10

Slughorn was on the run from the Death Eaters, changing locations weekly and staying in Muggle homes to evade discovery. How then did Dumbledore know where to find him when he took Harry to recruit Slughorn back to Hogwarts as a professor?

  • 1
    Dubmledore had known him for a long time - and probably had more sources of information in the Muggle world, alerting him to irregularities that would be caused by wizards. And, of course, he was one of the most intelligent wizards ever. – Vixen Populi Jan 12 '15 at 6:46
3

Although there is not a full canon answer, it is important that Slughorn had only just arrived in the house, and that he is a little forgetful. Dumbledore points out to Slughorn that he had not created the Dark Mark, which alerted him to the fact that the house had not really been visited by Death Eaters. Slughorn responds that he knew he'd forgotten something, but wouldn't have had the time to create it before Harry and Dumbledore arrived, anyway.

Which means Slughorn only just arrived. It is not told how he arrived, but most if not all forms of wizarding transport are monitored by the Ministry. Although Slughorn would probably have tried to avoid the attention of the Ministry, he may well have slipped up. Meanwhile Dumbledore had been looking for Slughorn for a while, so he must have kept close tabs on anything betraying his presence.

Precisely how Dumbledore found Slughorn isn't specified, so as far as canon is concerned, we'll simply have to assume that it's because Dumbledore is a genius - which is more than we can say about the Death Eaters.

This last part is speculation, but it's reasonable to assume that Dumbledore has contacts in the Muggle world, who can alert him to things like burglared houses. Whereas the Death Eaters would try to either avoid Muggles or torture information out of them, Dumbledore probably has some friends who come to him, out of their own volition.

  • 9
    Are you sure Slughorn only just arrived? I read it that Slughorn was settled in the house, but didn't have time to construct a perfect scene between being alerted dumbledore was in the village and dumbledore walking through the door. – Mac Cooper Jan 12 '15 at 8:44
  • 2
    Slughorns intruder alarms went off alerting him to Dumbledore and Harry's arrival, there is nothing mentioned about him having just arrived at the house himself. but i concur with most of your statement, likely that Dumbledore had been looking for him for a while, i am sure he had his ways of tracking Slughorn – BP_Phoenix Jan 12 '15 at 13:05

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.