Casting Alan Rickman (a great actor) in the role of Snape would make a great deal of sense if one considers the depth of the character as exposed by all the books up to the seventh one.

A great example is the deleted scene from the HBP movie:

The still – which does absolutely no justice to Rickman's talent – is on HP Wikia. I'd prefer not to post the links to the video as that might violate copyright.


The scene shows the choir singing 'In Noctem` and then Snape looking out at the approaching darkness.

But it seems a mite of an overkill (shades of Alec Guinness here) if one merely needs to portray an somewhat evilly guy from "The Philosopher's Stone" – yes, Rickman played those before (e.g. Die Hard), but still an overkill – and he's been known to turn down blockbuster roles before (he turned down the villain role in 007 movie Goldeneye.

Is there any support for the theory that the casting of Alan Rickman was done based on at least a rough idea of his full story and depth as a character in JKR's mind?

Ideally I'd like an explicit statement from someone involved; but circumstantial evidence based on timelines would also be OK if the former doesn't exist.

  • 15
    I'm fairly sure that posting a link to a video doesn't violate copyright law... yet. – Goodbye Stack Exchange Dec 29 '11 at 5:39
  • @neilfein - bad wording. I care about it being unethical as well as illegal. – DVK-on-Ahch-To Dec 29 '11 at 5:45
  • 6
    It took reading only the first book for my father (an ex-literature_teacher) to point out that Snape is by far the most interesting and complex character in the whole thing. – n611x007 Jun 30 '12 at 3:26
  • 1
    Implying fair use is unethical. – Gabe Willard Jun 30 '12 at 3:58
  • 6
    I'm placing a bounty on this excellent question to draw attention. Snape was (IMO) by far the most interesting character in HP, and though I dislike much about the film adaptations, Rickman's portrayal was perfect. RIP. – Rand al'Thor Jan 15 '16 at 0:20

From wikipedia:

Severus Snape appears in all eight Harry Potter films, portrayed by British actor Alan Rickman. Rickman was Rowling's personal choice to portray the character. He had conversations with Rowling about his character and is one of the few Harry Potter actors that she spoke to prior to the completion of the book series about the future direction of the character. "He knew very early on that he'd been in love with Lily," said Rowling. "He needed to understand […] where this bitterness towards this boy who's the living example of her preference for another man came from."

Also from a Time article:

Rowling also had a hand in choosing most of the adult cast members. She specifically requested Coltrane. Others, like Richard Harris as Dumbledore, Maggie Smith as Professor McGonagall and Alan Rickman as Professor Snape came straight from a wish list of actors that Rowling provided the producers. She gave Rickman and Coltrane precious bits of information about their characters' futures.

And, from a much later Time article, Alan Rickman is quote as saying:

"Three children have become adults since a phone call with Jo Rowling, containing one small clue, persuaded me that there was more to Snape than an unchanging costume, and that even though only three of the books were out at that time, she held the entire massive but delicate narrative in the surest of hands."

| improve this answer | |
  • 8
    Whoa. Impressive! – DVK-on-Ahch-To Dec 29 '11 at 5:16
  • Glad you like it.. I just remembered wondering the same thing a while ago, and went back to where I found answers last time. – K-H-W Dec 29 '11 at 5:22
  • 2
    The role was originally offered to Tim Roth. moviesblog.mtv.com/2007/12/07/… – Rob Dec 29 '11 at 18:06
  • Believable; the offering of a part is a bit complex, and isn't always first to the author's choice.. As I recall, however, Rickman was going to turn the role down, as a one-dimensional villain, but Rowling gave him more information about the part to convince him to take it, as he was HER first choice (although not necessarily the studio/director's first choice.) – K-H-W Dec 29 '11 at 18:40
  • 4
    I should clarify, though -- first choice means PRIMARY choice in this usage; not the first person it was offered to -- of the actors she saw, Rickman was JKR's preferred choice; that doesn't mean he was the first person offer the role. 'First' in the sense of score, not sequence. – K-H-W Dec 29 '11 at 18:58

It appears that while Rowling herself knew what was coming, she did not release all of that information to Rickman, just a few pieces. As K-H-W states Rowling did want Rickman to play the part, so she must have envisioned him in this role to the end.

There is a longstanding story that Rowling let Rickman know early on that Snape was not the bad guy or Voldemort henchman in waiting many expected him to be. Before I could even finish my question about this anecdote Rickman jumped in to clarify.

According to Alan Rickman.

"Not true. I don't know who thinks that is true, but it's not true," Rickman says. "She gave me one tiny, little, left of field piece of information that helped me think that he was more complicated and that the story was not going to be as straight down the line as everybody thought. If you remember when I did the first film she'd only written three or four books, so nobody knew where it was really going except her. And its was important for her that I know something, but she only gave me a tiny piece of information which helped me think it was a more ambiguous route." LINK

Rickman adds,

"What I knew was he was a human being and not an automaton and I knew there was some sense of protection for Harry or I worked that out. It was enough to know, I didn't know he was a double agent."

"Three children have become adults since a phone call with Jo Rowling, containing one small clue, persuaded me that there was more to Snape than an unchanging costume, and that even though only three of the books were out at that time, she held the entire massive but delicate narrative in the surest of hands. quote

Here we see that by book 3, Rickman knew JRK had a plan in store for Snape.

"She certainly didn't tell me what the end of the story was going to be in any way at all," Rickman said. "No, she gave me one little piece of information, which I always said I would never share with anybody and never have, and never will. It wasn't a plot point, or crucial in any tangible way, but it was crucial to me as a piece of information that made me travel down that road rather than that one or that one or that one." Rowling revealed [on Twitter] what she had told Rickman: "I told Alan what lies behind the word 'Always'." quote

This "Always" was most likely in reference to Snape Loving Lilly, showing that Rowling had planned Snapes story out by book 3, when hiring Rickman.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.