5

In the Pilot episode of Gotham we see that Gordon is a war hero. Also, at the end of the episode, Harvey said that Gordon has killed people before, in the war.

What war was that? I didn't find anything on Gordon's Wikipedia page.

Is this something new for the Show, or has it been mentioned on the comics?

  • 1
    I'm pretty sure this is a new back-story just for the TV show. – Moogle Sep 23 '14 at 9:21
  • 10
    He fought in The War. You wouldn't understand that, because you weren't there, man. – Valorum Sep 23 '14 at 11:44
  • The first mention I remember of Gordon being a "war hero" kind of guy was back in the 80's when Batman was first entering into the "dark, gritty" phase of continuity. That timeframe would have made it Vietnam, but obviously they're not using that in the TV show - he'd have to be in his 60's or 70s if that were the case. – Omegacron Sep 23 '14 at 20:22
6

No -- it is unlikely they will define which war it was. See this question and answer: What time period is Gotham set in?

The aesthetic of this show is that there specifically is no time period.

Calling it just "The War" was certainly intentional.

1

As far as I know, the show did not say anything specifically that would let us pin down what year it was, including the specific war that James Gordon fought in. However, we can make some educated guesses based on things we saw.

Probably the most obvious bit of information we have are the phones everyone was using. It appears that, at the time the show is set in, that small flip-style mobile phones are in common use, but smart phones are still not available. The iPhone came out in 2007, and within a year or two were widely deployed, so my guess is that the show is set some time prior to 2007. Rather, flip-style cell phones (e.g. the one that Fish's goons carry) seem to be popular, which would place the show sometime in the early 2000s, possibly very late 1990s.

With that in mind, the most likely answer is that James Gordon fought in the Iraq War in 2003, and the show is set sometime between 2003 and 2007.

(BTW: This estimate makes it unlikely that the show can be viewed as a prequel to any f the existing Batman comics or movies; for example, assuming Bruce Wayne was in his early 20s in Batman Begins*, he would have been 8 around 1990 -- ten years too early to match Gotham.)

  • yeah, I thought about that but he looked too young to be in the army in 1992 and just starting out as a detective in 2003... he'd be more like the age of his partner. But I suspect we'll probably find out more as the show goes on. – KutuluMike Sep 23 '14 at 13:32
  • Isn't Gotham supposed to be totally standalone from any of the previous Batman franchises? Does the time setting of Batman Begins officially figure into anything? – phantom42 Sep 23 '14 at 13:36
  • It's also possible that Gordon fought in Afghanistan (2001 onwards). – Royal Canadian Bandit Sep 23 '14 at 13:52
  • 1
    “It’s a mash-up, to use the modern phrase. [...] So in your memory, the past is all mashed up together. If today Batman exists, then this world is the past. But it’s everybody’s past, an 18-year-old’s past and a 54-year-old’s past. So in your memory, the past is all mashed up together. So in this Gotham, it’s a kind of timeless world. It’s yesterday, it’s today, and it’s tomorrow all at the same time, because that’s the world that dreams live in.” says Gotham showrunner Bruno Heller – BCdotWEB Sep 23 '14 at 14:13
  • 1
    I thought it was supposed to be sort of anachronistic, like the Batman: The Animated Series. Sort of a mash up of different technologies and architectures so it could be taking place at any point in time. – Monty129 Sep 23 '14 at 17:18
1

The Rolls Royce Phantom came out in 2003 which is the same vehicle Bruce Wayne uses. Ben McKenzie (Gordon) is 36 years old. David Mazouz is 14 years old. Christian Bale was 31 when batman begins came out. Gary Oldman was 47.

Enlistment age is 18 and training would take about a year, meaning the youngest he could have been is 19 (lets just round it to 20). So he could have served for about 10 years (accounting for 6 years to go from academy to detective)

As the show doesn't have widespread use of smartphones we can assume that show starts before 2010 so he could have been a soldier from 1987 to 2004 (upper and lower bounds)

If we go by our timeline then he could have fought in:

  • Afghanistan (7th October 2001 – present)

  • Kosovo (28th February 1998 – 11th June 1999)

  • Bosnia (6th April 1992 – 14th December 1995)

  • Battle of Mogadishu (1993)

  • Gulf war (2nd August 1990 – 28th February 1991)

Given the way they talk about it, the most likely (imo) is the battle of Mogadishu, and even at the latest point he could start to serve he could would have been able to fight in it. The movie Black Hawk Down came out in 2001 making him somewhat famous.

However, the DC universe is not the same as ours and the war could have been anything if they have an alternative universe to ours. This would also explain the the use of cars from different time periods and the abnormalities. Also the difference between the Nolan Batman age and Gotham is 17 for Bruce Wayne and 11 for Gordon. So it could be a sign that its a completely different universe as compared to the Nolan universe which is very similar to our own.

  • Welcome to the site. This is a stellar first answer, but in the future, please use proper capitalization and sentence structure. Well reasoned and compelling answers are still likely to be downvoted if they are poorly formatted and difficult to read. – Wad Cheber stands with Monica Aug 6 '15 at 18:57
1

TL;DR: We don't know specifically what war the Gotham-continuity Gordon fought in, but the trope of Gordon being a war hero and/or ex-military has been around since at least the 80's.

What War was Gotham Referring To?

We don't know. Gordon's past hasn't been discussed much in the show so far. In fact, the dialogue you're referring to is probably this conversation from the pilot:

JIM: She said you had to keep me, huh?

HARVEY: Yeah, she did. She said you were a war hero and your daddy was a big shot D.A. back in the olden days, so I have to keep my trap shut and do as I'm told.

JIM: Ouch.

HARVEY: Listen, kid, you got juice; do me a favor. Ask for a transfer.

JIM: Sorry, this is where the action is. You'll get used to me.

Given that Gotham isn't assigned to any particular time period, the writers have probably decided to leave such references vague. After all, mentioning a specific conflict would tie the show down time-wise, which is something they're trying to avoid. However, given that the show appears to be a blend of vehicles, technology, & culture from within the past 30 years, we can speculate that "the war" is referring to either Vietnam or one of the numerous conflicts in the Middle East.


Is This Something New or From the Comics?

Actually, the idea of Jim Gordon being ex-military has been around for quite some time - it's just not a major trait of the character. Here are some examples:

  • The Dark Knight Returns (1986): An aging Jim Gordon in his 70's makes a reference to serving in WWII, comparing Batman to Franklin Roosevelt.
  • Batman: Year One (1987) - Jim Gordon is stated to be former Special Forces in the US Army.
  • Gordon has made several references in the comics to having "seen combat", or knowledge of how men react when under heavy fire.

This was also alluded to in the 2012 film "The Dark Knight Rises", during an exchange that takes place when Gordon leaves the room:

Foley: You should spend some more time with the Mayor.

Gordon: Well, that's your department. [walks off]

Congressman: Anyone shown him the crime stats?

Foley: He goes by his gut and it continues to bother him, no matter what the numbers.

Congressman: Must be popular with his wife.

Foley: Not really. She took the kids and left for Cleveland.

Congressman: Well, he'll have plenty of time for visits. The Mayor's gonna dump him in the spring.

Foley: Really?

Congressman: Mm-hmm.

Foley: But he's a hero...

Congressman: A WAR hero. This is peace-time.

Although some of this could be referring to the "war" against crime, much of it comes together to paint the picture of a military veteran.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.