28

In the book(as opposed to the movie), Bellatrix sends out red sparks from her wand, not green light like an Avada Kedavra spell. When it hits him, Sirius is not killed instantly, but did he die? And what was special about that archway?

54

The most popular theory I've come across time and again regarding Sirius's death is that Bellatrix's second curse -- which is not identified as Avada Kedavra, as you say -- knocked Sirius off balance, causing him to fall through the veiled archway (the veil). The veil is a one-way ticket; it cannot be entered and then exited. When a person goes through the veil it means they have died and it is permanent.

‘Come on, you can do better than that!’ he yelled, his voice echoing around the cavernous room. The second jet of light hit him squarely on the chest.

The laughter had not quite died from his face, but his eyes widened in shock.

[...]

It seemed to take Sirius an age to fall: his body curved in a graceful arc as he sank backwards through the ragged veil hanging from the arch.

Harry saw the look of mingled fear and surprise on his godfather’s wasted, once-handsome face as he fell through the ancient doorway and disappeared behind the veil, which fluttered for a moment as though in a high wind, then fell back into place.

Harry heard Bellatrix Lestrange’s triumphant scream, but knew it meant nothing – Sirius had only just fallen through the archway, he would reappear from the other side any second ....

But Sirius did not reappear.

Order of the Phoenix - Pages 710-711 - British Hardcover - Adult Edition

Here's an explanation of the veil from the Harry Potter Wiki:

The Veil is the barrier between the land of the living and the land of the dead. One cannot travel freely between the two worlds, as it is a one-way trip. Inexperienced wizards know nothing about it, but the much more experienced wizards may have heard about it, and the Unspeakables who work in the Department of Mysteries have likely studied it closely.

A physical manifestation of the barrier (the veil) was somehow kept in the Ministry of Magic's Department of Mysteries; in the Death Chamber, a room large and echoing, dimly lit and rectangular, and kept in the centre of a raised stone dais in a sunken, great stone pit some twenty feet deep, with benches running all around the room and descending in steep steps like an amphitheatre (or like the Wizengamot Courtroom 10) and surrounded by a cold air and complete stillness.

Though the living could have the strangest feeling that there was someone standing right behind the Veil on the otherside of the archway, their words are inaudible except for "faint whispering and murmuring noises" coming from the other side of the Veil. When the living person attempts communication themselves, the dead try harder and their whispering and murmuring becomes louder. If those who hear the whispering stare at the archway long enough, they shortly become entranced and mesmerised by it, believing it had a kind of beauty about (old though it was), unknowingly walking towards it, intrigued by the gently rippling Veil, and feeling a very strong inclination to climb up on the dais and walk through it.

However, this would prove fatal, as passing through the Veil would cause instant death.

Hope this helps to answer your question :)

  • 1
    Why do they keep a murder arch free standing in the ministry instead of sealing it in a block of concrete? – GordonBennett Sep 27 at 10:15
6

Harry and Luna could hear the whispering voices from beyond the veil, just as they could see Thestrals. Unless I am mistaken, I believe that only those who have witnessed death can hear the voices. Based on that, I assume that the veil is a gateway to death.

  • 3
    "It was a splen­did and cryp­tic old fam­ily heir­loom which be­longed right where it was, in the cel­lar." Zelazny, Sign of the Unicorn. – Joe L. Jul 17 '14 at 20:56
5

He died from the veil

In JK Rowling's original notes for Book Five, Bellatrix wasn't involved. Dementors were closing in on Sirius and he choose "death" (the veil) rather than be kissed.

enter image description here

[Chapter 34] Harry runs for it with prophecy but Sirius is in trouble - goes back - chucks away the prophecy but Sirius chooses death rather than the Dementor - snake there - Voldemort comes

[Chapter 35] Hermione and Ron pull Harry back from death ...

This shows that the veil was capable of killing people. And as others have shown, the nature of Bellatrix's last spell was never specified in the book.

0

Another possibility is that, although Bellatrix only used a Stunning spell, because it hit Sirius squarely in the chest it incidentally stopped his heart (blows to the chest can do that). So when he fell through the archway he 'moved on' instead of falling out the other side, because he was in fact already dead.

  • 2
    You could improve this answer by adding a quote that states that a stunning spell can be lethal when aimed at chest - for instance the incident with McGonagall during Harry's astronomy exam, or the death of Bellatrix herself at the hands of Molly (ironic, huh? Kills him with stunning spell, gets killed by stunning spell). – Gallifreyan Mar 31 '17 at 18:35
  • Alternate answers confirm official source that you don't come back out the other side regardless of your condition when going through the arch. – Gnemlock Jul 24 at 0:39
  • When your heart stops you die quickly. But not quite that quickly. – Misha R Sep 27 at 23:12
-3

I think it was a stunning spell rather than Avada Kedavra because Harry wanted to pull Sirius from the veil. If it was the killing curse, which Harry would have identified because of the colour, I think it would have been easier for him to accept that Sirius died. Harry was confused when Sirius didn’t appear on the other side of the veil, which meant that it wasn't Avada Kedavra.

  • 3
    You’ve provided a partial answer talking about the veil and the stunning spell, but if it was a stunning spell when did Sirius die? And why didn’t her come out on the other side of the Veil? – Edlothiad Jun 30 '18 at 13:08
-4

Avada Kedavra (the Killing Curse) was not vividly identified as the spell that hit Sirius Black. According to the circumstances mentioned in the book, Bellatrix Lestrange most likely used a stunning spell against Sirius. When the spell hit him, Sirius immediately lost his balance and fell through the veiled archway(the Veil). Even though we are not particularly sure what SPECIFIC spell Bellatrix used to hit Sirius, we already know that passing through the Veil causes immediate death.

I hope you found this answer helpful.

  • 4
    The exact same point has already been made in two previous answers, one of which was accepted by the asker as adequately answering the question (three years ago, no less). – Janus Bahs Jacquet Sep 20 '15 at 1:41
  • 2
    Hi! Welcome to the site :) Although I agree that what killed him was falling through the veil, as Janus says, this has already been stated and on this site, we don't really "do" duplicate answers. You really have to add something if you're going to give the same fundamental answer as somebody else. Moreover, I disagree that the spell Bellatrix Lestrange used was "most likely" a stunning spell - especially immediately after he'd goaded her. And we don't "already know that passing through the Veil causes immediate death" – Au101 Sep 20 '15 at 2:34
  • 2
    Or rather, the reader doesn't know that to begin with. The reader can surmise that from the fact that Sirius does not appear to have been hit by the killing curse and yet does not remain in the mortal world on passing through the veil. His body is, apparently, annihilated. – Au101 Sep 20 '15 at 2:36
-5

I assume the spell was a stunning spell which caused Sirius to be knocked off his feet and into the veil. I'm still a little confused as to why they were fighting directly beside the veil, though. When you think about it, the outcome was quite predictable.

  • 4
    I fail to see what this adds to the existing (accepted) answer. – Valorum Aug 3 '14 at 20:57

protected by Rand al'Thor Sep 27 at 7:49

Thank you for your interest in this question. Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).

Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.