answers that don't include explanations may be removed.

  • 2
    This does not provide an answer to the question. To critique or request clarification from an author, leave a comment below their post. – HorusKol May 5 '14 at 7:16
  • 10
    For me, the answer is that "The reason for which C-3PO memory was deleted is that it is unable to keep a secer, and the reason for which R2-D2 memory was not is that it is known to be able to keep it". I am not critizicing anything, nor requesting clarification. I'm providing an answer. – Envite May 5 '14 at 7:59
  • 1
    This was my first thought, as well, since there is no canon reason that I'm aware of. It'd be better if you expanded the answer a little bit, perhaps providing an example or two of 3PO's motor-mouth, or instances where R2 clearly held his... not-tongue? – phantom42 May 5 '14 at 10:46
  • hmm - I didn't realise that the "critique or request clarification" part was tacked on there... I meant more that this is an off-the-cuff response, and would be better suited as a comment - unless you want to flesh out with supporting evidence from the movies or the EU? – HorusKol May 5 '14 at 23:45
  • 7
    C-3PO shuts up all the time. All it takes is an angry wookiee. – James Sheridan May 6 '14 at 1:46
7

I am unaware of any direct statement on the reason for this by anyone involved in Lucasfilm, but after the release of RotS, the Expanded Universe trilogy The Dark Nest was published, in which Luke finally discovers the identity of his mother due to a malfunction in R2-D2. R2-D2 had kept the knowledge that Luke's mother had died in childbirth from Luke as part of his "owner-protection protocols," which explains why the droid had not revealed Luke's true identity or that of his mother (or father, prior to TESB) during the original trilogy.

It is highly likely that George Lucas had input on this storyline; it was Lucasbooks favourite - and the favourite of no Star Wars fan ever - Troy Denning who wrote The Dark Nest Trilogy, and there is a good chance he was given that role to keep other authors and comic book writers from fighting over who got to reveal Amidala as Luke's mother in the EU. This was after the switch from Bantam Books to in-house publisher Lucasbooks in 1999; George Lucas took a far more hands-on role with the EU at this point, to its detriment.

EDIT: To add to my answer now that I'm home, the novel that contains the revelations about Luke's mother is The Swarm War. There is also a section of this in R2-D2's Wookieepedia entry:

In 35 ABY, when Luke was fixing R2-D2, the Jedi encountered a recording of his father and mother discussing a dream of Anakin's in which his mother had died in childbirth, and another recording of Padmé talking to Obi-Wan Kenobi about Anakin. The recordings, however, were apparently encoded, probably by Alderaanian technicians. R2-D2 himself refused to show Luke or Leia the recordings and insisted he was trying to protect them. The only way to remove the recordings safely was to either find the original designers of the unit, a prototype, or erase R2-D2's memory, an idea only C-3PO seemed to take seriously. Because the recordings hadn't been removed, R2-D2 began to malfunction. By 36 ABY, a year after the first recording was shown, R2-D2 seemed to be functioning again, though he remained unwilling to show the recordings. It wasn't until the Swarm War, when Luke needed to see it to help him in his fight against Lomi Plo, that R2-D2 finally revealed Padmé's death to Luke, as well as his and Leia's birth, and an image from a Hologram inside the Jedi Temple showing Vader and the 501st carrying out Operation: Knightfall at the exact moment Artoo hacked into the Jedi Temple Security system and watched Order 66 happen at the Jedi Temple on Coruscant.

Unfortunately, I still can't find a reason for this, but it would seem it was done so the cheap, cop-out reveal could be executed in The Swarm War.

2

The answer comes down to the relative value of the droids.

During all 6 movies we very rarely come across other protocol droids, but many astromechs are on screen. In one scene, R2D2 is repairing a ship in flight mid battle with a few other droids all of which are destroyed. Astromechs were also present in most fighters, of which most were destroyed on screen.

Astromechs are low value grunt workers who are are frequently destroyed on screen, and I would assume would be treated as such by the people they were assigned to.

The flippancy with which Bail Organa gave the order to wipe C3POs memory shows how little he valued the robots individuality. To him, it was a tool, and a tool that had vital information unnecessary to its function. Why bother wiping the Astromechs memory when it shows little communication skill and will probably be destroyed at some point soon.

No doubt Bail Organa instructed R2D2 (and other droids) into innumerable hazardous situations between Episodes 3 and 4 with as much concern as he has for any other tool.

1

R2-D2 was obviously part of the Rebellion beyond what anyone would believe a droid to be.

Now, with Star Wars Rebels, it is pretty obvious they are setting up R2 as an interegral member to the Alliance/Rebellion, as he has already shown up without any accompanying characters (save Ahsoka), but the funny thing is that R2 could even reveal Darth Vader's identity to her - and he hasn't.

Plus, it's pretty obvious that Star Wars Rebels is trying to apply a more human personality to droids by having the Chopper character.

Oh well, who knows what they will do, now that Disney scrapped the years and years of Extended Universe.

-2

The real answer comes from behind the scenes. Lucas to this day envisions Star Wars as being narrated from a point in the future (hence "a long time ago") and R2 is that narrator. So R2 had to have all memories intact. Unfortunately there is no logical in story answer.

  • 2
    Can you offer any evidence to back up these bold statements? – Valorum Oct 14 '18 at 17:05
  • This is only an answer if you can offer canon evidence that the entire Star Wars saga is being narrated by R2-D2, or that this is Lucas' intention. – F1Krazy Oct 14 '18 at 19:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.