11

From the text of the Akallabêth, it is clear that following the creation of Númenor, the "Ban of the Valar" forbade the Edain from sailing anywhere near Aman, or even Tol Eressëa. And the earlier portions of The Silmarillion make it clear that, for quite some time, the rebellious Ñoldor were likewise forbidden from returning to Aman. However, the question of whether men were ever permitted to approach Aman is far less obvious.

When Eärendil arrives in Aman to ask for the help of the Valar, most of them aren't very happy. Mandos makes a thinly veiled suggestion that the Valar should kill him rather than allow a "mortal man" to set foot in the Undying Lands. Of course, Eärendil is actually half Elf and half human, and the Ñoldorin Elf part of his heritage unquestionably denies him access to the Undying Lands, but it seems significant that Mandos specifically referred to him as a "mortal man" before the issue of his Ñoldorin ancestry is raised.

I don't recall reading anything to suggest that men were always banned from Aman, but Mandos' words seem to imply that a ban was already in place; if I'm not mistaken, the first reference to such a law occurs in the Akallabêth, after the creation of Númenor. Did I miss something here? Was there always a law forbidding humans from traveling to the Undying Lands?


Note: While the title of the question "Since when did Eru forbid men from going to the undying land?" is similar to the intent of this question, the actual content of that question is wildly different; despite the title, it actually asks about some sort of hostility shown by the Valar towards men. The question and the answers to it don't address the issues I raise here, and as far as content is concerned, there is almost no similarity between the two. I couldn't get the kind of answer I'm looking for from that question without changing it so much that it had no relation to the OP's intentions in asking it.

  • 1
    Why the downvote for this question? – Often Right Jun 25 '15 at 6:47
  • @N_Soong - I was wondering the same thing. – Wad Cheber Jun 25 '15 at 6:52
  • I can't recall any mention of Men being prohibited from travelling to Valinor before the creation of Numenor. However, I have not read the History of Middle-eart series of books. Perhaps there is something pertaining to the ban in there. – maguirenumber6 Jun 25 '15 at 13:29
5

In response to the Two Trees being destroyed by Morgoth (with his accomplice Ungoliant) and the Noldor rebelling and leaving Aman, the events called "the Hiding of Valinor" took place. The Valar raised huge monutains all around their land (leaving only the path from Tirion), and setting the Magic Islands and Shadowy Seas between Tol Eressea and the Great Lands. In these waters were dark rocks wrapped in mist, and in the twilight any mariner would grow weary and loathe the sea. If a sailor reached one of the isles he would sleep until the world was changed. - The Silmarillion, "Quenta Silmarillion: Of the Sun and Moon and the Hiding of Valinor"

http://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Enchanted_Isles

http://tolkiengateway.net/wiki/Shadowy_Seas

Thus, the way to Aman was closed to anyone not authorised by the Valar, including men. It was only Earendil's Silmaril that allegedly allowed him to sail past the Shadowy Seas and the Magic Isles to reach Valinor.

I think it's safe to say that (in the established canon) men were never meant to be in Valinor in the first place, although the earliest version of the legendarium (The Book of Lost Tales) suggests that certain number of men could live in Valinor after they died, and that living children of men could visit Valinor in their dreams. But that is a story for a different question :)

  • Great answer, thank you, and +1. – Wad Cheber Jun 25 '15 at 22:47

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.