27

It occurs me that it's a bit strange that after 5 years of being Snape's students, and presumably seeing his handwriting almost everyday - writing class instructions, correcting papers etc, neither Harry, Ron, nor Hermione could compare the HBP's handwriting to Snape's.

The book mentions HBP's writing as being "small ...[and] cramped". Is there any description of adult Snape's handwriting in the books, or any discussion in interviews and the like regarding why none of the trio (especially Hermione) recognized the handwriting as being Snape's?

  • 3
    perhaps they were different. Harry and others have probably only seen Prof. Snape's writing on a big board or while writing comments on they homework, but the text in the potions book was written to cram as much information as possible in a small amount of space. – user13267 Jan 26 '15 at 5:04
  • I don't think they've seen much of Snape's handwriting. During classes, Professor Snape would magically copy potion-making instructions to the blackboard using his wand, and I presume those instructions need not have been in his handwriting; or just have the class read the instructions in the textbook. – b_jonas Jan 26 '15 at 7:21
  • 2
    BTW: Anecdotally, out of universe, my handwriting changed significantly between school years and now. – DVK-on-Ahch-To Jan 26 '15 at 15:32
  • 5
    Harry didn't even realise someone was speaking Parseltongue to him, you want him to recognise hand-writing? – Möoz Jan 26 '15 at 21:40
17

Here's another example describing Snape's handwriting at age 15:

Harry moved around behind Snape and read the heading of the examination paper: DEFENCE AGAINST THE DARK ARTS – ORDINARY WIZARDING LEVEL.

So Snape had to be fifteen or sixteen, around Harry’s own age. His hand was flying across the parchment; he had written at least a foot more than his closest neighbours, and yet his writing was minuscule and cramped.

Order of the Phoenix - pages 564-565 - Bloomsbury - chapter twenty-eight, Snape's Worst Memory

A few things:

When it comes to a canonical characterization (I believe as you seem to), Hermione ostensibly should have noticed, if Snape's handwriting remained the same from his teen years to adulthood -- this is extremely unlikely. There is nothing in canon that directly addresses this.

J.K. Rowling needed Hermione to not notice because JKR needed us not to know who the Half-Blood Prince is until the story is wrapping up. Harry needed to be the one who discovers the truth to the secret of the Half-Blood Prince.

As DVK and alexwlchan both mention, handwriting can change significantly between the teen years and adulthood. Some similarities exist (see out-of-universe example below) but the finished products could easily be mistaken for separate writers if one isn't looking with a super keen eye.

TEEN:

Teen handwriting

ADULT:

Adult handwriting

Same writer.

14

I can’t find anything describing the adult Snape’s handwriting (books, Pottermore, interviews, nada). But here’s one passage which seems relevant:

Although Harry had offered to share his book with both of them, Ron had more difficulty deciphering the handwriting than Harry did, and could not keep asking Harry to read aloud or it might look suspicious.

I would expect that after five years of his criticism on their homework, they’d be sufficiently familiar with his handwriting that they wouldn’t have much difficulty reading it. This suggests that Snape’s handwriting as a teenager and as an adult are quite different.

I know that’s pretty weak sauce, but it’s the only canon source I can think of which comments on the legibility of the handwriting in the textbook.

  • there is some mention of the teenage Snape's handwriting I think, when Harry goes into Snape's memory and sees them taking the OWLs – user13267 Jan 26 '15 at 9:38
  • 3
    I actually don't agree with this being weak, it's a legit and smart answer. – Dagon313 Jan 26 '15 at 12:14
  • @user13267: I've just checked that passage, and it looks like it just mentions Snape scribbling away at speed, but I didn't see anything about his handwriting style. – alexwlchan Jan 26 '15 at 12:29
  • my thoughts where, does snape even right on the board? he could simply wave his wand and notes appear, and he could even grade with a quick quotes quill (which would even leave rude comments on students homework ) – Himarm Jan 26 '15 at 16:50
  • 1
    Yes you're right, I much prefer stronger sauce! – Möoz Jan 26 '15 at 21:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.