4

It is my personal opinion that the more the Android learns human knowledge, the more human he becomes. The very yearning to be so is human in its own right. If I understand, the emotion chip causes malfunctions but I think observation naturally could give him some kind of emotional function. I haven't yet seen where he's got said chip but it seems like the more he learns, the more human he is. I still have yet to see In Theory as well but apparently, he gained a relationship with a hologram in some way and on Data's Day, he clearly believes he would be married someday AND even said he understands love and friendship. I can't see how it'd impossible to gain a relationship with someone even without emotions - he does have a conscience and morale. I am needing more interesting research for a fanfiction I'm writing.

  • 3
    I don't know what to do about this question, looks really opinion-based... But it will be usefull to you if you watch 4x25 where Data does get into relationship. – Deltharis Mar 18 '15 at 9:47
  • 1
    "I can't see how it'd impossible to gain a relationship with someone even without emotions - he does have a conscience and morale." You really need to watch more episodes with Data before concluding he has no conscience or morale without his emotion chip. – Zibbobz Mar 18 '15 at 13:55
  • 1
    More pertinently, whether or not he could develop the ability to at least simulate emotions, it was his belief in Star Trek: Generations that he had reached an impasse in his development without it. Whether or not this is true is up for debate. – Zibbobz Mar 18 '15 at 13:57
  • 2
    I think there's sufficient info about Data to answer this. – Valorum Mar 18 '15 at 19:37
6

I'm going to say no. Firstly, it's explicitly stated in several of the scripts that emotionality will always be beyond Data, even in situations where he can clearly identify that an emotional response would be appropriate, for example in TNG: The Offspring where his daughter dies:

DATA : What do you feel, Lal?

LAL : I... love... you... Father.

And Data just stares at her... unable to say it back.

DATA : I wish I could feel it with you.

LAL : I... will... feel... it... for... both... of... us.

...

PICARD : The crew grieves for your loss, Mister Data.

Data studies the sad faces of his "family", never has, never will entirely understand "grieving".

and in Star Trek Generations, Data himself gives us a pretty good indication that without the chip, he's reached the end of the road as far as his growth (as a person) is concerned.

(n.b. I've quoted from the novelisation for ease of reading but the script is essentially the same.

"I thought you were afraid it would overload your neural net." "That is true," Data replied. "However, I believe my growth as an artificial life-form has reached an impasse. For thirty-four years I have endeavored to become more 'human'- to grow beyond my original programming. And yet I am still unable to grasp such a basic concept as humor."

He turned back toward the crystalline case. "This emotion chip may be the only answer." Geordi leaned forward to dubiously study the chip, then sighed. At worst, it could cause some annoying complications, but no permanent damage. And what right did he have to deny his friend such an experience?

  • I feel it's important to remember, though I cannot find any citation to support it, that Data's personal growth hasn't reached an impasse because of difficulty, but because of a hard limit on what he can experience. His programming has gotten very good at simulating and replicating emotional reactions, but spontaneity and the understanding of uncontrolled emotions elude him because he cannot experience them, even if he can run simulations of how he should react in certain situations. – Zibbobz Mar 18 '15 at 20:13
  • 1
    @Zibbobz - Per my comment below (on cde's answer), it's not that he can't sense when emotion would be appropriate, it's that in the absence of genuine emotion, he's unwilling to fake it. On those occasions that he tries, it's very 'forced' and he seems to find it quite unpleasant – Valorum Mar 18 '15 at 20:24
  • Exactly. He recognizes it, he can even force it when he wants, but it's not something that 'comes naturally' to him, and he recognizes this. – Zibbobz Mar 18 '15 at 20:30
  • Well, with one exception: He appears to experience genuine emotion right at the end of 1x23, after Tasha's funeral service, but does not recognize it for what it is – Izkata Mar 19 '15 at 1:06
  • 1
    It's a false premise: dunking Crusher was hilarious. – 1252748 Apr 2 '15 at 12:42
1

I think Data would be able to develop responses that were perhaps rudimentary feelings. It started by imitation, but there were times where you can tell from his reactions that the "imitation" had some sincerity.

My best evidence: "The Most Toys". It's probably the most emotional you ever saw him before the chip, and so much more satisfying as character development. He became angry and was going to kill Fajo. I argue this because he recognized it as an emotional response. Had it been a logical decision to protect future victims, Data would have reported it honestly.

0

Yes it is possible. First, from everything we have seen in Trek, anything is possible. Probability is the problem. Second, what is emotion other than learned behavior brought on by observed contextual clues of your surroundings, i.e. social and evolutionary programming. Data is capable of learning on a mental level, not just rote memorization.

That said, Data and his creator both know there are natural technical limitations to Data, that cannot be overcome by sheer willpower. Hence the chip. Note that Lore did not have those limitations in place, him being the reason for Data's limitations, and nor did Data's mother. And possibly neither did his Daughter.

  • 1
    His lack of emotional response is down to his essential truthfulness. He spurns emotionality even in situations where an emotional response would be easy to fake. – Valorum Mar 18 '15 at 19:53
0

I think the best evidence we have of this comes from my Soong in TNG 'Brothers':

Basic emotions. Simple feelings, Data. Your feelings. I've imagined how hard it's been for you, living amongst beings so moved by emotion.

The fact that Soong knows Data doesn't have emotions suggests he knows Data couldn't develop emotions without some alteration. So, I'd say that Data couldn't possibly develop emotions without some external input.

0

Yes, as we saw briefly in the episode Deja Q. At the very end, Q gives Data a brief gift of laughter. How did he do this? All powerful trickster god, who knows? But it would seem to hint that the possibility is there. However, as a practical measure, convincing an all-powerful trickster god to give you emotions is...probably not a practical solution. So in terms of personal evolution, no. In terms of perhaps altering some of his code or whatever, probably. No reason the code of a chip can't be integrated into the system. But the danger there, of course, is that nobody but Soong is competent to do such a thing- and look how well that turned out with Lor.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.