After encountering an alien space probe Picard awakes in a new life where he has a wife, a job, a hobby, and best friend. Over time he grows to accept these things, but would he have been able to choose otherwise?

Was he constrained to the simulation the aliens wanted him to play out?

3 Answers 3


He demonstrates a certain amount of free will in terms of what he says and his memories, so the control over him is not complete. They could have just taken over to the point of blocking memories of the past and substituting their own constructed past so he'd remember growing up on their planet. They didn't, so they did allow him to keep an awareness of his life and even to talk about it with the constructed characters in the simulation.

With that awareness, especially in a person with a will as strong as Jean-Luc Picards, freedom of movement and thought would be extremely important. There'd have to be freedom of two different types. The first would be freedom of movement. He'd have to be able to explore and not feel trapped. He'd also have to be able to accept or decline invitations or actions. For instance, if they invited him to their planet's equivalent of WWF, it's like Jean-Luc Picard would have insisted on declining so he could read a book on poetry.

It would be like our Interstates. You have a general route like, say, I-95 going from Maine to Florida, but you might get off on the side roads, or stop at rest stops, or take extra time to stop in Washington, D.C. on the way down to Florida so you can see the museums, but, in the long run, the road and the side roads all lead to the same place (in this case, the launching of the probe).

It's likely they had optional routines in the program to set the probe launch event at different points. If, after five years, he was getting too restless, they could have led up to the probe launch at that time, but the longer the time in the scenario, the better he'd remember the people and the culture.

Notice that he arrived in the scenario after he would have had children and all the characters were in place already (other than his grandchild, which was the result of other characters' behavior and not his). So the scenario didn't depend too heavily on him marrying or having children or picking a job or career.

As long as he stayed in the community, there was still ample "play" in the scenario for him to have the experiences they wanted him to have.

The part I never figured out is how wide a geographical area they let him explore. I would think they'd have wanted to have as much of the planet mapped out for a visitor like him as they could.

They also seemed to have other characters ready to work with him and to calm him down if he were to get unruly. Notice the others didn't overreact to him when he talked about life on the Enterprise but seemed to know more about guiding him than pushing him around. I'm sure that's a pattern that was ready to come into play anywhere in the simulation when needed. (And if they had to take him to the hospital and give him a psychotropic drug, I'm sure that would work much better than restricting his choice and not letting him go places or forcing him to play along - especially with any strong willed person.)

  • 1
    I saw it as an "on-rails" video game. It may look like you're able to make decisions but the endpoint is always identical. The story in "TNG : The Royale" was a similar situation.
    – Valorum
    Feb 23, 2015 at 23:16
  • 2
    I believe you have an incorrect statement. Picard had no children at the beginning of the simulation. He only had a wife. There's a very poignant scene where he discusses having their first child with her. (He talks about building on a new room for the child.) Other than that, great answer.
    – jpmc26
    May 20, 2015 at 14:15

The point for for him to experience the society, not any particular life. He could have done anything he wanted. This isn't what the probe-builders would have wanted, but it wasn't in their nature to force anyone to do/experience anything.

  • 2
    "...it wasn't in their nature to force anyone to do/experience anything." Really? They forced Picard to experience an entire lifetime!
    – gnovice
    Jan 23, 2012 at 17:37
  • 2
    I guess I meant they wanted him to experience it as himself, not as an automaton with no free will. Not sure how to word that distinction... Jan 23, 2012 at 18:28

I think the imposed scenario had to be adapted to the person whose mind was being invaded. Imagine if the probe had encountered the Pakleds, for example. I don't know what scenario the probe would have come up with for them, but it wouldn't have been the one Picard had. So I think Picard had free will, but the probe modeled his brain well enough to predict how he would behave. It then put him in a situation where he would eventually accept the new world he lived in, and fully experience the culture.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.