3

In ST:TNG "Aquiel", Geordi reaches into the drawer in his quarters pulls out a phaser, and fires it at the organism. Aren't hand weapons on the Enterprise disabled? Are all officers allowed to have hand weapons loaded and armed in their quarters?

  • I've had the name of the series changed so many times in so many posts. @N.Soong this is the first time I think that I've seen it done the way you edited it. Is there a set way that we are supposed to name Series, show, episode? If not why do people keep changing it? – JMFB May 13 '15 at 4:48
  • sorry I made a small mistake with that edit. I'll amend that edit to the way I've seen in most questions and personally use 😉 – Often Right May 13 '15 at 5:14
  • 2
    @N.Soong Wait, you use 😉 between ST and TNG? – Mr Lister May 13 '15 at 12:43
  • @MrLister lol 😝 – Often Right May 13 '15 at 22:49
6

If you'll allow me to quote from the (considered fully canon) "Star Trek: The Next Generation: Technical Manual", the simplest answer is yes, you can operate a hand-phaser on board the ship, but you need to be a a command officer or a senior security officer in order to legally override the phaser controls which automatically set themselves to stun.

Downstream from the power cell are three interconnected control modules: the beam control assembly, safety interlock, and subspace transceiver assembly (STA). The beam control assembly includes tactile interface buttons for configuring the phaser beam width and intensity, and a firing trigger. The safety interlock is a code processor for safing the power functions of the phaser and for personalizing a phaser for limited personnel use. Key-press combinations of beam width and intensity controls are used to configure the phaser's safety condition. The STA is used as part of the safety system while aboard Starfleet vessels. It maintains contact between the phaser and the ship computers to assure that power levels are automatically restrained during shipboard firings, usually limited to heavy stun. Emergency override commands may be keyed in by the beam controls.

As to why Geordi has a phaser in his quarters isn't really explained. Other officers do occasionally demonstrate that they keep weapons lying around (Picard evidently has one in his ready room and both Worf and Tasha (albeit both were Security officers) evidently kept them in their bedrooms) but I'd guess that the out-of-universe reason was simply that having him go to a weapons-locker and come back was an unnecessary 30 seconds of filming.

  • Really should get a copy of that manual ;) – Often Right May 13 '15 at 5:54
  • 1
    @n.soong - You really should. It's an amazing resource for the serious trek-enthusiast. The sheer amount of thought that's gone into creating a coherent fictional universe is frankly startling. – Valorum May 13 '15 at 7:26
  • Also, Data keeps a phaser in his quarters. We see it at one point where it is confiscated while Data is malfunctioning for a plot-related reason. – Columbia says Reinstate Monica Jul 2 '18 at 11:24
2

You seem to be asking two questions here:

  1. Are hand weapons on the Enterprise disabled?

    The answer to that is a resounding 'no'. Think about the number of times phaser battles have occurred on the Enterprise throughout. One prominent example that comes to mind is when Worf uses the phaser to disable the Borg in The Best of Both Worlds Pt I and in Brothers when Worf and the security team are using phasers against Data (although there are force-fields in place there).

  2. Are all officers allowed to have hand weapons loaded and armed in their quarters?

    I haven't found anything on this on Memory Alpha, but from observation of the series, you don't normally see people walking around with phasers, unless they're security officers (not that they seem to help them most of the time anyway :P). Furthermore, most of the time on away teams in TOS, equipment like phasers would be provided upon departure. I seem to recall something like this occurring in TNG, but I can't say exactly where unfortunately. Picard in The Battle had a phaser on him when he destroyed the sphere and I seem to recall that he also had a phaser when he was in his quarters when he was paranoid about being revisited. Consequently, I would speculate (my apologies) that only senior officers and security personnel would be able to hold armed weapons with them in their quarters.

  • I should have phrased it differently. If I edit the question, it'll be undone as it has in the past. Obviously, security officers can have weapons, which Worf is one of. Officers outside of security officers is what I meant to say. Geordi is an engineer, doesn't it seem peculiar that he keeps a phaser in his quarters? – JMFB May 13 '15 at 4:44
  • @JMFB go ahead and edit the question if you like; it shouldn't be edited if you're clarifying your question. If that does occur you should contact the editor and tell them why you used that particular wording. – Often Right May 13 '15 at 5:17
  • @JMFB regarding the point about other officers I do say that it stands to reason that high ranking officers can be armed based on other evidence in the series – Often Right May 13 '15 at 5:19

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.