52

In the 1977 animated film version of the Hobbit, the dragon Smaug is drawn similar to a cat- the shape of his head is distinctly feline (complete with whiskers), and his posture when awoken from his rest by Bilbo is reminiscent of a housecat coming out of a nap- does this not seem an odd choice to depict a dragon?

  • 8
    'Cos they wanted to? – Ben Jul 22 '15 at 1:00
  • 62
    Just speculation but maybe the animators used a live cat as a model since they couldn't get a dragon to cooperate. – Whovian4Life Jul 22 '15 at 1:35
  • 6
    Just so you know, this question had me digging up interviews from 1977 regarding a movie that most people don't know about. They weren't very easy to find. I had to do a good bit of snooping around. But at least I finally found the answer. :) – Wad Cheber Jul 22 '15 at 4:09
  • 8
    Doesn't seem odd to me at all. Isn't that how you'd imagine a dragon? "Toothless" from "How to train your dragon" is basically a cat that can fly and breath fire. – AndreKR Jul 22 '15 at 5:59
  • 22
    @Whovian4Life if I know cats, you have better chances finding a cooperative dragon than a cooperative cat. – overactor Jul 22 '15 at 13:30
114

The appearance of Smaug in the 1977 Rankin-Bass adaptation of The Hobbit was the result of artistic license and the nationality of the animators. The animation team was from Japan, and they depicted Smaug as a sort of hybrid of western dragons and Japanese dragons. However, Tolkien does make at least one reference to catlike traits when describing Smaug.

[Smaug's snoring was] "like the noise of a large pot galloping in the fire, mixed with the rumble of a gigantic tom-cat purring"
- The Hobbit, Inside Information

enter image description here
Smaug as depicted in the 1971 animated film The Hobbit

Tolkien Gateway describes this version of Smaug as follows:

In this version, Smaug is broadly similar in size and colour but his shape is less elongated due to being more weighty. Smaug's face is rounder, possessing more mammalian traits - resembling a mix between a cat and a bat - having bat-like ears and fur around the face and down the back.

Furthermore, even in Tolkien's description, Smaug carries himself in much the same way a cat would: he is proud, independent, aloof, and inscrutable. The way he stretches after waking up is not, however, a uniquely feline quality - my own dog, a yellow lab, does exactly the same thing upon waking up in the morning.

More generally, some traditional depictions of dragons are very similar to traditional depictions of cats - or at least lions. This is especially true of Celtic imagery:

enter image description here
Traditional Celtic depiction of a dragon (or is it a lion?)

In the medieval illuminated manuscript known as The Book of Kells, the dragons and lions are almost indistinguishable from each other (presumably because the artists, who lived in Ireland their whole lives, had never seen a dragon - or any other kind of reptile - or a lion):

enter image description here
enter image description here
Dragons in The Book of Kells

enter image description here
Lions in The Book of Kells


Update:

I finally found the answer. I just stumbled across this blurb in a review of the recently released DVD of the Rankin-Bass Hobbit movie:

The adaptation is mated to beautiful artwork in both the painted backgrounds, a hybrid of Tolkien’s illustrations and the paintings of Arthur Rackham; and in the animation, which was the first of many collaborations between Rankin-Bass and the Japanese animation studio Topcraft (which would eventually evolve into Studio Ghibli). At the time, the character design and animation drew some criticism, since it was so radically different from conventional American animation. Today, of course, anime has penetrated American animation to such a degree, both as an import and as a stylistic influence, that The Hobbit now seems ahead of its time.

The best designs are easily those for Gollum and Smaug, both of whom are singularly captivating and exude entirely different kinds of menace to Bilbo and his companions.

Source

This gives us a crucial bit of information: the animation team was Japanese. What do Japanese dragons look like? Like this:

enter image description here enter image description here enter image description here

Note the fur around the face, and in some cases, running down the dragon's back. Very similar to Smaug's appearance in this concept art from the movie, although the artists clearly modernized and "cartoonified" him a great deal:

enter image description here

enter image description here

Another dragon drawn by the animators at Studio Topcraft/Studio Ghibli is relatively similar to Smaug, further implying that this is simply the way they draw dragons.

enter image description here

Although dragons are typically conceived as being purely reptilian in western culture (i.e., all scales, no fur) the idea that dragons have at least some fur is a common motif in Asian cultures:

enter image description here
Vietnamese dragons

enter image description here
Chinese dragon

The Chinese dragon appears to have had a significant influence on the Japanese dragon. The Han Dynasty (206 BCE - 220 CE) scholar Wang Fu wrote, of traditional Chinese dragon imagery:

The people paint the dragon's shape with a horse's head and a snake's tail. Further, there are expressions as 'three joints' and 'nine resemblances' (of the dragon), to wit: from head to shoulder, from shoulder to breast, from breast to tail. These are the joints; as to the nine resemblances, they are the following: his antlers resemble those of a stag, his head that of a camel, his eyes those of a demon, his neck that of a snake, his belly that of a clam (shen, 蜃), his scales those of a carp, his claws those of an eagle, his soles those of a tiger, his ears those of a cow. Upon his head he has a thing like a broad eminence (a big lump), called [chimu] (尺木). If a dragon has no [chimu], he cannot ascend to the sky.

So the answer appears to be that he probably wasn't modeled on a cat*, he was modeled on traditional Japanese dragons, which have fur.

*In a fairly exhaustive attempt to find an answer to this question, I didn't come across so much as a single reference to cats from anyone associated with the film. The one clear reference I did find was in a discussion about Smaug as depicted in various adaptations, from the Tolkien Gateway entry quoted above; it is mere opinion, however, and is written by someone who just happens to have seen the movie, rather than someone involved in producing it. As far as I was able to determine, no evidence of a deliberate resemblance between Smaug and cats exists.


The Tolkien fan site "Periannath" offers this amusing take on the Rankin-Bass version of Smaug, which is worth sharing here, as it is at least somewhat relevant:

enter image description here

  • 1
    Your answers are getting lo... More comprehensive than Thaddeus' – AncientSwordRage Jul 3 '16 at 20:15
  • Awesome answer. The artwork alone is amazing but it obviously took a lot of time and effort to write. Actually I bookmarked this page because of the artwork. – Pryftan Feb 21 '18 at 1:58
-1

The extended version of The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug, which also includes special features, has clips that were specifically about the creation of Smaug in the film where they also did say that cats have unpredictable temperament, so I'm guessing it's not just in the cartoon version they based it on. It also did apply in the film (although it was mentioned briefly).

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.