Hot answers tagged

105 votes
Accepted

Why did J. K. Rowling choose to downplay dragons?

She didn't choose to violate genre conventions. She doesn't read fantasy in the first place, and Harry Potter wasn't intended as a (high) fantasy. In an interview with The New York Times, J. K. ...
  • 9,363
94 votes
Accepted

Tolkien calls Sauron Morgoth's Greatest Servant - But does he ever really earn that with his actions?

Who is more powerful, the President of the United States or the marine guarding him? In personal one-on-one combat I'm certain the marine would defeat the President. However, it is the President ...
  • 5,576
72 votes
Accepted

What was Sirius' way of tackling dragons?

We find out later in the book, when Sirius writes to Harry after the task: Congratulations on getting past the Horntail. Whoever put your name in that goblet shouldn’t be feeling too happy right now! ...
  • 102k
67 votes
Accepted

What's the origin of the trope that dragons used to be common but aren't any more?

The idea that dragons were once numerous, but are no longer, is just one of many manifestations of what TV Tropes calls the "The Magic Goes Away" (named for the Larry Niven story). It is ...
  • 89.7k
52 votes

Why did J. K. Rowling choose to downplay dragons?

Dragons in Harry Potter are indeed powerful. Though it’s true that dragons were used in one of the tasks of the Triwizard Tournament competed in by schoolchildren, dragons were shown to be powerful ...
  • 105k
50 votes
Accepted

Books about dragons and war from a cat-loving author

It sounds like Eragon by Christopher Paolini. Published in 2003 but it looks like the German translation wasn't published until 2009. The film was 2006. Eragon finds a dragon egg and it hatches. ...
  • 2,035
49 votes

What's the origin of the trope that dragons used to be common but aren't any more?

I think this is inspired by real life. Consider that where I live — the island of Ireland — was once a habitat for elk, wolves, wild cows and many species of deer. Over the last thousands of years ...
47 votes

Wouldn't this dragon have a lot of trouble flying?

It's likewise impossible for zombies to walk with no blood pumping through their veins and no way for them to move huge distances with no source of energy, nor does it make sense that they could run, ...
  • 38.7k
42 votes
Accepted

Wouldn't this dragon have a lot of trouble flying?

Magic is not the answer (in this case) Magic is not the correct answer here, in my opinion. There are many things about the dragons that can be answered by magic: How Viserion was born from a ...
  • 8,146
42 votes
Accepted

Is there any mention of the absolute ceiling of dragons?

No there is no such mention in neither books nor the show. It is unlikely there would be any mention either as: Dragons vary in their strength, agility and endurance so one definite answer is not ...
  • 47.7k
41 votes
Accepted

Which dragon did we see in S07E06?

The closed captions indicate that it was Viserion. Daenerys watches as Viserion flies by screaming after having been hit.
  • 133k
33 votes
Accepted

How did demolishing the bridge to the lake town Esgaroth help against Smaug’s attack?

You have to read the whole passage. Specifically: ... his enemies were on an island in deep water too deep and dark and cool for his liking. Smaug could fly and would likely initially attack from ...
  • 5,101
32 votes
Accepted

How many dragons ever existed in Westeros?

Number of Dragons in Westeros In Westeros Dragons first came with Targaryen invaders. There were three of those dragons: Balerion the Black Dread Vhagar Meraxes In reign of King Viserys I, ...
  • 47.7k
31 votes
Accepted

Why are there no other dragons in ASOIAF?

Flawed Premise In order to hatch a dragon in A Song of Ice and Fire, the eggs must be heated to an incredible heat Who said that? Dragon incubators do not exist in Planetos. Hatching a dragon ...
  • 47.7k
27 votes
Accepted

What types of dragons are there in Middle-earth and how and why do they differ?

There were Fire-drakes and Cold-drakes The first fire-drake to issue from the gates of Angband was Glaurung; he was said to have sired the other fire-drakes and they are also the most common. Again ...
  • 75.7k
26 votes

Tolkien calls Sauron Morgoth's Greatest Servant - But does he ever really earn that with his actions?

Things Sauron managed to pull off: Leading the greatest Men on the planet, the ones most beloved of the Valar, Eldar, and presumably Eru as well, astray, leading to the damnation of pretty much all ...
  • 67.8k
25 votes

Tolkien calls Sauron Morgoth's Greatest Servant - But does he ever really earn that with his actions?

Since you invite challenges to your premise, I'm going to offer some. How controlling is the context? You make a lot of "But Tolkien is talking about Sauron in the context of a servant", and use the ...
25 votes
Accepted

Was it Ice or Fire?

As Dawny33 speculated, and speculated correctly. It was fire. This is confirmed in an interview by The Huffington Post with director of the episode "Dragon and the Wolf", Jeremy Podeswa, when asking ...
  • 75.7k
25 votes
Accepted

Identify the background image of a dragon from this book cover

The user "88grzes" on Deviant Art claims to be original artist of the image and as posted it here calling it "Baptism of Fire". Along with the image they also have the following description. Thanks ...
  • 143k
24 votes

Book about dragons and time travel

This is one or more of the novels in Anne McCaffrey's Dragonriders of Pern series, which began in 1967. The characters in these novels can travel through time while riding their dragons. The ...
  • 110k
24 votes

Was it Ice or Fire?

It is fire The thing which the dragon was breathing radiates like flames, which only fire can do. Never seen any creature in Scifi breathing ice which radiates flames Also, one can clearly see black ...
  • 3,520
23 votes
Accepted

Was Balerion three thousand or two hundred years old?

There is no explicit age given. But Barristan Selmy's guess seems to be a good one. There is no reason to believe that oldest MUST mean it is also the biggest. Not all the dragons would have died at ...
  • 75.7k
22 votes
Accepted

Name/Author of story of heart surgeon who corrects alligator hearts and makes dragons

This is The Day of the Dragon, by Guy Endore. (He's credited as "Guy Endor" in the linked reproduction but appears as "Endore" on Wikipedia and IMDb.) A Professor Crabshaw endeavors to cure alligators'...
  • 6,493
21 votes
Accepted

Movie in which two men ask a dragon three questions

I think this may be the Earthsea miniseries. With the help of Ogion, Ged confronts the Gebbeth and attempts to drown him using a rock, however, it escapes with Ged's likeness and voice. Ged's ...
  • 201k
18 votes
Accepted

Where did the notion that Dragons could speak originate?

TL;DR: The oldest mention of a talking dragon would be from Chinese mythology. It's important to note that the modern concept of dragons is an amalgamation of two primary sources - the European "...
  • 62.3k
18 votes
Accepted

How smart are the dragons in Game of Thrones?

There's very little information in the books you can use to determine their intelligence. Even if a dragon did something very smart (like attacking Danys enemies and not her friends), you could argue ...
  • 2,856
18 votes
Accepted

Towards the end of Game of Thrones season 7, has Drogon become larger than Balerion was?

Balerion seems to be bigger - just compare the skull of Balerion to the head of Drogon: Cersei next to Balerion skull Jon next to Drogon But keep in mind that Balerion is much older than Drogon, ...
  • 8,211
18 votes

Novel where a girl, Sre, hatches a dragon, Blue, to defend her from an innkeeper

It looks like this book was The Dragon Tamer, by Cly Novak. This answer is largely based on a public forum post (NSFW, possible trigger warning too) that carries elements similar to what you describe....
  • 34.7k

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible