I'm desperately looking for a science fiction short story I read in the 80s (or maybe 90s, my memory is not the best). I remember the main story line was about the job interview of a worker, who dreamt about getting a job operating some nice sounding devices here or there. At the end, he got suspicious about the reactions of his employers, and fears that he is not up to the challenge and doesn't get any job.

Instead, the interviewers find that he is much too smart to operate those machines, he will be hired to design/engineer new machines.

So, I think the distinction between operators/users and creators/engineers was the main focus of the story, not brain analysys, not colonies.

The story was in a pretty lonesome setting without dialog with other people, mainly the protagonists sharing his thoughts about the job interview.

Any pointers would be greatly appreciated!

  • I'm fairly sure this a dupe.
    – Valorum
    Commented Jul 12, 2015 at 21:39
  • How is this fantasy or science fiction? Did you read it in a science fiction magazine or collection?
    – user14111
    Commented Jul 12, 2015 at 22:18
  • @user14111 - I'm fairly sure this is an Asimov (or similar Golden age) story.
    – Valorum
    Commented Jul 12, 2015 at 22:35
  • @Richard The description is vaguely reminiscent of Asimov's "Profession", is that what you're referring to?
    – user14111
    Commented Jul 12, 2015 at 23:42
  • @user14111 - Yes. That's the one I was thinking of.
    – Valorum
    Commented Jul 12, 2015 at 23:44

1 Answer 1


Your description is vaguely reminiscent of Isaac Asimov novella "Profession", which has appeared in a number of publications; first published in Astounding Science Fiction, July 1957, available at the Internet Archive. It has come up before as an answer on this site. You can read it here. The following plot summary of "Profession" is from its Wikipedia page:

The author presents a centralized Earth society of the sixty-sixth century, in which children are educated by almost instantaneous direct computer/brain interface, a process known as taping. This system is similar to the BrainCap, a concept later explored by Arthur C. Clarke. Besides educating its own people this way, Earth also supplies educated professionals to other planets, the Outworlds

Persons in this future society are taught to read at the age of eight and then Educated at the age of eighteen. Each's professional speciality is dictated by an analysis of his or her brain, with no choices allowed to the subject. The best of the Educated people compete in professional "Olympics" in the hope of being "bought" by an advanced Outworld. To stay on Earth is almost an admission of failure.

George Platen is determined to be a Computer Programmer, a profession in demand, and he hopes to qualify for "export" to a top-flight Outworld. On Reading Day, however, concerns are raised about George's ability to be Educated. On George's Education Day, he is told that his brain is unfit for any form of Education. He is drugged and sent to a House for the Feeble Minded.

Although not under physical guard, George stays in the House for a year, where the staff tolerates, even encourages his philosophical and intellectual ruminations as a way to pass the time. He is befriended by Omani, who seems to take a personal interest in George's plight. George then determines to escape, to leave and seek out Dr. Antonelli who told him he was feeble-minded, and confront him.

On the lam, George visits the Olympics, which are happening in San Francisco at that time. He meets his primary schoolmate Trevelyan, who has been Taped as a Metallurgist, Nonferrous. Trev is excited about his opportunities but performs poorly on the Beeman spectrograph—his Taping was inadequate regarding the new device—and he is forced to take employment on a fourth-rate Outworld. George, watching Trev bitterly depart, wishes him well. Trev turns and sarcastically asks, "Well, what have you done?" He then shakes George. A passing policeman breaks up the scuffle and asks George for his identity card. His ruse is up, he will be exposed as an Uneducated escapee.

Suddenly a stranger appears. He gives the policeman his business card and takes possession of George. The stranger introduces himself as Ladislas Ingenescu, Registered Historian. George and Ingenescu enter into a long conversation about history, society, and progress. George impatiently demands and Ingenescu obtains for him an interview with a Novian, an Outworlder on Earth to purchase talent. The Outworlder knows Ingenescu personally. He expresses anger at the Registered Historian (why to a Registered Historian, George wonders?) over Earth continually introducing very minor changes to the Tapes—such as the recent addition of the Beeman spectrograph for Metallurgists—necessitating the Outworlds to keep spending money to stay up to date. The Registered Historian introduces George as someone who thinks he may have a better solution. George contends that people can learn in ways other than being Taped, such as by reading books and in discussion with those who already hold the desired knowledge. This baffles the Outworlder, who sees it only as a source of additional expense. He breaks off their conversation. George is dismayed; the Registered Historian offers condolences.

George is returned to the House and discovers the reality: the House is an Institute of Higher Studies. Those people who have the urge and persistence to create, even though they have been told otherwise about their abilities, are sent there to support the advancement of science and civilization. George has always been under constant observation, and it was subtly but deliberately suggested that he escape and seek out the doctor who sent him there. Reflecting on his experiences "outside," George realizes that a man named Beeman would have to have been the inventor of the Beeman spectrograph. Beeman could not have been Tape-educated and still have created the new device. Someone has to program the Tapes that program the Educated, "men and women with capacity for original thought." George's "keepers" in the Institute are revealed as sociologists, psychologists, historians, scientists, and other professionals who also demonstrated an innate capacity for original thought but not the stamina to keep fighting to express it. Their job is to help other determined, innovators like George–a small fraction–to avoid the same fate. The future of society is at stake.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.