If the sandtrouts turn water into a pre-spice mass resulting in desertification, wouldn't the water source deplete, which would stop the production of melange? Then the sand plankton, which feed on melange, would die out, destroying the Spice Cycle. If not, what reproduces the water necessary to the Spice Cycle?

2 Answers 2


They don't turn water into spice. The spice is a complex chemical dissolved in the water. That's why it can be dried and compressed into disks used as money in the deep desert.

The water is recycled from the sand plankton to sand trout to sand worms through the atmosphere and underground aquifers. This is explained in the appendix of the first book.


I would guess that the sandtrouts are not able to completely encyst all moisture when they form the pre-spice mass, so some water leaks out of the process and is available for the next cycle.

Also, while sandtrouts and sandworms are the dominant biology on Arrakis (or other spice planets later in the series), there is still other life on these worlds, and so it is conceivable that water is introduced into the system by other means (as a by-product from some bacterial process or something - I imagine a rotting sandworm could release a lot of hydrogen in molecular and compound forms).

It is also possible water-laden meteors and comets could introduce new water every so often - they don't even have to be all that large if they are mostly ice and hit regularly - most of them would burn up. However, I can't recall any meteor strikes being discussed in the books, but I would be surprised if it never happens.

There is also a large amount of water locked up at the poles - it could well be that these polar caps have been diminishing steadily over time, providing enough moisture to sustain the spice cycle.

Finally, humans have big spaceships that are capable of instantaneously travelling from one world to another - it isn't inconceivable that water is shipped in from worlds where there is an abundance. This is also not discussed in the books - and given the importance of 'planetologists' in the Empire, it might be that they don't do this too much as removing that much water from any other world would seriously disrupt that world's ecology and the humans know this. Then again, some powers (like House Harkonnen) don't really care about their planets' ecologies (look at Giedi Prime).


The question assumes a closed system in the spice cycle - but there are plenty of routes for water to be re-inserted into the cycle.

  • 1
    "Finally, humans have big spaceships that are capable of instantaneously travelling from one world to another - it isn't inconceivable that water is shipped in from worlds where there is an abundance." I don't think this is likely, due to the extraordinary costs of transporting stuff with spaceships (the extremely high costs of space travel and transport are mentioned quite often in the books).
    – Yaztromo
    Feb 22, 2012 at 11:01
  • If you count them (and YMMV) the extended series books have exactly that happening in 'Paul of Dune'.
    – K-H-W
    Feb 23, 2012 at 3:13
  • @Yaztromo - any supply method becomes financially viable given enough scarcity
    – HorusKol
    Feb 27, 2012 at 0:15
  • A small nitpick: saying the Harkonnens don't care about their planet's ecology is something of a simplification. Giedi Prime was/is rich with natural resources and the planet is polluted with industrial runoff. The Harkonnen's ancestors were somewhat unfairly castigated and ostracized and had to introduce intense industrial output to become wealthy enough to somewhat earn their rightful reputation back. The Harkonnens may have cared deeply about their planet's ecology, they cared more about returning to power and prestige. Dec 7, 2015 at 18:07
  • We see other successful houses maintain a balance between ecology and economy in the series (okay, this is limited to Atreides in original books, but there are more examples in the expanded universe by Brian Herbert).
    – HorusKol
    Dec 7, 2015 at 23:09

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.