The story mentions the three laws of robotics, but I can't find it in the list of Asimov's stories in Wikipedia. I read it about a decade ago.

Humans have been extinct (possibly left the earth) for a long time. A group of robot scientists clone/create/raise a young girl, the only human on earth.

The story is a conversation between a visitor to the lab where they created the girl and one of the scientists. The visitor is concerned that because of the laws of robotics the girl can order them to do anything. It would disrupt their society if other robots find out.

I don't remember how it ends, would appreciate if someone can help.

  • 4
    Check out "Saturns Children" by Charles Stross. It is set in a future where humanity is extinct. Societies of robots have built a society involving authority by tracing things back to long-imposed human orders. It's a dystopia. The protagonist, Freya, is tasked with delivering a package which turns out to have genetic material with which a human could be cloned. It's a novel, though, and most of the book has Freya unaware of what she's carrying.
    – FuzzyBoots
    Commented Dec 5, 2014 at 15:50
  • I can confirm that it's not by Asimov (otherwise I would have read it).
    – Ubik
    Commented Dec 5, 2014 at 22:13
  • 1
    Reminicent of "Silver Shoes for a Princess" by James P Hogan. It's on line at Baen. Commented Dec 6, 2014 at 22:58

4 Answers 4


The short story "Instinct" by Lester del Rey (first published in Astounding Science Fiction, January 1952, available at the Internet Archive) matches parts of your description.

The setting is a future robot civilization, long after Man has killed himself off. Asimov's Three Laws of Robotics are not mentioned in the story, but Asimov himself is mentioned:

He probably knew some of it, Senthree thought. They all get part of it as legends. He leaned back in his seat now, though, as the biochemist began the old tale of the beginning as they knew it. They knew that there had been Man a million years before them. And somebody—Asimov or Asenion, the record wasn't quite clear—had apparently created the first robot. They had improved it up to about the present level. Then there had been some kind of a contest in which violent forces had ruined the factories, most of the robots, and nearly all of the Men. It was believed from the fragmentary records that a biological weapon had killed the rest, leaving only the robots.

The main character, the robot Senthree, is the leader of a biolab which is trying to recreate Man. Their funding is in danger because of their lack of success and competition with the space colonization program; also there is opposition from robots who fear the return of Man:

"So." Arpeten's face became bland, but he avoided the look of Senthree. "I'm afraid not. At least for a while. That's what I came about, you know. We've just had word of several new planets around Arcturus, and it will take the major allocation of our funds to colonize these. New robots must be built, new ships . . . oh, you know. And we're retrenching a bit on other things. Of course, if you'd succeeded . . . but perhaps it's better you failed. You know how the sentiment against reviving Man has grown."

Senthree growled bitterly. He'd seen how it was carefully nurtured—though he had to admit it seemed to be easy to create. Apparently most of the robots were afraid of Man—felt he would again take over, or something. Superstitious fools.

Then there's a breakthrough. The biotechnicians find out what they've been doing wrong, and carry out their first successful experiment. They use an accelerated time field to get twenty years of growth in one day. Contrary to the description in the question, they do not just create a girl; they create a boy and a girl, and it's the boy who does the talking in the story:

He went down the hall, hearing a tumult of voices, with robots apparently spread about on various kinds of hasty business. The main lab where the couple was seemed quiet. Senthree hesitated at the door, wondering how to address them. There must be no questioning now. Today he would not force himself on them, nor expect them to understand his purposes. He must welcome them and make them feel at ease in this world, so strange to them with their prehistoric tape education. It would be hard at first to adjust to a world with only robots, with no other Man people. The matter of instinct that had taken so long could wait a few days more.

The door opened in front of him and he stepped into the lab, his eyes turning to the low table where they sat. They looked healthy, and there was no sign of misery or uncertainty that he could see, though he could not be sure of that until he knew them better. He could not even be sure it was a scowl on the male's face as the Man turned and looked at him.

"Another one, eh? O.K., come up here. What you want?"

Then Senthree no longer wondered how to address the Man. He bowed low as he approached them, and instinct made his voice low and apologetic as he answered.

"Nothing, Master. Only to serve you."

He waited expectantly.

  • Yes, that's it! Thank you very much, just found it and read it again. It was a long time ago I read it last time, must have mixed it with another story. Thank you again.
    – DannyD
    Commented Apr 14, 2015 at 20:11

Lastly, the short film P.L.U.G. seems to match much closer to your description but isn't a written work.

P.L.U.G. tells the story of ex-military robots that inhabit Earth and end up raising the last human girl.



One that seems a little more likely is The Naked Sun by Isaac Asimov



  1. Extremely sparse population - one human rarely or never sees another
  2. Robots run everything
  3. Robots raise the children

Doesn't match:

  1. Occurs on Solaria, not Earth
  2. Robots don't clone/create humans

I'm posting a couple of possibilities. I'll put each in a different header. None of them completely match your story, instead each of them has elements of your description. Could you be mixing elements from multiple stories together?

The first and least likely is Robbie by Isaac Asimov:



  1. Little girl raised by robots
  2. On Earth

Doesn't match

  1. Most of the rest

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.