In the first Agengers Assemble movie, Romanov states that she "has red on her ledger" because Fury sent Barton to kill her, but that Barton decided to spare her. She said she did not like having red on her ledger, and she needed to repay Barton so that she did not owe anyone anything anymore. She even went so far as to use the words "I've been compromised" to describe the debt to Barton which she wanted to eliminate so that she did not owe anything to anyone.

But then in Age of Ultron, Romanov thanks Banner for saving "her best friend" (Barton), and then we see that Romanov is the only one who knew of Clint's family, and that Clint even named his soon to be born child Nathaniel after Natasha.

So how did Natasha and Clint go from simply trying to erase a debt in the first movie to being best friends in the second movie?

I guess the change had mainly to do with Romanov, since Clint is so easy going, but I would just be guessing. Does anyone know from any other movies, tv shows, or in-universe comics?

  • I also appreciate the process Nat is in. No way, the MCU is just a bunch of superficial action movies without emotional depth on behalf of the characters. Nat is the best example, or let's say, her inner conflicts - shown in Ultron - are presented in a more subtle way than that of her love, Banner. See, how happy she is in the Hammer scene! She actually smiles happily, letting the audience participate with her feeling part of a family. Not her smirking like in Cap 2. But then the bad awakening! – user64221 Apr 4 '16 at 19:07

They were always close...

Well to start with, she and Barton were clearly close during Avengers 1, moreso than you seem to imply. It's true that she feels indebted to him, but they also act with quite a bit of tenderness after Barton sheds Loki's influence. They're clearly more than business partners, they're friends, or at least close companions.

enter image description here

That being said, you're right, Widow's side of the interaction seems substantially warmer during Age of Ultron than in the previous film.

...but Winter Soldier changed her attitude about friendship.

Black Widow's arc during the events of Captain America: The Winter Soldier revolved largely around her trust issues, and her unwillingness to believe that her teammates genuinely trust her. She opens up quite a bit to Rogers about her doubts, even her lack of self-awareness around her own nature and trustworthiness.

In that film, we see her toy with the idea that she might actually be able to have friends, not just brothers-in-arms. Then, when we pick up with her in Age of Ultron, she is pursuing a romantic relationship and acting much more warmly with Barton.

This isn't a coincidence.

It's never explicitly stated, but it's a reasonable assumption that Romanov continued her emotional exploration of friendship and trust between Winter Soldier and Age of Ultron, testing the waters of being less stand-off-ish with her squadmates and flirting (for real) with a cute guy on her team. We know that Cap was encouraging her in that effort (from their conversations in Winter Soldier and his bar-side chat with Banner in Age of Ultron). And for those who dislike the Hulk/Widow romance, it actually makes a good bit more sense when you factor in this multi-film arc: Romanov isn't just suddenly thrust into a romantic storyline, she's tentatively reaching out for the first time, and she naturally connected someone who also wrestles with crippling self-doubt.

One can easily imagine that Barton, who is always laid back and jovial, welcomed these first signs of Romanov's opening up, and encouraged the shift from coworker to genuine friend during the inter-film period.

  • 2
    This is the kind of answer I love to see - one that digs deep into the characters and their motivations, fully exploring their developments over multiple films. +1 – Dr R Dizzle Jun 9 '15 at 22:16
  • Any reason for the downvote? – Nerrolken Jun 11 '15 at 21:33

I don't believe there is an answer in the MCU currently, this is meant to be one of those things that happened before and we just found out about it.

That said, I think the premise of your question is wrong. Natasha went to talk to Loki specifically to interrogate him about his plans. All the things she said about her relationship with Clint were said to evoke a response out of Loki; I don't think we can take anything she said there as being entirely true, or at least not the whole truth.

Besides, even in the movie, and in her conversation with Loki, it's implied there's more than just a transaction in play. Loki guesses she cares about Clint as more than someone she's indebted to, hence why he threatens to have Clint kill her "intimately, in every way he knows you fear." But Loki (and the audience) guessed they were romantically involved, when it turned out that wasn't the case.


In the comics, Barton is employed under Stark and then begins committing crimes to impress Widow. Clint then ends up fighting Stark, but ends up employed under SHIELD instead. He is then sent to kill Nat, but can't bring himself to do so, and they end up in a sexual relationship for a short while, but then separate and become partners in their work, remaining best friends instead. At some point Clint meets his wife and has kids with her and Nat is still one of his best friends.


They totally were romantically involved until Bobbi Morse showed up. The 2 were worried that their romance would interfere with being an Avenger, so Hawkeye jumped to Bobbi (Mockingbird), got married - then divorced and got back together after forming the West Coast Avengers.

  • Could you add more details? In which ark dose that happen? – Gallifreyan Jan 29 '17 at 18:09

I believe that Natasha was captured by S.H.I.E.L.D. and Barton interrogated her, and promised that if she joined the good guys that she would be able to redeem herself of the people she's murdered, that she wouldn't ever be forced to do anything against her will. But hey, there's no proof.


I used to want Clint and Natasha to be cannon, but now I prefer them to be more of a best friend sort of cannon. I think that Clint was actually sent to kill her when she worked for the KGB, as threat to S.H.I.E.L.D. I think that he saw that Natasha had potential to be good, and just needed someone to be there for her, so he didn't kill her. I also believe its true she felt like she had to repay him, and I think he probably told her many times to just forget about it and move on, but she can't. Clint was probably one of the first people to open up, and love her for who she was. And for that she was grateful.

  • Hi, welcome to SF&F. Can you cite any evidence for this theory? – DavidW Jan 9 '20 at 3:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.