8

Since the "Smith" virus is the opposite of the One, did Neo's five predecessors create viruses like Smith before by killing an agent or not even doing anything?

| improve this question | | | | |
  • 2
    Just a side comment, I think people sometimes imagine the previous cycles must have been very close to the one we see in the films (at least before the moment Neo chooses not to reboot the Matrix) because they interpret the faces on the screens in the Architect's room to be previous versions of The One who all look identical to Neo--but I don't think this was actually the intention, see my arguments in this answer. – Hypnosifl May 9 '15 at 19:36
  • Given the fact that Neo is unique among the Ones, and that Smith is unique among the Agents, and that his vendetta with Smith is largely personal (on both ends - remember that Smith chose to return as a virus rather than accept deletion, deletion being what he was "supposed to do"). I doubt previous agents would have had the deletion/resurrection experience we see in the film. To be honest, I'm not 100% that previous ones even could delete agents like that (Neo never does it again after Smith, so it's another unique occurrence). – DavidS Jan 19 '17 at 9:58
8

I'm going to go out on a limb and say "no", solely based on the fact that the Deus Ex Machina was incapable of working out a way to defeat Smith while preserving the Matrix.

Neo turns up and it threatens to kill him, something that it wouldn't have done if it had known he was the solution. It then accepts his proposal, again, something that wouldn't have happened had it had a better alternative, which it surely would have done if it had encountered this same problem in the past.

| improve this answer | | | | |
1

It is arguable whether previous iterations of the Matrix faced a similar emergence of "virus"-agents. I will explain why below and why we can't know.

The Architect revealed that the Chosen One, like Neo, get his power from the "remainder" of an unbalanced equation, the core equation running the Matrix.

This why Neo has so much power (and gains more if he can destabilize further the Matrix and its equation), because the equation (and its anomaly) is systemic, global, as it affects all the system, from the top to the most basic and simple programs. This is a general flaw at the foundation of the system, it's not just a vulnerability in a specific program, the anomaly affects everyone and everything in the Matrix:

Your life is the sum of a remainder of an unbalanced equation inherent to the programming of the matrix. You are the eventuality of an anomaly, which despite my sincerest efforts I have been unable to eliminate from what is otherwise a harmony of mathematical precision. [...] As you are undoubtedly gathering, the anomaly’s systemic, creating fluctuations in even the most simplistic equations.

It is thus clearly stated that the anomaly is systemic, which means that not only is the Chosen One affected by the anomaly, but also all Matrix entities, from the most basic ones to the most complex.

This suggests that although the Chosen One has the exclusive possession of the "remainder" (=powers) of the unbalanced core equation, other entities might compensate (mechanically: the missing remainder must be complemented by something else, else the unbalanced equation alone could not work and the Matrix could not continue to run). This is hinted at by Smith in Matrix Reloaded:

  • Agent Smith: Surprised to see me?
  • Neo: No.
  • Smith: Then you're aware of it.
  • Neo: Of what?
  • Smith: Our connection. I don't fully understand how it happened. Perhaps some part of you imprinted onto me... ...something overwritten or copied. It is, at this point, irrelevant. What matters is... ...that whatever happened, happened for a reason. [...] And now, here I stand because of you, Mr. Anderson. Because of you, I'm no longer an agent of this system. Because of you, I've changed. I'm unplugged. A new man, so to speak. Like you, apparently free.

It can be argued that rather than being a copy of Neo's "code" into Smith, the "connection" is rather the impulsion into Smith of an "anti-remainder": by destroying Smith using his own anomaly, Neo generated a counter anomaly. This would be consistent with the movie symbolism, representing Neo and Smith as the yin and the yang: two complementary parts that are necessary to balance the whole (Matrix system). And indeed, all along the Matrix 2 and 3 movies, Smith's progress remarkably parallels Neo's: the more powerful one is, the more will be the other. But whereas Neo achieves his power on his own (by being granted the "remainder"), Smith accumulates power (=anomalies) by cloning into other entities, thereby feeding on the bits of compensatory "anti-remainders" that every entities might possess.

Let's get back to the Architect: we also learn from it that the Matrix has a measure of control: reinsert the Chosen One back to the core, which indeed inserts the missing equation's "remainder" (missing from the Matrix point of view, because only the Chosen One possess it, until he gives it back to the Source):

The function of the One is now to return to the source, allowing a temporary dissemination of the code you carry, reinserting the prime program.

Why does this matter? Because arguably, if you insert the "remainder" in the equation, you balance it, effectively destroying any anomaly and any remainder, as well as any anti-remainder. In this case, even if an agent (or another entity of the Matrix) got over-powered like Smith, they will essentially be reset, along with everything else.

However, in Matrix Reloaded, Neo chooses NOT to reinsert the remainder to the Source, which creates an unprecedented scenario: the remainder is allowed to grow uncontrollably, and so any other anomaly like Smith. This allowed for Smith to become so anomalous, so powerful, that he could take over the Matrix, whereas in previous iterations he would have been reset with the rest when the Chosen One would enter the Source.

This explains why Deus Ex Machina nor any other entity had no contingency plan to mitigate this issue, as it never happened before that an entity could gain so much power: all anomalies were already reset long before the anomalies could accumulate at this threatening level.

To conclude, there is no clue in the movies suggesting whether or not previous Matrix iterations saw the rise of over-powered program entities to counter-balance the Chosen One powers. What is stated is that the anomaly is not limited to the Chosen One, but systemic, so all entities in the Matrix possess a bit of the anomaly. It is also known that previous Matrix iterations did not see the rise of such powerful entities capable of taking over the entire Matrix, but whether this is because of the Source reinsertion program having worked well up until now, or either because no entity was clever enough to clone into everyone to accumulate anomalies, remains totally up to debate.

| improve this answer | | | | |
  • 2
    So your argument is that it is possible that there was a Smith-like virus in a previous version of the a Matrix, but it's a moot point because it never would have gotten as out of control as Smith did because the One always rebooted the Matrix in the past. Is that correct? The only thing I struggle with there is that Smith already had the power to enter the real world before the choice. If Neo chose to reboot the Matrix and picked his survivors to repopulate, I would think that he would pick the crew of the Nebuchadnezzar as part of them at which point real-world Smith threatens everything. – Thunderforge Jan 19 '17 at 1:24
  • @Thunderforge Yes that's part of my point, but my full point is that it's stated that the anomaly is systemic, thus not limited to the One, so we know that previous Matrix iterations also saw over-powered entities beside the One, but diluted across all Matrix entities, contrary to Smith which used cloning to get it all (except Neo's part of the anomaly). Good point that Smith could however threaten everything because of real-world transfert, so previous iterations might have seen over-powered entities but not as clever as Smith, so maybe nobody tried to go real-world (or had the opportunity). – gaborous Jan 19 '17 at 13:58
  • Also the systemicity of the anomaly explains exiles, as they are clearly over-powered compared to the rest, and are affected a certain degree of freedom. Indeed, the anomaly resides in the Matrix giving the ability to choose, and exiles show that not only humans can take advantage of the anomaly but also programs (ie, if you can choose, you can choose to not abide by the rules). – gaborous Jan 19 '17 at 14:02

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.