2

I've started watching Batman: The Animated Series and I'm into the second season, I believe. There is an episode where Robin says that people call Batman "The Dark Knight", but I don't recall a time in that series where anyone has said that. When does someone (specifically in this series) refer to Batman as "The Dark Knight"?

  • Batman has been called the Dark Knight for many, many years in the comics. Probably since shortly after his first appearance. – Wad Cheber Jul 20 '15 at 22:51
  • 1
    I'm wondering for this animated series specifically – cocoa Jul 20 '15 at 22:53
  • It's not in-universe, but there is the episode of The New Batman Adventures called "Legends of the Dark Knight". Can't remember if he gets referred to by that name in the episode though – Jason Baker Jul 21 '15 at 2:09
  • I don't know but it is an even better description of the character than Batman. – kaine Jul 21 '15 at 13:18
  • @Wad Cheber - I don't think the term goes back as far as his first appearance--it became really popular with Frank Miller's comic "The Dark Knight Returns", and this wikipedia article says Miller chose the title 'based upon him being called the "Darknight Detective" in some 1970s portrayals.' Of course uncited claims in wikipedia aren't necessarily correct, but if the term was widely used earlier I'd think some comic fan would correct this statement. – Hypnosifl Jul 21 '15 at 14:25
8

I found a set of transcripts of Batman: The Animated Series here, and used command-F (control-F on a PC) to search for "Dark Knight" in them. The episodes are listed out-of-order on that page, but looking at the production order here, it seems the term was first used in episode 15 of the first season, "The Cat and the Claw", when Catwoman said "So long, Dark Knight." It was also used in some other first-season episodes:

  • In episode 18, "Beware the Gray Ghost", the Mad Bomber (a toy collector) says "Well, if it isn't the Dark Knight himself."

  • In episode 22, "Joker's Favor", a character named Charlie says to the Joker "This is how it ends, Joker. No big schemes. No grand fight to the finish with the Dark Knight. Tomorrow, all the papers will say is that the great Joker was found blown to bits in an alley alongside a miserable little nobody."

  • In episode 46, "Almost Got 'im", the Joker recounts a story in which he had captured Batman and put him on a phony talk show, where he introduced him with the line "We've got a real treat for you, kids. I ran into my first guest last night while making a withdrawal from the bank. You know him as 'the dark knight,' but we prefer to think of him as history. Here he is, the one and only Batman."

  • In episode 48, "What is Reality?", Edward Nygma said "They call you the Dark Knight. Then you have to move like a knight."

The term didn't originated in the series though, it had been used in the comics previously. Prior to Christopher Nolan's film The Dark Knight, most people who knew the term would probably have associated it with Frank Miller's comic series The Dark Knight Returns, which became one of the best-selling graphic novels of all time. Miller's wikipedia page says 'Miller created a tough, gritty Batman, referring to him as "The Dark Knight" based upon him being called the "Darknight Detective" in some 1970s portrayals.' Someone on this reddit thread suggests the term "Darknight Detective" probably was invented by Batman comic writer Denny O'Neil in the 1970s. The book Hunting The Dark Knight: Twenty-First Century Batman refers on p. xii (viewable on google books here) to '"Denny O'Neil and Neal Adams' 'Darknight Detective' of the 1970s"', and another book on the history of Batman, Batman Unauthorized: Vigilantes, Jokers, and Heroes in Gotham City says on p. 20 (viewable on google books here):

However, it was as the camp television show was in its final days that a writer named Denny O'Neil (born in the same month and year as Batman himself, May 1939) took over the reigns of the comic book and changed everything. Partnering with the soon-to-be-legendary artist Neal Adams, who brought a hitherto unseen level of realism to the depiction of superheroes, O'Neil revamped the Batman legend, either reinventing the character or returning it to its 1939 roots, depending on your perspective. Robin (who was previously presumed to be thirteen) was swiftly aged and sent off to college. Gone mostly were the costumed villains, replaced by international terrorists, corrupt politicians, and mafia bosses. O'Neil's Batman was a Darknight Detective—emphasis on "detective"—more akin to Sherlock Holmes than a superhero, who employed his wits and credible criminology methods in the apprehension of evildoers.

And here is a comic from 1982 which uses "Darknight Detective" for a title.

edit: Thanks to JC2k8, who notes that this wikipedia article says the name "Dark Knight" actually dates to the first standalone Batman comic (after his initial origin in Detective Comics), Batman No. 1, from 1940. It seems it was in the debut story of the Joker, which is posted on this site...below is the final panel on this page from that story (it was recently posted on the twitter feed of Marc T. Nobleman, who wrote the book Bill the Boy Wonder about Batman co-creater Bill Finger that was referenced in the wikipedia article):

enter image description here

Perhaps the term had been out of usage for a long time before Denny O'Neil brought it back for his more gritty take on Batman?

  • 2
    Addendum: The term Dark Knight was coined in Batman No. 1 in 1940, according do Wikipedia, in a story written by Bill Finger. – JC2k8 Jul 22 '15 at 16:27
  • "the very first episode "The Cat and the Claw"" - Are you really sure that is the very first episode of The Animated Series (or maybe that isn't what you're saying in that sentence?)? – TARS Jul 22 '15 at 16:46
  • @TARS - It was listed first on the page but I see they're listed out-of-order there, I've corrected that sentence. – Hypnosifl Jul 22 '15 at 16:52
  • Awesome answer! Thanks so much! – cocoa Jul 22 '15 at 16:52

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.