I think it is a lighter, this references a scene in BSG where Bill Adama lends Lee a lighter which belonged to his father, I assume it is the same one. I'm not exactly sure which episode it is but I suspect it's The 'Hand of God' S1E10. If not is its in similar circumstances before a dangerous mission, Lee returns it to Bill when get gets back safely.

Only top voted, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible