7

I am currently reading this series, and I am nearing the end of The Shadow Rising. Siuan was just stripped of her Amyrlin Seat position and stilled because she hid the fact that Rand is the Dragon Reborn, and secretly helped him. Why did her and Moiraine not come out as soon as they knew that he was The Dragon Reborn? They were only doing what was needed. I'm confused as to why they kept it such a secret from the other Aes Sedai, and then why everyone was so horrified.

  • 1
    your question is answered in further books if youd like i can give a more complete answer but it contains a few minor spoilers (nothing ruins any plot points its just clarified the reasons) essentially, though Siuan and Moiraine feared that the tower, upon finding out who rand was, would freak out and gentle him, kill him, or otherwise hinder him from fulfilling the prophecies. – Himarm Nov 21 '14 at 19:04
  • 5
    You might want to read to stop here and read New Spring, the novella; it's a prequel to the series that explains Moraine / Siuan's motivation pretty well. – KutuluMike Aug 13 '15 at 13:15
7

TL;DR: They didn't know who they could trust within the Aes Sedai.

Siuan Sanche and Moraine Damondred were both considered "moderates" in the Aes Sedai political structure, if not outright "rebels". They had both known from a young age (their time together as apprentices, in fact) that the Dragon Reborn would be found at some point, and had been taught by their mentor that the man would need to be supported and guided if the forces of good were to win The Last Battle.

In contrast, the majority of the Aes Sedai believed that ANY man who could channel - especially the Dragon Reborn - must be gentled and/or controlled. Add to this mix the mysterious Black Ajah, who wanted to control Rand at best and kill him at worst, and you have quite a bubbling pot of risk. Announcing Rand's identity to even the senior sisters, an unknown number of whom were likely Black Ajah, would be tantamount to throwing him into the wind with no control of which way it's blowing.

In short, Siuan & Moraine were trying to protect Rand - not for his own sake, but so that the side of the Light wouldn't lose its most valuable weapon. At the time that the Black Ajah made its move and everything hit the fan, they were considering (Siuan especially) on bringing others in on the secret but weren't quite sure who to trust yet. Once their secret was exposed, it was a moot point, since those who wanted to control or destroy Rand were now in power and could spin it any way they wanted. At that point, even sisters who might have agreed with their tactic otherwise now saw it as further evidence of their treason.

2

I believe that their main motive for hiding their knowledge of Rand being the Dragon Reborn was that they didn't know which Aes Sedai to trust. They knew that the Black Ajah exists, and that it hunts for the Dragon Reborn and has killed other Aes Sedai that were searching for the Dragon Reborn, as well as men (and even boys) who were suspected of being the Dragon Reborn. This is told in New Spring (both the short story and the novel).

I seem to remember that just prior to being deposed Siuan was planning on telling the Hall of the Tower about Rand. I think it was just when she got the news that the Stone of Tear has fallen.

  • i believe siuan did tell the tower about rand, however they found out that she had known for a long time, and had been helping him out, before she told the tower, that plus the black ajah is why they overthrew her and stilled her. – Himarm Nov 21 '14 at 19:05
  • and because Elaida was a dick. – Himarm Nov 21 '14 at 19:06
  • @Himarm I might be mixing up the order of events in The Shadow Rising. – Eran Nov 21 '14 at 19:08
  • np, basicly rand takes tear, siuan annouces that he did and that rand is the dragon reborn to the tower, and then alvarian goes to a farm that siuan had sent an accepted(or novice) that had overheard her talk about dealing with rand prior to her announcement, questions/kills her and shares the info with elaida who then riles up the tower to overthrow siuan (with the help of at least 1 if not 2-3 blacks) Just did a full reread in the last 2 months lol. – Himarm Nov 21 '14 at 19:10
1

There are several reasons that have been already discussed that I won't go into, other than to say that I agree with them but there are other reasons too. For one, you must remember the whole reason the White Tower was founded was to guard against the Dark One until Lews Therin was reincarnated. Other than the Last Battle approaching, the Dragon Reborn would rebreak the world. Controversy could kill him faster than anything when dealing with Aes Sedai. Also, the Black Ajah wanted him dead since they'd been killing any boy of the right age who showed signs of being able to channel, so what would happen if he never even grew up. Also, they knew that hiding the existence of Rand was treason, so in essence they were sworn to secrecy and I'm sure the Three Oaths hold on all promises. And don't forget, a Black Ajah member almost killed Moiraine just because she suspected she knew something she shouldn't. The secret they kept wasn't just about Rand, it was for their own safety too.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.