20

I have always wondered why Dumbledore didn't have his broken nose "magic-ed" back into place. It is a nice character element with his half-moon spectacles, etc. but one wonders if it is intended to infer that he carried it as a mark of shame and responsibility over the death of his sister, his nose having been broken by his brother at their sister's funeral.

Is there anything more than speculation and inference on this small detail?

  • 3
    Wait What!!! Do all high level magic guys have nose problem? – Baby Yoda Oct 1 '14 at 16:53
  • 4
    @SachinShekhar -- It does seem to be a requirement for the really top notch, master wizards, doesn't it? Voldemort's nose was snake-like, and even Snape's nose is described as hooked and unattractive. Heck, even Harry gets his nose broken by Draco in book six (although Harry is not exactly a master wizard -- he's competent, but he's no Dumbledore). – Slytherincess Oct 2 '14 at 0:20
21

I do think this is speculation and inference, the broken nose being a mark of shame, that is. Deathly Hallows tells us:

‘Oh, Aberforth is just the tip of the dungheap,’ laughs Skeeter. ‘No, no, I’m talking about much worse than a brother with a fondness for fiddling about with goats, worse even than the Muggle-maiming father – Dumbledore couldn’t keep either of them quiet, anyway, they were both charged by the Wizengamot. No, it’s the mother and the sister that intrigued me, and a little digging uncovered a positive nest of nastiness – but, as I say, you’ll have to wait for chapters nine to twelve for full details. All I can say now is, it’s no wonder Dumbledore never talked about how his nose got broken.

Deathly Hallows - page 28 - Bloomsbury - chapter two, In Memoriam

If Dumbledore did or did not fix his nose due to guilt and shame, it sounds like he never told anyone, either way.

J.K. Rowling has said that magic doesn't heal all wounds. Perhaps a nose broken out of anger can't be healed by magic, especially if it's righteous anger. For example, look at Mad-Eye Moody -- he was covered in scars from injuries, and lost both an eye and a leg, and there is no indication in the books that Moody chose these injuries instead of having them magically healed. Canon suggests that Moody's wounds could not be healed; Molly Weasley notes in Deathly Hallows that injuries caused by Dark Magic cannot be magically healed, which is why George had to go without his ear.

As J.K. Rowling has said about Snape and his poor hygiene and bad looks, perhaps, regarding Dumbledore's slightly disfigured nose, Dumbledore valued other qualities in himself than his looks and therefore never had his nose fixed.

However, according to Rita Skeeter, we will never know for sure!

  • 10
    AFAIK, Moody was covered with unhealable scars because he was an Auror fighting Dark Magic users and damage caused by Dark Magic can't be healed: see also Bll's face scars and George's lost ear. I don't think there's anything in the books about "righteous" punches being unhealable, and it seems really out of character for the world-building, I feel. – Shisa Oct 1 '14 at 7:53
  • 2
    Re: righteous punches, it was just a passing thought that occurred to me; I'm not married to the idea or anything. I did mention wounds from Dark Magic as not being able to be healed -- Moody and George in particular. Perhaps you overlooked that? :) – Slytherincess Oct 1 '14 at 12:26
  • @Julldar - Yes, I made a mistake in my math. Sorry. However, you apparently don't actually know Slytherincess, and I do and when she says it isn't her style, I believer her. And this whole comment thread isn't really appropriate for comments and should be taken to chat. – Donald.McLean Oct 1 '14 at 17:24
  • I think the beginning of this response stands alone, without dragging things Rowling has said outside of the books into it. – Matt Jan 6 '17 at 20:55
5

He may have decided to leave his nose crooked as a daily reminder of what his desire for power had cost, to keep himself from being tempted in the future. His broken nose was given to him at Arianna's funeral by Aberforth. Dumbledore felt personally responsible for her death, and it was a turning point in his life. For the rest of his life he was wary of being tempted by power and returning to his old ways.

I, meanwhile, was offered the post of Minister of Magic, not once, but several times. Naturally, I refused. I had learned that I was not to be trusted with power.

...

I was safer at Hogwarts. I think I was a good teacher

Dumbledore has also said before that remnants of injuries can be helpful or serve a purpose, which is why he wouldn't have healed Harry's scar even if he had the power.

Scars can come in handy. I have one myself above my left knee that is a perfect map of the London Underground

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.