6

I watched Inception again and I started scratching my head again, which lead with a series of Google searches that made me scrach my head even more.

When watching the movie, I assumed that Saito was an old man in limbo and Cobb young because Saito died in the third layer (the snowed fortress) and Cobb died drowned in the car, since he didn't wake up. So the deeper you go the slower time feels, so that's why Saito is older while Cobb isn't. Am I wrong? I probably am, please explain.

I thought this was it, but then I read this answer and made me wonder. If Cobb entered limbo with Ariadne trying to rescue Fischer and decided to stay, how did he seem to re-appear in limbo washed up on the beach? Wasn't he already in limbo? Why does it seem like he just re-entered it again?

7

You've asked two separate questions here. I'll try to approach them in order:

Why Saito is older while Cobb remains the same age

You're absolutely right. Saito is older than Cobb because he's been down in Limbo much much longer. Not only is there a dramatic time differential but he's also unaware of the dream nature of his existence and is expecting his age to continue increasing.

ARIADNE : How long would we be stuck there?

YUSUF : You couldn't even think about trying to escape until the sedation eases

EAMES : How long?

YUSUF : Decades - it could be infinite - I don't know! Ask him - he's the one who's been there before!

Cobb later clarifies:

ARIADNE : And if he dies?

COBB : His conscious mind will drop out of the dream. He'll be trapped in Limbo for a lifetime...

Washing up on the beach (again)

This one's a bit trickier. Cobb shepherds Ariadne out of Limbo, then in the next scene we see him back at the beach.

Ignoring any out-of-universe answers, the simplest explanations are:

  • Cobb briefly left Limbo when Mal died (possibly but highly unlikely)

  • Cobb was so distracted when Mal died that it somehow resulted in him returning to Limbo location #1, the Beach (possible but unlikely)

  • Cobb has spent years searching Limbo for Saito's fortress. The beach just happens to be where we catch up with him (this imho is the most likely option, especially when we take into account that Cobb has aged and grown a beard, indicating that a great deal of time has passed.


Out of universe, it's a nod to the idea that dreams often take non-linear paths.

Nolan speaks to the fact that any scene involving Cobb is filled with ambiguity and misdirection;

"He’s an untrustworthy narrator"

"...you need to doubt Cobb"

  • Wasn't 100% the intention of the first header, but it seemed incomplete, feel free to rollback if I've missed the mark. – Möoz Dec 2 '16 at 4:35

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.