15

Thor's Hammer was fixed in Thor's Chariot, wasn't it? Was there some reason why Sha're could not have been taken back to Cimmeria during that brief window of opportunity?

  • A better question would be why don't they ask the Tok'ra to remove the symbiote? If they had time to try one, admittedly much riskier method, then they would have time to contact the Tok'ra and go the safe route. – Omegacron Apr 15 '15 at 21:01
9

The hammer damn near killed Teal'c. To death.

Imagine for a moment what it would do to a pregnant woman.

Yeah.

Edit:

There are a few other concerns as well:

  • The Asgard improved the AI on the hammer: Teal'c is explicitly mentioned, but it makes sense that the change that was actually done was to allow all friends of the Tau'ri, likely making the hammer unable to detect Sha're as a threat.

  • The hammer might not be able to detect the presence of a dormant Goa'uld in any case.

  • The SGC might have compunctions about sending a highly pregnant woman through the Stargate, especially if it is to potentially die at the hands of an Unas in a dark and horrible dungeon, or to potentially be killed by an Asgard device.

    While the hammer might indeed correctly recognize Sha're as a threat, tackling her like O'Neill did to Teal'c the first time around certainly wouldn't work, leading either to her not being taken to the dungeon at all, or her being sent and Daniel being ignored, leaving her alone and likely in shock-induced labor, a moderately suboptimal situation.

Given the above concerns, the risk/reward calculations are looking pretty bleak. Kind of.

A darker analysis reveals, of course, that Sha're losing the child might not have been a terrible thing, all things considered, and would likely ingratiate the SGC with the System Lord collective, but bring down upon them the full force of Apophis, who at the time was otherwise occupied.

Of course, late third trimester abortions aren't only morally difficult, they are also a dangerous proposition for the mother, further impacting the risk/reward calculus.

Additionally, they might simply have failed to consider it. SGC staff is notoriously forgetful when it comes to this kind of stuff.

And, finally, on the meta-level,

saving Sha're was never an option.

It would completely derail Daniel as a credible team member, destroying his motivation.

Instead, her later death steels his resolve to exterminate the Goa'uld and everything they represent; further cementing his path towards the dark side; making his later realization of what he is becoming and subsequent redemption all the more powerful.

  • 7
    Interesting!! Thanks for the answer. I don't think Thor's Hammer DID nearly kill Teal'c though, did it? It nearly killed his symbiote, which would have killed him in the long run, but the entire point of the machine is to kill the goa'uld while leaving the host intact. We also know that it can detect a dormant goa'uld, because Teal'c's larval goa'uld is dormant. It seems to detect the physical presence, regardless of the goa'uld's state. And they were about to take very-pregnant Sha're through the Stargate anyways, just not to Cimmeria, so they had no problem with that. – abcooper Dec 20 '11 at 17:28
  • Well, the hammer itself didn't nearly kill Teal'c, but the internal struggle did. Additionally, Teal'c's symbiote isn't dormant, it's incubating. It's acting as any other symbiote in its position would. In any case; your point about pregnant Stargate travelers is certainly valid. Also, the machine doesn't actually kill the symbiote, I think; it seems as if simply gives the host the tools to fight it. – Williham Totland Dec 20 '11 at 17:42
  • The Asgard are big on tests of character… – Williham Totland Dec 20 '11 at 17:43
  • I guess. :/ I don't think there's any really satisfying answer, but lovers of SG-1 have to take the occasional crazy plot-hole in stride, I suppose. – abcooper Dec 20 '11 at 21:09
  • @abcooper: While this is true, I'm not sure that this is actually a plot hole, tho'. – Williham Totland Dec 20 '11 at 21:19
2

The thing is, one way or another, they should have brought her to Earth to have the child (a human, innocent child) and, as they had talked about in that very episode, use her for intelligence purposes (Daniel and her already agreed on that).

That would have her available to ANY method of extracting the Goa'uld (after giving birth is you're so worried about her pregnancy), like the Asgard (they created the Hammer, so...) and, a few episodes later, Marchello's larvae or whatever they were, especially created to free the host -safely- killing the bug.

In the real world, however, I suspect they wanted to free Daniel for future flirting.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.