14

One of the few things that bothers me about the Dominion arc in Deep Space Nine is the Jem'Hadar. I enjoy the concept but I don't understand why they would be genetically addicted to Ketracel White (or anything else for that matter).

There are some obvious problems

  • When they run out, the Jem'Hadar go ballistic and kill everything in sight uncontrollably.

  • With the Gamma Quadrant and the supply of White cut off, Starfleet's first move was to go after 'White' production in the Alpha Quadrant. The Dominion may as well have put signs up saying "this is our weak spot."

  • In Hippocratic Oath, Bashir and O'Brien meet a Jem'Hadar who was decanted without the addiction. As soon as a Jem'Hadar realizes that he doesn't need the White, he realizes he doesn't have to do what his Vorta tells him and it goes downhill from there.

Since The Dominion has already proven that it is capable of breeding loyal and obedient servants (The Vorta) then why would they use an addiction that would open them up to such obvious liabilities instead of simply breeding the qualities they wanted into their soldiers?

  • 6
    The example in Hippocratic Oath a direct answer to this question: The addiction is used to keep them loyal. The one who was not addicted was a rare genetic anomaly, so it's not really a liability. – Izkata Feb 1 '15 at 5:20
  • 3
    “Ignoring the social implications (which can be hard to do with DS9, especially Avery Brooks, sometimes)” — eh? – Paul D. Waite Feb 1 '15 at 11:02
  • 2
    The Vorta were uplifted from just-barely-sentience and bred/genetically manipulated for a very long time. The Jem'Hadar are a relatively recent creation. – Joe L. Feb 1 '15 at 14:13
  • 2
    @JoeL.: I watched DS9 Very recently and I've read most of the info I can find on them. I haven't seen anything that suggests they are a recent addition to the Dominion. Do you have a source? – geewhiz Feb 1 '15 at 15:37
  • 2
    The Dominion may as well have put signs up saying "this is our weak spot." Of course, the engineering of the Jem'Hadar occurred long before the Dominion even knew about the wormhole to the alpha quadrant. – user11521 Feb 1 '15 at 15:59
21

The Ketracel White is used to keep the Jem Hadar loyal to the founders as well as functioning as their sole source of food and drink. In the event that they become disloyal to the Founders (something that's apparently a rather more common occurrence than the Founders would like the Federation to believe) they can simply withdraw access to the substance and they'll all die.

BASHIR: I know that the Jem'Hadar have been genetically engineered by the Dominion to be addicted to what you call ketracel-white. And that by controlling the supply of the drug, the Founders maintain control over you.

GORAN'AGAR: The Vorta. They are the ones who control the drug. They are the ones we came here to escape.

BASHIR: Escape? You're trying to leave the Dominion?

DS9 : Hippocratic Oath

and

SISKO: Couldn't the Founders just order them to surrender? From what I know, the Jem'Hadar have been genetically conditioned to obey them.

WEYOUN: The Founders' ability to control the Jem'Hadar has been somewhat overstated. Otherwise we never would have had to addict them to the white.

SISKO: Sounds like the Dominion isn't quite as stable as you'd like us to believe.

DS9: To the Death

  • 1
    Has anyone considered the fact that, based on these quotes, it might not have been the Founders that created the addiction, but rather the Vorta? – Moo Mar 2 '16 at 14:13
  • 2
    @moo - Both the Vorta and the Jem'hadar are the products of genetic manipulation. It's possible (albeit highly unlikely) that the Jem'hadar were loyal to the Vorta first and were then co-opted by the Founders. I fail to see why you'd think that though. – Valorum Mar 2 '16 at 16:25
  • 2
    I'm not saying the Jem'hadar were ever loyal to the Vorta at all, but given that the Founders seem to use the Vorta to run the Dominion at arms length, surely that also probably involves managing the Jem'hadar force, including updating the genetic code used to create them. Perhaps at some point in the past, the Vorta decided they had had enough of rampaging, hard to control soldiers, so they did something about it, especially as they were more likely to suffer as a result of uncontrolled Jem'hadar than the Founders were. It would be within their scope of being the Founders facilitators... – Moo Mar 2 '16 at 16:50
  • 2
    @moo - Ah, I see. That's wandering into the realms of fan-fiction though – Valorum Mar 2 '16 at 17:13
13

While Richard's answer is excellent, it overlooks one central point in Geewhiz's note.

"When they run out, the Jem'Hadar go ballistic and kill everything in sight uncontrollably."

This is not actually a disadvantage, if accommodated or planned for. Jem'Hadar have an incredibly short lifetime (see DS9: To the Death) and mature very quickly, going from infant to Fighting size in a matter of weeks (see DS9: The Abandoned). Given this accelerated life, if a company is compromised from white withdrawal the following strategic points become important:

  • The company will self-destruct in a short time frame (DS9: Rocks and Shoals)
  • If members of the company are able to survive white withdrawal, they will have trouble subverting others (DS9: Hippocratic Oath)
  • The company can be materially replaced quickly. (DS9: The Abandoned)
  • Direct intervention by a Founder can probably accommodate the situation (Any DS9 showing Founder-Jem'Hadar Contact).
  • The second, third and fourth items may be combined for an effective, if heartless solution to an insurrection

Given the Founders view all species as subservient, and have a very long term view of strategy, it does not seem that this apparent liability would be viewed as such by them.

  • Maybe the Jem'Hadars' concept of honor plays into this, too? We were shown on some occasions that they adhere to an honor codex that requires killing members of the own team under certain circumstances. When parts of a group of Jem'Hadar start becoming disloyal, it seems conceivable some members of the group may feel compelled to act as a "kill switch" for the entire group for reasons of honor, thereby accelerating point 1. – O. R. Mapper Aug 8 at 23:56
7

breeding a loyal dog is not as easy as breeding an attack dog

fighters have to have the ability to think for themselves in tactical situations, an individual who thinks for himself can choose to disobey his master.

short answer they couldnt do it because breeding a loyal race would remove that races ability to think tactically and a soldier who cant think tactically is worthless

1

The Vorta weren't just loyal to the founders, they revered the founders as gods. No need for a "safety switch" like a Ketracel White dependency. They don't factor into the logic behind the need to do so for the Jem'Hadar - bred to be the ultimate soldiers above all else, a safety switch is a necessity to ensure loyalty. And they really weren't exactly loyal to the founders so much as to the Vorta - the source of their Ketracel White.

  • 3
    The Jem'Hadar considered the Founders divine as well. They were just further removed from them for the most part. According to the Memory Alpha article: "Although the Jem'Hadar worshipped the Founders as gods, the vast majority of the Jem'Hadar had never actually seen a Founder, and some doubted that they even existed." en.memory-alpha.org/wiki/Jem%27Hadar That and the quote in Richard's answer indicates the problem is keeping the Jem'Hadar obedient to the Vorta. – geewhiz Feb 1 '15 at 15:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.